[starlite1]

Question for you guys and gals! What would you do if your ex wanted you back today? Would you say yes or no? just curious... remember when doing NC it is also great rule of thumb to know where you stand if infact they do come back into your life... start preparation for that mental meltdown incase it happens.

Hi Jolienoire,

Yes, I would. My situation is a little complicated though, this time I broke up with him, out of fear (if you want to, read my posts it will give you the whole kit and kaboodle). But provided we have both worked on ourselves, and because the love is already there, I would go back with him in a NY minute. I just hope that day comes, and he wants me back...

[jolienoire]

Thats a good question. I know I can say that I wouldn't. The sheer amount of people... family and friends that would kill me for doing so would keep me in line. I think I would be too embarrassed to show my face if I did. Easier for me by the way she treated me I think.... I really hope all you guys would do the same.

Well I read your story, and your relationship lacked effort from her. You were doing all the work, and that is never a good thing. So for you it would require a lot of thinking, and thinking and thinking..

[starlite1]

It could it or it could not, Let me tell you I was in the same boat, I went months without talking to my ex. He did inititate several attempts to contact during the NC period, But I kept my cool stayed grounded, and didn't give in. But again I already have been through a divorce so my tolerance level is pretty dense.. Anyway Months passed I already considered us never getting back together, but again this is the guy I dated many years ago back in HS before I was even married. SO we have a history..anyway he came back and with a vengenance.. He was completely miserable the whole time we were apart. I guess I didn't worry because I knew deep down in my heart of hearts I was good to him, and when you make a good impression in someone's heart it usually stays there.. My point is when he came back I was firm in what I wanted and stood for, and if he couldn't handle it then he was knocking at the wrong door. He knows I am very verbal, and very true to my word. Yes we are still together, and stronger than ever...

I am so happy for the both of you! I wish you all the best! :)

[dollarman]

It could it or it could not, Let me tell you I was in the same boat, I went months without talking to my ex. He did inititate several attempts to contact during the NC period, But I kept my cool stayed grounded, and didn't give in. But again I already have been through a divorce so my tolerance level is pretty dense.. Anyway Months passed I already considered us never getting back together, but again this is the guy I dated many years ago back in HS before I was even married. SO we have a history..anyway he came back and with a vengenance.. He was completely miserable the whole time we were apart. I guess I didn't worry because I knew deep down in my heart of hearts I was good to him, and when you make a good impression in someone's heart it usually stays there.. My point is when he came back I was firm in what I wanted and stood for, and if he couldn't handle it then he was knocking at the wrong door. He knows I am very verbal, and very true to my word. Yes we are still together, and stronger than ever...

Such an awesome story! I would love to have something like that happen, though I'm not banking on it. I just dig the idea of love truly connecting two people. Amazing and I'm very happy for you! :)

[jolienoire]

Hi Jolienoire,

Yes, I would. My situation is a little complicated though, this time I broke up with him, out of fear (if you want to, read my posts it will give you the whole kit and kaboodle). But provided we have both worked on ourselves, and because the love is already there, I would go back with him in a NY minute. I just hope that day comes, and he wants me back...

I did read your story and although you broke up with him, I can understand your reason, He seemed too fickle to begin with, and you wanted to make sure you were going to make the right decision. Totally understandable,however how can he then say he was ready for marriage and so instantaneously dismiss that when you show him a little skeptism? I mean look at his track record.. How could he really have wanted to get married when he just showed that he can't communicate effectively? It was okay to dismiss your feelings prior to that but telling you he was not ready and when you question his motives, he totally disregards your concerns and blame you for the breakup? Honestly in my opinion you didn't ruin anything. He isn't being logical.. and he acted irrationally.

[jolienoire]

Such an awesome story! I would love to have something like that happen, though I'm not banking on it. I just dig the idea of love truly connecting two people. Amazing and I'm very happy for you! :)

It really depends on how the relationship was overall, because To be honest my ex-husband would never ever get a second chance.

[NorthernNiceGuy]

Well I read your story,, and your relationship lacked effort from her. You were doing all the work, and that is never a good thing. So for you it would require a lot of thinking, and thinking and thinking..

Yea your right, I think I would have to take back what I said about hoping the others wouldn't take their ex's back. Forgot that everyone here didn't have an ex like mine... Your story sounds pretty amazing, and I will admit that even though I know I shouldn't ever get back with her, I have thought about a scenario like yours. Can't help but think that.

[jolienoire]

Yea your right, I think I would have to take back what I said about hoping the others wouldn't take their ex's back. Forgot that everyone here didn't have an ex like mine... Your story sounds pretty amazing, and I will admit that even though I know I shouldn't ever get back with her, I have thought about a scenario like yours. Can't help but think that.

Besides you have nothing to worry about, Your young, attractive, and you express your emotions.. You would have a line out of the door and around the corner. If only you can see your potential.

[starlite1]

I did read your story and although you broke up with him, I can understand your reason, He seemed too fickle to begin with, and you wanted to make sure you were going to make the right decision. Totally understandable,however how can he then say he was ready for marriage and so instantaneously dismiss that when you show him a little skeptism? I mean look at his track record.. How could he really have wanted to get married when he just showed that he can't communicate effectively? It was okay to dismiss your feelings prior to that but telling you he was not ready and when you question his motives, he totally disregards your concerns and blame you for the breakup? Honestly in my opinion you didn't ruin anything. He isn't being logical..and he acted irrationally.

I know, that is true. I mean he did it twice to me, and this time, I got nervous for valid reasons, and he doesn't even let me explain or when I suggested that we still move in and work on things, he says no... But yet, I have taken him back... twice...

[jolienoire]

Honestly jolienoire...I'd be willing to work on it. I'm not sure how I'd react if I heard those words, but I'd be willing to work on it. And I would take all that I've learned and see what happened..

In your case your ex wanted to test the waters, or perhaps think the grass is greener on the otherside. WHich I can understand why you feel betrayed, because she should be working it out with someone she loves rather than looking for it else where, By the time you heal from this NC you may not even want her back, In my opinion, I find it as I deal with a lot of people in relationships that people tend to have more bitterness when they are left for someone else and usually when they do come back your trust in the relationship lacks tremendously and at times can end in another bad breakup.

[jolienoire]

I know, that is true. I mean he did it twice to me, and this time, I got nervous for valid reasons, and he doesn't even let me explain or when I suggested that we still move in and work on things, he says no...But yet, I have taken him back...twice...

Yes, irrational, he is contradicting, and really not seeing the whole picture. Your reasons were valid especially with someone who is fickle like he was. But sometimes people think when you take them back you erase or must forget about the past and start anew. Which we should do but its hard, and Heck we are all human, Its like getting burned once accident, getting burned twice, negligence getting burned three times you asked for it..

[dollarman]

In your case your ex wanted to test the waters, or perhaps think the grass is greener on the otherside. WHich I can understand why you feel betrayed, because she should be working it out with someone she loves rather than looking for it else where, By the time you heal from this NC you may not even want her back,, In my opinion, I find it as I deal with a lot of ppl in relationships that people tend to have more bitterness when they are left for someone else and usually when they do come back your trust in the relationship lacks tremendously and at times can end in another bad breakup.

Spot on. Thank you for your answer, and I hear all of your points loud and clear. It was very tough for me to hear her say she wanted to date other people... very tough. But if you love them let them go, because if it does work out I don't want it to be a fluke.. let me stop because I seem to have that wishful thinking welling up. Thank you though.

[NorthernNiceGuy]

Besides you have nothing to worry about, Your young, attractive, and you express your emotions.. You would have a line out of the door and around the corner. If only you can see your potential.

jolienoire,

I think you just made my day, I really took that to heart and I am going to do my best to not sell myself short. Really, thank you, that simple post made me feel a world of better. I really respect the advice you give, guess that's why you're an expert :)

[classicrocker]

It could it or it could not, Let me tell you I was in the same boat, I went months without talking to my ex. He did inititate several attempts to contact during the NC period, But I kept my cool stayed grounded, and didn't give in. But again I already have been through a divorce so my tolerance level is pretty dense.. Anyway Months passed I already considered us never getting back together, but again this is the guy I dated many years ago back in HS before I was even married. SO we have a history..anyway he came back and with a vengenance.. He was completely miserable the whole time we were apart. I guess I didn't worry because I knew deep down in my heart of hearts I was good to him, and when you make a good impression in someone's heart it usually stays there.. My point is when he came back I was firm in what I wanted and stood for, and if he couldn't handle it then he was knocking at the wrong door. He knows I am very verbal, and very true to my word. Yes we are still together, and stronger than ever...

Im glad to hear that, that is awsome.

[zooropa1985]

This is just weird but my ex somehow still has me on msn, I thought I had blocked and deleted her turns out I only deleted her.

Anyway she starts talking to me, I reply with very short one word answers then she asks me If we could try again would you want too.

I was surprised at this and wanted to say yes but I played it cool and said I honestly don't know, she then asked would I think about it, I said I would.

Then she starts saying how she's missed me and talking like this reminds her of the old days and that's what made her fall for me.

Now I'm confused, is she being serious, could we really go back after the damage that has been done. So many questions in my head, I honestly don't know what to do.

[ISneezeFunny]

Make her work for it.

... really... work for it.

[Wiggy22]

I'm only on my first day, and its been killing me, after we had the conversation yesterday I sent her 2 messages on my myspace but she hasn't been online to read them.. its really tearing me apart.

[starlite1]

Well guys, here I am again... I am such a mess... I really want to call him and apologize for everything... I wish I could know if he would ever reconsider getting back with me... My God I miss him... I'm sorry

[starlite1]

im only on my first day, and its been killing me, after we had the conversation yesterday i sent her 2 messages on my myspace but she hasnt been online to read them..its really tearing me apart.

Hi Wiggy,
I know what you are going through. Not to worry, I'm sure she will respond once she sees them. Are you keeping yourself busy though? That is key, try and keep as busy as you can. I'm glad to see that you came back here though. That is a good thing :)

[talaniman]

im only on my first day, and its been killing me, after we had the conversation yesterday i sent her 2 messages on my myspace but she hasnt been online to read them..its really tearing me apart.

Stop texting, stay of her whatever page, and do something with yourself, that doesn't include desperate humiliation.