Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    Wirewizard's Avatar
    Wirewizard Posts: 5, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Mar 31, 2012, 10:40 AM
    Shared neutral on GFCI breaker
    I am remodeling my house and have run a variety of colored wires through conduit to a junction box. One branch circuit from that run goes to outdoor outlets and another goes to a double gang outlet for the entertainment center.

    Now that the entertainment center outlets are being used, the GFCI breaker trips when anything is plugged into the entertainment center.

    Is this caused by sharing the neutral between the two circuits?
    Can the neutral be shared between a GFCI or Arc Fault breaker and a standard circuit?
    ma0641's Avatar
    ma0641 Posts: 15,675, Reputation: 1012
    Uber Member
     
    #2

    Apr 1, 2012, 09:00 AM
    Yes, you cannot have a shared neutral on a GFCI. In a shared neutral, the neutral, acts as a return line, per se, and when one circuit is used, it senses an imbalance and trips. Why not leave the outside protected and pigtail off before the GFCI?
    hfcarson's Avatar
    hfcarson Posts: 1,003, Reputation: 49
    Ultra Member
     
    #3

    Apr 1, 2012, 09:16 AM
    Mr. Wizard...
    Initially I'm concerned that you're sharing a neutral... yes, it is an approved wiring method but in many past projects has caused many failures. As a standard company policy we have forbidden this wiring method from all of our projects. What have you gained or saved? What is the risk?
    My recommendation to you would be not to share any neutrals, separate your circuits...
    I strongly recommend getting a permit and an inspection, most inspectors I know are more than happy to help with DIY projects.

    Sharing a neutral with a GFCI breaker will never work as the current through the phase conductor and neutral will often be different which is exactly what the GFCI is designed to protect against.
    Sharing a neutral with an AFCI might be OK but does it violate the installation instructions?

    Keep your projects simple, don't cut corners and follow the listing and labeling instructions for everything you install. Good luck
    Wirewizard's Avatar
    Wirewizard Posts: 5, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #4

    Apr 2, 2012, 04:38 AM
    Thank you, Great answer and advice.
    The reason in one case was a 4-way light circuit was wired with one wire shy to properly wire the three switches. One solution was to install hi-tech expensive Lutron (or equivalent), and the other was to borrow a neutral from a nearby outlet on a Arc-fault breaker. As you can guess, the arc-fault tripped as soon as the lights were turned on.

    In the GFCI case, exterior outlets were added to a junction box under the house that contained wiring for multiple circuits. Several neutrals were tied together and the neutral for the new outlets was added to the wire nut. I have since isolated one neutral to dedicate to the outdoor outlets and all is well.
    I have learned a lot from this project, and 3-way/4/way light switches are now second nature.
    Inspections are forthcoming and I have a good working relationship with the inspector.
    Wirewizard's Avatar
    Wirewizard Posts: 5, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #5

    Apr 2, 2012, 04:55 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by ma0641 View Post
    Yes, you cannot have a shared neutral on a GFCI. In a shared neutral, the neutral, acts as a return line, per se, and when one circuit is used, it senses an imbalance and trips. Why not leave the outside protected and pigtail off before the GFCI?
    This was a mistake made within a junction box. I wired to a neutral that went to a dedicated circuit for the entertainment center and the problem wasn't discovered until the first time I plugged in a computer to the outlet.
    I wasted time troubleshooting the outlets in avoidance of the uncomfortable crawl under the house (I thought I was done ;-) )
    This has been an ambitious project
    Thank You
    Attached Images
       
    hfcarson's Avatar
    hfcarson Posts: 1,003, Reputation: 49
    Ultra Member
     
    #6

    Apr 2, 2012, 04:57 AM
    Wirewizard...
    Excellent... The more you learn the more you discover there is to learn.
    I'm pleased to hear you are having the local inspector review your work,
    Many shy away from permits and inspections when the inspector is another
    Resource for support. When many permits only cost $50, why not?
    tkrussell's Avatar
    tkrussell Posts: 9,659, Reputation: 725
    Uber Member
     
    #7

    Apr 2, 2012, 05:46 AM
    The 4 PVC conduits passing through framing members entering panel will need nail plate protectos, same as over the low voltage wiring.

    I do not see the neutral marked white, if those are the 120/240 volt feeders at the bottom of the panel.

    Romex to right of CCTV box not stapled properly.

    At the 4 gang, inspectors typically want to see sheathing removed, and at least all gorunds splices and pigtailed ready for devices.
    Wirewizard's Avatar
    Wirewizard Posts: 5, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #8

    Apr 2, 2012, 06:19 AM
    All of those issues have been addressed. Nail plates have been installed even where they weren't needed.
    This was early pictures of the work I did, part of the photo portfolio to show what is behind the walls.
    This house is fully dry-walled and painted at this point. Appliances and A/C to be installed soon.
    Thanks for the advice, I am way past minimum code requirements ;-)
    Wirewizard's Avatar
    Wirewizard Posts: 5, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #9

    Apr 2, 2012, 06:33 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by hfcarson View Post
    Wirewizard...
    Excellent...The more you learn the more you discover there is to learn.
    I'm pleased to hear you are having the local inspector review your work,
    many shy away from permits and inspections when the inspector is another
    resource for support. When many permits only cost $50, why not?
    I agree. I wired the low voltage for a friend who was remodeling a small office. At my insistence he removed all his romex boxes and installed smurf and increased his interior wall depth to accommodate the conduit boxes. His argument: I'm not pulling a permit, no inspections.
    After following my advice he was "discovered" by an inspector who was so impressed by the work there was no fine imposed and the work was allowed to continue. A great lesson, do the right thing even when nobody is looking.
    The photo attached is above the ceiling in a lawyer's office.
    Attached Images
     

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Shared neutral [ 21 Answers ]

I have a 50 year old home. I am doing some remodeling and found that I have 2 separate circuits sharing the same neutral. I hadn't seen this before and I am worried about it. Is this in itself a problem? Also, the neutral is hot where I am remodeling but not at the breaker box. Do I have a...

Do single pole breakers hook black to breaker and neutral & grd to bonded neutral bar [ 6 Answers ]

I have an Eaton Cutler-Hammer meter/breaker box. (MB816B200BTS-FLCH) I want to run a 20 amp circuit (underground wire) from this box through existing underground conduit to a receptacle for a dishwasher. This run would be app. 15' to 20' and from my main house panel it would be 40' to 50'. All...

Shared neutral [ 11 Answers ]

I believe I have a shared neutral. I was installing a new ceiling fan. I checked the circuit with a multimeter and it read 54 volts when the switch is off. I also checked the outlet that is controlled by a different switch, same result. Actually the whole house is like that. I then removed all...

Three phase shared neutral [ 1 Answers ]

If at the intake position from the utility company it is three phase, and the load is, say 50amps per phase. Would the return shared neutral take that full load of 150 amps? Or is there a reason why it would be lower because shared neutral conductor size is always the same as phase conductors. ...

Shared neutral on 14/3 with tandem breaker [ 2 Answers ]

Hey all! I am a new member and learning a lot from this great forum. I have a question about shared neutrals, 14/3 wire, and tandem breakers. I have seen several posts about shared neutrals, and want to make sure my home wiring is safe. My home is about 7 years old, and I have 8 circuits...


View more questions Search