[arcura]

The Whys of ´Fish Eaters´

By Sonja Corbitt
2/20/2010

BETHPAGE , TN (Catholic Online) - As a Catholic I am often asked by non-Catholics why we eat fish on Fridays during Lent. Until I was Catholic, it never occurred to me that the Filet-O-Fish® sandwich is not an ordinary staple at McDonald´s except in the spring, or that the sudden flurry of Red Lobster commercials just before Easter was similarly calculated. Where does this traditional Catholic practice originate?

Christ Eaters

The fish was one of the most important Christian symbols of the early Church. In a political and religious climate often fatal to them, the fish was a secret symbol used to identify Christian brothers and to mark Christian meeting places and tombs.

Ichthys is Greek for fish. Its letters, dissembled, correspond to the first letters of each of the words in the ancient Christian phrase, "Jesus Christ, God's Son, Savior." It was an acrostic in ancient Greek that helped the early Christians survive martyrdom and that often appears in first century catacombs in Rome .

The fish enjoys Scriptural prominence too. Several apostles were fishermen, called to be "fishers of men"; Jonah was swallowed by a fish and became symbolic of the resurrected Christ; Peter found coin for the temple tax in a fish´s mouth at Jesus´ command; it was said the Judgment will be like sorting one´s catch for the day. In the miracle of the loaves and fishes, the fish was symbolic of the Eucharist, so that "fish eaters" were ichthys eaters, or those who "ate Christ."

Because of early Christian use of its symbolism, the fish is strongly symbolic of Christ and the apostles, but second century Christians continued the practice and symbolism. Clement of Alexandria advised Christians to use a dove or fish symbol for their seal, and when writing on baptism, Tertullian said, "But we, being little fishes, as Jesus Christ is our great Fish, begin our life in the [baptismal] water, and only while we abide in the water are we safe and sound" (De Baptismate, i).

Fish Eaters

But "fish eating" was not to remain merely symbolic, although it would always be distinctly Catholic. At the time of Christ's Incarnation, in the first century, Jews were accustomed to fasting as a spiritual discipline; they fasted or abstained on Mondays and Thursdays. The early Christians, to show participation in Christ´s suffering and unity with Him, moved the fast days to Wednesdays and Fridays, because Judas betrayed Jesus on a Wednesday and Jesus was crucified on a Friday.

Thereafter, Wednesday and Friday fasts were a universal Catholic custom, one which Eastern Catholics and Orthodox continue to observe. It evolved over the centuries into the practice of "No Meat Fridays" in which, as a spiritual discipline, Catholics did not do without food altogether, they just gave up meat.

In the Palestinian area where Jesus and the apostles lived, and from that time period until recent history, fish was the easiest to come by. Other "meat" was a luxury for which only the rich had the means: the money required to buy meat or land on which to raise herds. Fish, however, was a common staple, as easy as a stream and a line, and so it became symbolic of humility and poverty.

Later, the term " was a luxury for which only the rich had the means: the money required to buy meat or land on which to raise herds. Fish, however, was a common staple, as easy as a stream and a line, and so it became symbolic of humility and poverty.

Later, the term " became an insult, because one of the main cultural practices that set early Protestant American settlers apart from Catholics was their Friday fast. First lobbed at Catholics by Dutch Protestants (to which Catholics retaliated with "cheese-eater" became an insult, because one of the main cultural practices that set early Protestant American settlers apart from Catholics was their Friday fast. First lobbed at Catholics by Dutch Protestants (to which Catholics retaliated with "enmity against God: for [they are] not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be") it remains an anti-Catholic slur in some circles to this day.

The Lenten Fast

Although they continue in the East, weekly fasts have died out in the west for several reasons. Westerners are more hedonistic and often simply do not care that they are ruled by their flesh to the destruction of their spirits. Most of us consider our recreation and luxuries as necessities.

Also, the regulations for fasting are set by the bishops and vary by location. Dinner at Red Lobster or even Captain D´s hardly lives up to the ascetic spirit of a fast. For these reasons many western bishops relaxed the fasts because the ascetic spirit remained unobserved.

But Lenten fasting and abstinence remains even where Friday and/or Wednesday fasting has been abandoned. There are traditionally forty days in Lent which are marked by fasting. The idea was, and still is, to do without the luxuries in life, both foods and festivities, and to engage in acts of penance. Traditionally, those penances are prayer (justice to God), fasting (justice to one´s self), and almsgiving (justice to one´s neighbor).

One who gains mastery over his appetites, gains mastery over his flesh. The struggle against disordered appetites and passions of the flesh should anchor one in prayer, and is a prerequisite for spiritual progress, because fleshly appetites and passions are "flesh of an animal."

On Ash Wednesday and Lenten Fridays of fasting and abstinence, fish is traditional along with vegetables and meatless soups. Sundays are always free of fasting and abstinence, even in the heart of Lent, because Sunday is a weekly feast day in honor of Resurrection joy. The Lenten schedule of fasting and abstinence ends after the Vigil Mass of Holy Saturday.

[justcurious55]

Thanks acura. A coworked and I were actually just talking about this the other day and neither of us understood it at all. Now I do :)

[arcura]

justcurious55,
I'm pleased that it was helpful to you.
Peace and kindness,
Fred

[Clough]

That was interesting and informative, Fred!

Thanks!

[arcura]

Clough,
You're welcome.
Peace and kindness,
Fred

[JoeCanada76]

I grew up Roman Catholic, and Fish on Good Friday is a good tradition. The thing is sometimes now I find many people do not follow that tradition.

I remember rest of the family eating meat. I did not want to. Remember having a dream that there were three crosses. I was observing what was going on but also one of them that was on the cross. It was a very vivid dream as a teenager and it moved me a lot.

There is so many reasons for eating fish on Friday has so many reasons. It means several different things to me personally.

Thank you for sharing with us Fred, and actually quite enjoyed this thread so far.

Oh and by the way Fred that other site you showed me a while back still have to look at it but I honestly do not think it appeals to me.

[arcura]

Jesushelper76,
Thanks for your post and story.
I liked it.
Good for you.
Peace and kindness,
Fred