Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    pinkrazr's Avatar
    pinkrazr Posts: 4, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Sep 16, 2007, 01:11 AM
    Depression, Anger.and Blame?
    A few weeks ago, my ex, who as of late has been exhibiting many signs of depression, broke up with me because he "doesn't feel anything anymore". However, while he holds to the fact that I didn't do anything wrong, he remains extremely angry at me for no apparent reason, acting extremely mean-spirited and cold towards me (and only me... he's pleasant to everyone else!) He seems to attribute all his stress to me, failing to acknowledge his current problems with his work and family situations.

    I've read up on depression but haven't come across any stories where the anger and blame was to this extent. I was just wondering if it is common (or possible?) for someone dealing with depression to be extremely angry and blame another person for all the stress/problems/bad situations in their life. Does the anger ever fade, and do they ever understand that it wasn't that person's fault? Anything that I can do?

    Any thoughts, experiences, or advice?

    Thanks!
    KBC's Avatar
    KBC Posts: 2,550, Reputation: 487
    Ultra Member
     
    #2

    Sep 20, 2007, 07:09 PM
    Quote Originally Posted by pinkrazr
    A few weeks ago, my ex, who as of late has been exhibiting many signs of depression, broke up with me because he "doesn't feel anything anymore". However, while he holds to the fact that I didn't do anything wrong, he remains extremely angry at me for no apparent reason, acting extremely mean-spirited and cold towards me (and only me...he's pleasant to everyone else!) He seems to attribute all his stress to me, failing to acknowledge his current problems with his work and family situations.

    I've read up on depression but haven't come across any stories where the anger and blame was to this extent. I was just wondering if it is common (or possible?) for someone dealing with depression to be extremely angry and blame another person for all the stress/problems/bad situations in their life. Does the anger ever fade, and do they ever understand that it wasn't that person's fault? Anything that I can do?

    Any thoughts, experiences, or advice?

    Thanks!
    I am a manic depressed male that did exactly what he did to you,to another g/f 4 years ago.
    Sometimes a depressed person will focus all anger outwardly,and to focus on only one source doesn't seem out of the norm(at least this is my experience).My ex-mother-in-law also manic/depressed would have one focal hate at a time,sometimes it was for a short time(days)sometimes weeks.
    My relationship experiences while depressed would not allow for any lateral negotiations,what I thought was final,rational or not.

    I hope this helps answer your question.
    Ken
    pinkrazr's Avatar
    pinkrazr Posts: 4, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #3

    Sep 20, 2007, 08:18 PM
    Quote Originally Posted by KBC
    I am a manic depressed male that did exactly what he did to you,to another g/f 4 years ago.
    Sometimes a depressed person will focus all anger outwardly,and to focus on only one source doesn't seem out of the norm(at least this is my experience).My ex-mother-in-law also manic/depressed would have one focal hate at a time,sometimes it was for a short time(days)sometimes weeks.
    My relationship experiences while depressed would not allow for any lateral negotiations,what I thought was final,rational or not.

    I hope this helps answer your question.
    Ken
    Hi Ken,

    Thanks for your reply! It seems as if you have come to an understanding of your actions during that period... but how long and through what means did that come? My ex is not on any medication or receiving any treatment, as he refuses to acknowledge that this is a problem. I am no expert, but his actions (and background) seem to point to a problem. I feel terrible because I want to help, but it seems as if I'm rather helpless in this situations.

    Having little to no background knowledge in this, I really do appreciate any insights that you may have... Thanks again!
    KBC's Avatar
    KBC Posts: 2,550, Reputation: 487
    Ultra Member
     
    #4

    Sep 21, 2007, 05:22 AM
    Hi again,
    As for how I came to realize my actions,years of therapy and medications,before this I wasn't aware I even acted out of the "norm".
    A 10 year marriage ended finally when I just couldn't rationalize the behavior on MY part.
    Was my ex-wife responsible for the break-up? Maybe,maybe not, or to what extent were my actions/behaviors to blame?who knows? the result is just the same,I had issues related to ,or directly because of, undiagnosed bi-polar depression.
    Could therapy or a more understanding spouse changed this,NO.
    The timing was not right for me to seek help till I found I needed it,and only then through my own sufferance.

    Again result You are not responsible nor powerful enough to stop a persons need to find their our truth(or reality)support goes far when there is a connection,but look at your needs first,your connection is severed and your life is now first.

    Hope this helps,
    Ken
    Marily's Avatar
    Marily Posts: 457, Reputation: 51
    Full Member
     
    #5

    Sep 24, 2007, 06:37 AM
    I think he needs to see a doctor.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Help my anger [ 11 Answers ]

Hi I'm 15 years old and my name is Brandon. Ok look I have gone to counseling and anger management but none of that stuff works. My anger is starting to even scare me. I don't look for attention and if u want to tell me otherwise u might as well fuck off and pray I don't find you. Well I...

What to do with anger [ 37 Answers ]

I am just writing to ask about suggestions for dealing with anger and pain of unrequited love; and the person treats you like dirt on top of it. I already know that I was stupid to let it even get that deep, let myself be used, and for me feeling the same way for so long. I totally understand, it...

Global Warming - The blame for everything. [ 7 Answers ]

The above is something I found while surfing for the history of the earth's evolution. All are now concerned about global warming - and this should be information available to all. On most sites, I found that if I wanted to read more, I had to pay for it. Other, like the above link, just was...

Anger problems and depression [ 4 Answers ]

I suffer from anger problems and depression. I just broke up with my girlfriend, because of my problem. I don't realize I am doing it until it is to late, until I hurt somebody emotionally. Then it is to late to fix it. My ex girlfriend and I talked for a little while after our break up, until the...

Parents to blame for child porn [ 3 Answers ]

I personally feel that parents are to blame for the child pron growing so big, its not Completely down to the parents but it begins from here, an example is the fact that the clothing market for children is getting very similar to the adult market, it seems like the age of being a child is getting...


View more questions Search