Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    missmarrero's Avatar
    missmarrero Posts: 1, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Oct 18, 2013, 05:25 PM
    Off probation but incarsirated on probation violation?
    My fiancé was on probation in Philadelphia County from 1/2012-1/2013 when he signed off. During that period he got pulled over for a dui (3/2012) in another county. He went to all his court hearings up until we received a letter from the DA's office stating the DUI had lack of evidence due to the police not properly calibrating the breathilyzer and the case would be thrown out. He then did not go to the last hearing under the impression the case was dismissed. A bench warrant was then issued for his arrest. He was picked up 9/12/2013 in the county where the DUI was and released on ROR. Philadelphia then picked him up a detainer. He has now been sitting in Philadelphia since and went to a probation violation hearing and said they will continue to hold him there until the DUI case is finished. Even though it is getting thrown out and the county that arrested him released him and his probation in philadelphia ended in 1/2013. How long can they hold him for this? His call of the list hearing for the DUI is 10/24/13 & sentencing hearing may not be until December. Is this legal? How did he violate if there were no new charges? Please some advice would help!
    Fr_Chuck's Avatar
    Fr_Chuck Posts: 81,301, Reputation: 7692
    Expert
     
    #2

    Oct 18, 2013, 10:52 PM
    When we got the DUI did he tell his probation officer about it ? But yes, even if thrown out of court the evidence needed at the VOP hearing is less than a court trial. And if there is a court date, of course he has to go, he should know that.

    But probation stops (freezes) once there is a violation, so the DUI will have stopped his probation and he could not have been released until the DUI was cleared.
    excon's Avatar
    excon Posts: 21,482, Reputation: 2992
    Uber Member
     
    #3

    Oct 19, 2013, 05:54 AM
    Hello m:

    I disagree with my friend, the Padre. A violation only IS a violation IF one is CHARGED with a violation... If it's discovered AFTER he has been released from probation, they LOST their chance to violate him.

    Secondarily, if he was told that the DUI charges would be dropped, he should NEVER have been arrested...

    But, in the legal system, just because something SHOULD be one way, doesn't automatically mean it gonna BE that way. He needs somebody to MAKE it happen, and that would BE an attorney.

    excon

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Violation of probation- didn't pee but signed failed for hydrocodone to probation [ 10 Answers ]

misdemeanor probation violation one was dismissed I was released 6/10 /10 I violated for a random drug screen by admitting I wouldn't pass probby didn't make me pee but had to sign waiver, he felt bad I was falling apart I'm on felony agg. Battery charges brought to simple battery on probation for...

Probation violation on a felony. More probation or actual jail time? [ 2 Answers ]

My sister in law was on probation for fraudulent use of i.d. (felony in TX). She was just arrest for theft ($50-$500) in another town and served about a week in jail there. She was then extradited back home because she violated her probation. She is currently being held on NO BOND with charges of...

Violation of probation, but not convicted until probation is supposed to be expunged [ 2 Answers ]

I am currently on probation for paraphilnalia charges and my one year is over and this is to be expunged on jan 5, 2010. I recently have been charged with theft hoewever, and I probably will not have a hearing and get convicted for this until after jan 5th. So techniqually I will have been expunged...

Violation of traffic Probation while on unsupervised crimal probation [ 1 Answers ]

My husband was sentenced 3 yrs unsupervised probation for 2nd degree assault. He already had a case pending for traffic. He hit a car bumper. Was sentenced to supervised probation and to pay fines for damages of 1,000 dollars. We haven't paid the fine yet, we will at tax time we just haven't had...


View more questions Search