Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    Vaandjay's Avatar
    Vaandjay Posts: 2, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Dec 22, 2010, 07:19 AM
    Please help me compare Trane-Carrier quotes
    CARRIER PERFORMANCE SERIES
    Furnace: 2-stage 58HDV080 (80,000/56,000) (95%)
    AC: 2-ton 24APA7 Performance 17 (17 SEER)
    Coil: Not mentioned in bid
    Total Cost (before tax credit): $7,900
    Total After tax credit: $6,400

    Contractor would need 2 days because he said 2" PVC pipe would be used instead of the 3" in our current 88,000 BTU 1992 Carrier Weathermaker, and he would make a new holes for the new pipe closer to the unit than the ones that currently exist that stretch down the basement wall.

    TRANE
    Furnace: 1-Stage XR95 (76,000) (95%)
    AC: 2-ton XR-15 (15 SEER) (no tax credit)
    Coil: T4TXCB025BC3HCA
    Total Cost (before tax credit): $6,900
    Total Cost (after tax credit): $5,700
    Contractor said he's use existing 3" pipe and work would take 1 day.

    Finally, I've asked the Carrier contractor what the difference would be if we went with a lower SEER AC for our 1949 little colonial (1200 sq. ft above the finished basement). I don't have an answer on that yet. Any ideas on how much less a 15-SEER would be?

    Both contractors seem very good and have received excellent reviews from customers in a local consumer services magazine.

    Thank you for your help/advice.

Check out some similar questions!

Trane, Carrier or? ; R410A or R22? [ 17 Answers ]

Help. I live in a home with two A/C-Heat pump units that are around 15-16 years old. Since we moved in 10 years ago, we have had yearly problems with at least one of the systems or both. The outside box (condensor/compressor?) was replaced, the system would freeze, Freon would be low at least...

Trane vs. Payne vs. Carrier - Any suggestions. [ 5 Answers ]

Hello! I'm in serious need of a new a/c unit after ours died this past weekend. It was a 4 ton carrier, 9 seer, 14 years old. We've gotten 5 quotes & are seriously considering between 2 companies based on quality of prior installations (that's what I hear is most important, not price). All 3...

Trane vs carrier [ 2 Answers ]

I live in Virginia Beach Va area. A single family home, 1750 sq. ft. Trying to decide between a carrier 2.5 tons, 15 sere, R-410, Digital Thermostatnot replacing lines, Air handleler $5,750. Vs. a Trane 2.5 tons, 15 sere, R410, Digital thermostat, 1 year maintenance $5950. For both unit, Use...

Trane vs Carrier [ 2 Answers ]

We installed Trane zone heat pump system last year but have had nothing but problems with the zone working. The contractor has informed me today the are going to replace my Trane with a Carrier zone system - which is better system?

Trane vs Carrier AC/heat system? [ 1 Answers ]

I live in central Florida and in the process of choosing a new system for my AC/Heat. My decision is between Trane and Carrier. We are looking a using a reputable dealer/installer so that is not a problem. The system we are looking at using is a 13 SEER unit with a variable speed air handler...


View more questions Search
 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.