Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    kittekat's Avatar
    kittekat Posts: 5, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Oct 8, 2008, 04:56 AM
    Repair or Replace?
    Hi,
    I have a Heil heat pump system that was installed in my new townhouse in 2003.Air handler is 2001 model and Heat pump is 2003 model.
    Since 2005 I have had to have numerouse repairs made to this system including a new circuit board condenser, zone dampers (2), replacing the evaporator coil in 2006 and now I found out that I have another coil leak.
    Sunday, the company (with whom I have the preventive maintenance with) came out to add 12 pounds of freon. And made an appointment to perform a leak search next week.
    I have spent $3,000.00 to date on this system.
    I have gotten a couple of estimates to replace my system. Should I consider calling another company to come out to repair the leak or consider getting a new system?
    Also should I stay with the R22 or upgrade to the R410a system?
    hvac1000's Avatar
    hvac1000 Posts: 14,540, Reputation: 435
    Heating & Air Conditioning Expert
     
    #2

    Oct 8, 2008, 06:22 AM
    came out to add 12 pounds of freon

    It must be a huge system to hold 12 pounds of refrigerant even if it was completely empty. It was probably a 10 SEER system also and they hold less refrigerant than the newer 13 SEER systems.

    BTW I would be contacting Heil about that evaporator that was replaced in 2006.

    BTW I have no idea when the home was built but I am sure the Heil equipment had a 5 year parts warranty. 2003 to 2008 is 5 years so the coil that was replaced in 2006 was probably under warranty at the time.

    Should I consider calling another company to come out to repair the leak or consider getting a new system?

    I do not think I would ever call your other repair company again. It is a toss up as to what to do with your system. If you have the $$ I suggest getting 2 or 3 estimates from reliable HVAC contractors. Call your friends and seek there imput as who they have used in the past and who they were satisfied with. Also call the BBB and chech the complaint record for the companys who bid your job.

    R-410 is the wave of the future but make sure the company you choose has been certified by the manufacturer that they attended there R-410 class. Refrigerants all do the same job but R-410 jobs needs a bit more attention for proper install. If you decide to do a new R-410 system make sure they replace the line set also. They can be flushed to prevent R-22/oil cross contamination but when you are spending the big bucks for a new system get a new line set.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Replace or repair air unit [ 1 Answers ]

I have a 23 yr old Lennox forced-air furnace and air condenser. The air-conditioning stopped working. Public Service diagnosed and said the fan motor is shot. They told me that a new motor would be impossible to get given the age of the unit. They then quoted me $6500 to replace the air unit...

Repair or replace? [ 4 Answers ]

My 13 year old Phillips Magnavox has no picture, only sound. I'm trying to decide if I should repair or replace it. :confused:

Replace or Repair ? [ 5 Answers ]

The verdict: Bryant Heat pump's compressor is shorted to ground. Unit is 8 years old, out of warranty (warranty only 5 years) Now I have to chose one out of three 1. Replace the compressor alone: $1,750 for material &labor. Warranty for 1 year 2. Replace the outside unit: around $3,000...

Replace or Repair? [ 2 Answers ]

Hello Its -15degC outside and my furnace will not light. Thankfully my gas fireplace seems to be keeping up. I have a Keeprite furnace with a Honeywell SV9501M main gas and pilot controller. I have checked the all the limits and the Solenoid is receiving 28V to ask for heat. The Solenoid also...

Should I replace or repair my TV? [ 5 Answers ]

My TV has a white horizontel line across the screen, dividing the screen in half. Above the line the screen is totally black and below the line the picture is normal. It's a Samsung 25" TXE 25346.


View more questions Search