Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    annhayward's Avatar
    annhayward Posts: 1, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Dec 27, 2007, 10:40 AM
    Garage door damage liabilty - who is liable?
    Individuals who may have been working for a contractor in my high rise condo building gained access to the garage through my opening the door to let in my own contractors.
    When I realized that they were the wrong people I asked them to leave. They refused repeatedly and a verbal disagreement ensued. I called our front desk repeatedly to ask for assistance from the building's general manager and the front desk... This took some time, and as a result, in fear, I placed a cone under the garage door opening in order to manage my escape from the garage if necessary.
    The garage door came down, touched the cone, went back up and broke. The building wants me to assume total liability for the repairs.
    Is this correct in Virginia?
    It was an automatic door... Should it not have gone back up on its own properly? If it had been a child, there could have been substantial physical harm to the child...
    Can I file against the subcontractors for unlawful entry?
    this8384's Avatar
    this8384 Posts: 4,564, Reputation: 485
    Ultra Member
     
    #2

    Jan 18, 2008, 11:04 AM
    I get the feeling this isn't the full story. What exactly broke on the door? Was it something mechanical or the door itself? Who tried to close the door in the first place when there was something underneath it? What were you so afraid of that you put a cone underneath the garage door? You're asking for an answer without explaining the situation.

    If it's an automatic door, there should have been a sensor that would have seen something was in the path of the door, thereby preventing it from closing in the first place. Did someone force the door? If they forced it and caused damage, then that party would be liable for the repair.

    No, you cannot sue them for unlawful entry because you let them in. There's nothing unlawful about walking through a door when someone opens it for you.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Overhead Door garage door opener light just blinks? [ 5 Answers ]

:confused: My 15 y/o Overhead Door (brand) garage door opener was working fine opening & closing until a few days ago. It has very low usage because I mostly park my car outside the garage door. Now when I press the remote control w/ new battery OR the hard wired wall switch, the light on the...

Insurance coverage for garage door damage [ 4 Answers ]

Will my homeowner's insurance cover damage to my garage door?

Garage door [ 2 Answers ]

We do not have a garage door opener, but always open it by hand. Last week one side fell out of the track and I had to slacken the spring to fix it. The door is centred and is not rubbing against one side... so I'm assuming it is just the spring. Now that I put the spring back the door is very...

Garage door opener prevents door from opening all the way -- how to fix? [ 1 Answers ]

My wife and I moved into a house three months ago and we didn't realize this problem before we bought it. I'm trying to solve a problem with an existing garage door and Genie opener which due to the amount of backroom along the tracks, doesn't allow me to open the garage door the full length...


View more questions Search