T-30 Shower/Tub Diverter Handle stuck in old fixture needs to come out
I am replacing a TA-25A Temptrol diverter spindle and a t-30-kit temptrol diverter handle kit by Symmons. I'm replacing it because the spindle(TA-25A) was not diverting from shower to tub and I tried just replacing the spindle but still no luck. I read several previous articles that all said after everythings off and your left with the T-30 white plastic diverter handle, screw a lag screw in and pull it right out. My issue is I have a lag screw in and that sucker will not come out! I don't want to force it but I know this is not going to come out as easy as pulling on it, and I don't want to cause a bigger problem here. I'm hoping for a speedy response as its going to be one hot and sweaty memorial day weekend if I don't get this thing going soon! Please help me.
Thank you