Seems like this problem may have to be fixed with laser treatments. May not be a pigmentation problem. I don't know a lot about the treatments, but they use them on a lot of makeover shows, the laser zaps the dark spots caused by acne/hairbumps. It looks red when finished and then goes away altogether. I would research it before I keep spending money on products that don't work. You may have already paid for the treatment buying products. It's worth investigating anyway.