Ask Me Help Desk - Hollywood & The Media

Hollywood & The Media

Hello:

When I read a newspaper or watch a TV newscast, I don't think I'm being lead. I think I'm being talked to. When I see a movie, I don't see someone trying to influence me. I see them trying to entertain me.

In my view, these two entities reflect society - they don't lead it.

Apparently, there are others of you who disagree. I see the media and Hollywood being blamed for all sorts of society's ills all the time, and on THESE pages too. I say what?? Clearly, there are those of you who feel as though Hollywood and/or the Media DOES influence your thinking and your activities... And, they do so PURPOSEFULLY. I suspect you think there's a great left wing liberal conspiracy going on. Yes??

If so, please report. Come on, you can tell me.

excon

It's the right-wing's way of life: 'the media made me do it', it absolves them from personal responsibility.

Hello excon: You have posed a neat observation and question. I am certain that the news media and Hollywood try to shape public opinion and attitudes. My recollection is that in 1969, Newsweek Magazine and 60 Minutes on CBS were doing everything they could to disengage the U.S. from Vietnam. Particularly on 60 Minutes, there was no balance. I haven't watched 60 Minutes since then, with the exception of the Hillary and Bill show in 1992. The demise in readership of the mainstream newspapers continues as well from what I hear. Of course, it is on purpose. And just as Mr. O'Reilly says, if you want balance, read the editorial page from The New York Times and The Wallstreet Journal. Influence me? No way.

Hello George:

Thanks for your comments.

I don't know. I think I'm a fairly politically astute and somewhat intelligent individual. While I didn't read Newsweek, I DID watch 60 minutes during the Vietnam war, and I still do. I DID enjoy Dan Rather.

I have to tell you that, in all candor, when I read that some believe (as you do), that they were actively promoting a political agenda, I didn't see it. Maybe I missed it, but I don't think I did.

excon

Quote:

Originally Posted by NeedKarma

It's the right-wing's way of life: 'the media made me do it', it absolves them from personal responsibility.

Is that your alternate reality, NK, because the right is leading the charge for personal responsibility. We aren't the ones trying to ban trans fats and Fox News.

So why do some conservatives blame movies and the media for "corrupting" people? Can't people think for themselves?

Quote:

Originally Posted by excon

.... And, they do so PURPOSEFULLY. I suspect you think there's a great left wing liberal conspiracy going on. Yes????

If so, please report. Come on, you can tell me.

excon

For your further study: Media Bias Basics

And: NewsBusters.org | Exposing Liberal Media Bias

I turned off network TV news 35 years ago so it doesn't bother me at all.

Quote:

When I read a newspaper or watch a TV newscast, I don't think I'm being lead. I think I'm being talked to. When I see a movie, I don't see someone trying to influence me. I see them trying to entertain me.

When I read a paper or watch the news, I'm not being led either - but I see less and less reporting and more and more analysis disguised as news. As for Hollywood, yeah they're trying to entertain me but if you can't see the messages they're sending, regardless of which side they're from, you aren't paying attention.

Quote:

In my view, these two entities reflect society - they don't lead it.

To a degree it does reflect society, but in what universe is Michael Moore's Sicko, Fahrenheit 9/11 or Brokeback Mountain not trying to shape society? Filmmakers are not shy about their intent to influence culture and too many already acknowledge the impact it has.

Fields of Fuel
Indie filmmakers and their influence on modern culture
George Lucas Speaks About Hollywood's Influence on Society
Saving the environment, one celebrity at a time

You can find these all day, ex. Fortunately however, Hollywood's influence is waning as the box office receipts for so many activist movies recently has shown.

Quote:

Apparently, there are others of you who disagree. I see the media and Hollywood being blamed for all sorts of society's ills all the time, and on THESE pages too. I say what?? Clearly, there are those of you who feel as though Hollywood and/or the Media DOES influence your thinking and your activities... And, they do so PURPOSEFULLY. I suspect you think there's a great left wing liberal conspiracy going on. Yes??

Apparently both sides think so, ex. The left thinks there's a vast right-wing conspiracy in the media and the right thinks there is a vast left-wing conspiracy. Who's right? Where does the evidence lead? I say it's decidedly tilted to the left - as do many studies, surveys and admissions from the media themselves. The BBC admitted it, ABC's News Political Chief admitted it, NPR admitted it, Chris Matthews gets a thrill up his leg from Obama for crying out loud.

Hello again, George:

Sending me to conservative web sites that mirror your opinion doesn't do it for me. I certainly didn't think you were alone.

excon

Here is more reading for you:
Media bias in the United States - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Media Bias : the media is saturated with bias

What Liberal Media? --Eric Alterman

Quote:

Originally Posted by speechlesstx

the right is leading the charge for personal responsibility.

Yeah, "We don't torture, it's those 'bad apples' that did it". Bwa HaHaHa!!

Hello again, Steve:

There's a difference between news and analysis. I have no trouble making the distinction. Most people can't. Or maybe I should say most right winged people can't.

excon

Quote:

Originally Posted by speechlesstx

To a degree it does reflect society, but in what universe is Michael Moore's Sicko, Fahrenheit 9/11 or Brokeback Mountain not trying to shape society?

You're not listening - in a society where the people have free will and personal responsibility you can throw all messages at them and let them decide. What do want? More censorship? A bigger government to oversee and protect you?

Quote:

Originally Posted by excon

In my view, these two entities reflect society - they don't lead it.

I agree. I'd include politics as well. It's all demand-driven.

Quote:

Originally Posted by NeedKarma

So why do some conservatives blame movies and the media for "corrupting" people? Can't people think for themselves?

Why do you pick on Fox News?

Sorry mate, I don't follow you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by NeedKarma

You're not listening - in a society where the people have free will and personal responsibility you can throw all messages at them and let them decide. What do want? More censorship? A bigger government to oversee and protect you?

I'm not listening? LOL, I never said anything about censorship, we're not the ones screaming to restore the Fairness Doctrine - it is the left that wants to mandate "fairness" in media and silence Rush Limbaugh and Fox News. It is the left that is championing hate speech laws, speech codes and intolerance toward conservatives and their ideas. What are they afraid of?

Hello again:

Let's look at Brokeback Mountain... First off, I didn't see it. Second off, it appears to be a love story about two gay cowboys.

You, and your right winged cohorts however, see something else. Maybe you can tell me why. Do you doubt there's homosexuality in the world? Do you doubt that some were cowboys? Should their story not be told? Is telling their story promoting homosexuality? Or is it just telling their story. Is a love story between a man and a woman promoting heterosexuality? Does a love story promote anything other than love? I don't know. You tell me.

excon

I view hate speech in the same vein as yelling "Fire" in a crowded theatre. Rush falls into that category. "Intolerance towards conservatives"? If this website is any subset than the intolerance is towards anything liberal.

Quote:

Originally Posted by excon

Hello again, Steve:

There's a difference between news and analysis. I have no trouble making the distinction. Most people can't. Or maybe I should say most right winged people can't.

Isn't that what I said, there's a difference between news and analysis? Seems I made the distinction just fine.