Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    Janmarie's Avatar
    Janmarie Posts: 167, Reputation: 46
    Junior Member
     
    #1

    Aug 5, 2008, 07:52 PM
    What do I need to BE for him to commit and ask me for my commitment?
    Hi, I am a new member :-) and I would consider myself an expert on relationships. I have never had any problems dating or getting dates. I would say that I have had a wonderful dating life...some long term, some short and sweet and I could probably give out some real helpful advice on relationships BUT here is where I get stuck. I have been dating a man for a year and 3 months. He is an older, well established man in his 50's. The relationship started very quickly but has lasted. We live 8 hours away from each other in two different countries, USA/Canada. But spend most of the summers together. Infact he just left from a long extended stay with me and is on his way back to Canada. We do love each other. There was a time in the beginning of our relationship that he suggested that if our relationship is still going well after a year, he would come down in May and take me back with him. Okay, I thought, but I have two children in the states that have a couple more years of school and we decided to wait until they graduated and started their own lives. So I am thinking we can handle 2 more years. We had both looked into him moving to the states so we could be together while my children are going to school but that didn't seem to work out, it is hard for a Power lineman to get work if he's not a US citizen. Anyway, he has never asked me for a commitment to him and I am wondering if he assumes that I am or that he is even commited to me? Another thing that kind of alerts me is that he may be going through his midlife crises. He just bought a Harley and is going places alot without me. Tattoo's, crazy diets. I am the younger woman here so is he doing this so he can feel like he's a young man again? But there is still this question that I don't feel it is my place to ask for but would love for him to ask me, and that is for a commitment to him. How do I go about it in a way that he believes it is his own idea? This one frustrates me and I don't want to blow a great relationship. Thanks in advance
    ylaira's Avatar
    ylaira Posts: 1,193, Reputation: 118
    Ultra Member
     
    #2

    Aug 5, 2008, 08:14 PM
    Every person has different preferrences and there's no such thing "as what you should be" to be a marrying type. It's only your partner who can tell that depending on what how he thinks you suit to him.

    Sometimes no matter how you think you're great partner you will be, the person is just not really a marriage material. Im sure you've heard people who doesn't believe marriage. Some were just aking time. Otherwise check out these favorite links of mine.

    Seal the Deal and Make Him Commit - Cosmopolitan.com
    Will He Ever Marry You? - Getting Your Guy to Propose - Cosmopolitan.com
    talaniman's Avatar
    talaniman Posts: 54,325, Reputation: 10855
    Expert
     
    #3

    Aug 5, 2008, 08:43 PM
    Your breaking the first rule, and that's honest communications. Very few relationships last with out it, and if your afraid to express your feelings to your man, what kind of commitment can you expect?? Talk to him and tell him how you feel.
    Janmarie's Avatar
    Janmarie Posts: 167, Reputation: 46
    Junior Member
     
    #4

    Aug 5, 2008, 09:23 PM
    Quote Originally Posted by talaniman
    Your breaking the first rule, and thats honest communications. Very few relationships last with out it, and if your afraid to express your feelings to your man, what kind of commitment can you expect??? Talk to him and tell him how you feel.
    Ahhh someone who believes in communication. I believe it as well. I decided one day, about a month ago to trust that our relationship was able to handle the "Talk." Maybe it was bad timing on my part but I am usually not the one who asks to have the talk so I am very insecure about my approach to this subject. But he will kind of start it and when it seems to be getting a bit heavy, he stumbles over his words. I am still at a very comfortable level in our relationship and I want to just give him that opportunity to express it when he feels that talk needs to be discussed......But on the other hand....what is taking him so long? :-) What I have discovered on this last visit we had was that he let down a few of his walls and allowed me to come inside...for a few moments...and I just listened to him...I didn't judge him...I didn't compare what he was sharing with me to my own agendas...I just listened...and encouraged him so he would let me stay inside a little longer. He shared things that he only shared with his closest buddy and I thought it was amazing that he felt a safe place with me to open himself up more. I think that I need to practice a little more patience with him and allow him to have that safe place with me to share more of himself and then maybe he will feel safety when getting to that part where he asks me, no holds barred if I would commit myself to him. Thanks for the advice and I think I found my own answer :-)
    BetrayalBtCamp's Avatar
    BetrayalBtCamp Posts: 307, Reputation: 63
    Full Member
     
    #5

    Sep 8, 2008, 11:57 AM
    He may be assuming you know there is a commitment there because you guys are making long term future plans together. And many people aren't comfortable discussing their feelings, especially men who don't get as much practice as it as women do with their friends, family. They let their actions speak for themselves, like making long term plans together.

    If you're comfortable being patient, you're get your answer sooner or later one way or another. Which it sounds like you figured out already! :)

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

She Says she doesn't want to commit, but still wants me there as if we were. [ 5 Answers ]

First I meant she doesn't want a RELATIONSHIP, but still wants me there as if we had one... My Girlfriend and I recently split. We split because (and these are her words, not mine) one thing will happen, whether big or something really small, and she would blow up about it... so bad that she'd cuss...

Can't commit until I know for sure - [ 10 Answers ]

Hi everyone Just after a bit of advice as I know there isn't an answer :-( As with a lot of posts it is concerning a first love. I went out with her for 4 years and had a great time - Uni came and we ended up splitting up as many people do at this stage - a sad part of my life but I would...

Won't commit [ 8 Answers ]

I am 49 yrs old and widowed my new boyfriend is 44 and never married we have been seeing each other for seven months but began talking a little over a year ago one day he says things that leads me to believe he will move me to his state this is a long distance relationship and then the next it is...

He tried to commit suicide [ 5 Answers ]

My 23 year old cousin tried to commit suicide the other day. He slit his wrist, ended up hitting two majot veins and a major artery and had to get 30 staples to stop the bleeding. He is over 8 hours away, but I want to try everything I can to help him. I offered him my support many times, made...

She says she can't commit & needs time [ 2 Answers ]

I met someone in Sept. of last of last year while looking at new homes. She was the salesperson showing the home. Their was an instant attraction for both of us. During the tour we hit it of, I didn't want to be too forward and ask for number right away. Plus their was someone else along on the...


View more questions Search