Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Religious Discussions (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=485)
-   -   GOD is amazing! (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=263827)

  • Oct 24, 2008, 05:48 AM
    michealb

    It would make science a lot easier.

    PersonA: Why did such and such occur?
    PersonB: because god wanted it that way.
    PersonA: Sounds right to me lets go spend the rest of our grant money on beer.

    But I've said before I find religion interesting and I probably know more about all of the different types of religoins that 95% of the people out there. It just very interesting how a large group of people get caught up into and believing their cultures fictional stories as true. Even if you say Christianity is the one true religion it still mean 99% of the religions out there are false.
  • Oct 24, 2008, 10:20 AM
    gromitt82
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Capuchin View Post
    This isn't a religious board. It's a place for religious discussion. Religion is interesting to atheists because it's an intriguing phenomenon. Many atheists would love to believe in God. The human desire to have security in knowing what happens when we die, to know where we came from, to know what consciousness is, is a very natural drive that all humans seem to have. We wonder how other people have come to the conclusion that the answer is God, and sure, if you can pursuade us with real meaningful evidence, we'd love that.

    Unfortunately, our only proce is strictly based on Faith. Faith in that GOD created everything and faith in the Jesus (whose wxistence by the way has been historically proven) was the Son of God, and hence God himself who resurrected after the third day.
    We cannot prove, of course, but atheists cannot prove the contrary either.

    Therefore, I think it is just a matter of believing or not believing. A little bit like Hamlet, i.e. to believe or not believe.
  • Oct 24, 2008, 10:31 AM
    michealb

    Quote:

    whose wxistence by the way has been historically proven
    Ehh not so much. The only evidence for Jesus is the bible. The records at the time don't actually show anyone by that name. Look for third party evidence of his existence and you might be surprised. That's another topic.
  • Oct 24, 2008, 10:32 AM
    NeedKarma
    Gromitt,
    To each their own.
    Remember that you are also an un-believer in lots of other stuff. And I'm a believer in a lot of other stuff. We are both believers and un-believers at the same time. :)
  • Oct 24, 2008, 02:56 PM
    arcura
    Capuchin,
    I hope that you do discover ample evidence that there Is a God.
    Peace and kindness,
    Fred
  • Oct 24, 2008, 03:46 PM
    NeedKarma
    Fred,
    I hope you discover that you can live your life without a god.
    Have a great day,
    NK
  • Oct 24, 2008, 06:20 PM
    arcura
    NeedKarma ,
    That hope from you to me is a nightmare to my mind and belief.
    I hope that you can understand that.
    I am pleased that you are happy with your belief, though I disagree with it.
    I'm sad, though, that you will some day find out to late that there is a God.
    Peace and kindness,
    Fred
  • Oct 25, 2008, 01:19 AM
    NeedKarma
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by arcura View Post
    I'm sad, though, that you will some day find out to late that there is a God.

    I'm sad for you too Fred.
  • Oct 25, 2008, 02:51 AM
    Unknown008

    NK, how can you say that we don't know how you feel? I myself, was an atheist, then found God, things in my life changed, and I came to know a better meaning to life, more happiness in a way.

    However, I don't think that you ever was a christian, or never reached the proper 'level' to get that happiness that I (and others) can feel.

    That is why I'm sad for you... You've been given the choice, but you either reject it, or postpone it to an indefinite time.
  • Oct 25, 2008, 02:59 AM
    NeedKarma
    Yes, I was. I was baptised, went to catholic school, church, and even private boys catholic schools. I most likely have more friends of different religious or non-religious beliefs than you do. The fact that you feel that I can't be happy without being like you says more about you than it does about me. Yes I made a choice and I'm a happy guy. That's the way I'm raising my children too: no bible in this house, I teach them to respect others and respect yourself among other things. Respect is earned as an individual not simply being part as a group. My circle of friends are good people, regardless of whatever faith they choose. Being a christian does not automaticallly make you a good person, we all know that.
  • Oct 25, 2008, 03:01 AM
    Unknown008

    That means that my second possibility applies, you didn't have a deeper relation with God, to feel that happiness...
  • Oct 25, 2008, 03:32 AM
    NeedKarma
    Ok, if that makes feel more superior you can go ahead believe that if you wish.
  • Oct 25, 2008, 09:31 AM
    gromitt82
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by michealb View Post
    ehh not so much. The only evidence for Jesus is the bible. The records at the time don't actually show anyone by that name. Look for third party evidence of his existence and you might be surprised. That's another topic.


    While it is understandable that some people may debate over Jesus’ divinity I think that, at this stage of the game only a few dare discuss the historicity of Jesus.
    I will just give herewith a short list, which could be much more exhaustive, of those writers who have referred to Jesus in their writings. Most of them were practically almost comtemporary of Him.

    Fathers of the Church:
    St. Paul (Saul of Tarsus) Roman citizen (ca 5 - 67 AD)
    Pope Clement, of Rome, Roman Citizen (+ca 00 AD)
    St. Philip of Hierapolis (+80 AD)
    Papias, Bishop of Hierapolis (before 70 AD – 155 AD Smyrna)
    Saint Polycarp of Smyrna (ca. 69 – ca. 155)

    Pagan or non Christian Historians:
    Yosef ben Mattyyahu (AD 37 – c. 100), Jewish origin. Although when he became a Roman citizen, changed his name to Titus Flavius Josephus. (His writings provide a significant, extra-Biblical to such figures as Pontius Pilate, Herod the Great, Agrippa I and Agrippa II, John the Baptist, James the brother of Jesus, and a to Jesus (who appears mentioned 4 times in his writings, not as Son of God, but as a “singular prophet and saint man” He was noa a Christian but a Jew.

    Publius (or Gaius) Cornelius Tacitus (ca. 56 – ca. 117) was a senator and a historian of the Roman Empire. His Annals is one of the first-known secular-historic records to mention Jesus . He was not a Christian.J

    Thallus of Samaria, jewish historian who wrote in Greek. It is uncertain when he wrote, but it was probably in the early 2nd century. He refers to Jesus’ crucifixion when attempting to account SPECIFICALLY for the darkness surrounding His crucifixion. In other words, the strange darkness was REAL and a topic of scholarly discussion.

    Phlegon, of Tralles, Another Greek writer and freedman of the emperor Hadrian, who lived in the 2nd century. He also recorded this event as well, specifying the very HOURS OF THE EVENT!

    Lucian of Samosata (c. A.D. 125 – after A.D. 180) Assyrian rhetorician and satirist who wrote in Greek. In his satire The Passing of Peregrinus, its character, Poteus, takes advantage of the generosity and gullibility of Christians, “a sect lead by a man named Yesus”. This is one of the earliest surviving pagan perceptions of Christianity. He obviously was a pagan.
    Gaius Suetonius Tranquillus, (ca. 69/75 – after 130), was a Roman historian during the Roman Empire. His most famous work “Lives of the twelve Caesars” When referring to Emperor Tiberius he mentions the problems created in the Eastern Roman provinces by a “so-called Jesus, King of the Jews”.
    Celsus, who was a 2nd century Greek philosopher and fierce opponent of Christianity. In his work “The True Word” against the Christian religion he claims Jesus is nothing but a thaumaturge...!
    Aelius Claudius Galenus (129-200 AD) was a prominent Roman physician and philosopher of Greek origin. In some of his medical texts he mentions some of Jesus’ extraordinary healings.
    Also Jesus is mentioned in 4 different pages in the Talmud, as a prophet.
    In the Qu’ram 4:171; 5: 111 it can be read that Muhammad, believed Jesus was the Messiah, Allah's anointed messenger. That means that, at least, Muhammad believed Jesus had existed as a person.
    Throughout history hundreds of scholars have debated over Jesus’ divinity but none, that I know of, over his existence.
    Another interesting point that, I believe, reveals the “mauvaise foi” of some modern writers regarding the person of Jesus in particular and of Christianity in general, is that while they ignore the historical evidence of Jesus as a human being living in the first century, I have never seen anybody disputing the evidence of much older saint men like those from the old Testament (David, Elijah, Solomon, etc.) or Siddhārtha Gautama Buddha( from c. 563 BC to 483 BC), Confucius (551 BC - 479 BC) or Lao Tse, who lived in the 6th century BC or King Menes, Egyptian king allegedly founder of the First dynasty, sometime around 3100 BC!!
    Perhaps you can explain that...
  • Oct 25, 2008, 09:37 AM
    gromitt82
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by NeedKarma View Post
    gromitt,
    To each their own.
    Remember that you are also an un-believer in lots of other stuff. And I'm a believer in a lot of other stuff. We are both believers and un-believers at the same time. :)

    Sure, as I said, it is a matter of BELIEVE OR NOT BELIEVE
  • Oct 25, 2008, 10:21 AM
    ernestpaquin
    My name is Ernest Norman Paquin. I am not sure if this is an answer but here is a couple theories of mine;
    I believe that a time travel accident happened in the future which wrongfully sent a traveler back in time to the Garden of Eden where he crashed landed and died. Adam and Eve were the first people to come upon the incicdent after hearing a loud thunderous noise. They immdeiately felt the effects of the radioactive fallout released from the accident and were also the first people to withness death (the traveler). The Radioactive fallout eventually spread out over vast distances and over the years had engulfed the entire world. Radiation effects included perverse electrical stimulation absorbed then accepted in the minds of both Man and Beast, hence knowledge of Evil. The traveler sent back in time who crashed landed and died in the Garden of Eden was and has been mistaken, adopted or covered up and promoted over the centuries to be the Devil. The incident in the Garden of Eden perhaps was scientific that became religious. The Human race I believe was created long before the incident in the Garden of Eden. Adam and Eve were the first people to feel the effects of this event, and the first unkonwingly to inherit knowledge of Evil and witness death.
    They say Science is man's best guess, some religion has to be as well. --Ernest Norman Paquin, author of "Find Me, Eve".

    P.S. There is no Devil, think about it.
  • Oct 25, 2008, 01:43 PM
    shadowwatcher
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by gromitt82 View Post
    last night, i suddenly started to mull over how little we actually know about the notion of what the word god implies or should mean.

    We are no question influenced by the mythological references to gods and goddesses as persons with human feelings and emotions and, more than all, by the figure of jesus christ, which we may tend to visualize more like a man who died in the cross to redeem us, than as god himself.

    So i said to myself. let us imagine the most absolute void and emptiness some 15 billion years ago, which is not yesterday! then, all of a sudden, a tremendous explosion started the expansion of the universe, and gradually, galaxies started to develop, materialize and come into being to reach the 500 billion where, previously, there was nothing. Each galaxy including, in turn, billions of stars system, planets, and so one and so forth…

    but, what about the size of this universe, 15 billion years later?

    The nearest star to earth (proxima centauri) is supposed to be at 4.24 light years away, or some 25 trillion miles!! but, our earth is not in one end of this universe, but more or less in the middle of what we know. In addition, we can see stars and galaxies everywhere. Nobody knows how far away the farthest star is. However, some scholars claim the known universe stretches some 94 billion light years across.

    do we really assume what this means?

    In the meantime, some 4,5 billion years ago our earth and the other planets in our solar system formed out of disk-shaped mass of dust and gas left over from the formation of our sun. And little by little, the outer layer of our small and insignificant planet cooled to form a solid crust when water began accumulating in the atmosphere, to gradually become a planet that can sustain life!!

    and life it has indeed sustained. From the primitive sea algae (perhaps 1 billion years old) to modern man. 230 million years ago we already have evidence of some species of dinosaurs. And between 1994 and 1995, some paleontologists, investigating the archeological site of atapuerca (in central spain) found over 80 bone fragments from five or six hominids dating to between 850.000 to 780.000 years ago.

    now then, what do all these scientifically proven facts demonstrate?

    That god is really amazing!!

    For we have to imagine the incredible thought that there must be a supernatural being so powerful as to create all this universe we now know and everything else we still don’t know. and trying to imagine god as creator of all this is really a most frightening thought, indeed.

    "the heavens declare the glory of god; and the firmament proclaims its builder’s craft. One day to the next conveys that message; one night to the next imparts that knowledge. There is no word or sound; no voice is heard. Yet, their report goes forth through all the earth, their message to the ends of the world. God has pitched there a tent for the sun” (psalm 19:1-5).

    perhaps we should start thinking of how futile our discussions are in front of the awe inspired by god, who has created everything that surround us, and who 15 billion years ago decided to let his divine blow explode into the so called big bang!!

    thoughts on the above will be appreciated.

    your god can't help you now!
  • Oct 25, 2008, 03:14 PM
    xxariesxx
    Religion is such a touchy subject. It's really great that people talk about it and share ideas though, it's the only way we grow.

    Personally I don't believe in practicing religion. It's an aspect of a culture and society, not a given law of existence. Take for example something as simple as in our culture how it is to be expected to be cheerful and smiling constantly. That is completely normal in western society. But to do the same in another, say Russia, that behavior is not seen as normal. You would be an odd person to greet everyone with a smile. Does this mean that their culture is "wrong"? Are westerners "better" than Russians? Of course not. It's the same with religions. Christianity is the norm in western society, just as Buddhism would be in Asian societies, or Islam in the middle east (very generally speaking). Does this mean that we have the adacity to think that we are better than these people too? We are not any better and we know no more. Religion is not something universal; it is a product of our environment.

    One thing I think is really upsetting is that some try to claim that religion brings people together. Religion causes a lot more distance and separation between people than it brings together. Sure there are occasions when someone "finds God" and so becomes connected to society again. But is that because they actually believe there is a God, or were they searching for a connection to humanity that that was able to fulfill? It's rare that someone would find a religion if they are happy and productive. It's only after some kind of distress. These things might offend people but they can't be ignored.
    We separate each other based on if our religion accepts them or not (although that is always counter to what religion teaches). It is only another category to further separate the human race. If we ALL, everyone in every belief, took a step back and saw how completely the same we all are, many things in the world would be quite different.

    I think it's fascinating how willing we are to believe something so unconditionally without delving deeper into it. Some believe that homosexuality is wrong because the Bible states it is wrong. And everything the bible states must be completely true, correct? Yet:
    "Behold, here is my daughter a maiden, and his concubine; them I will bring out now, and humble ye them, and do with them what seemeth good unto you: but unto this man do not so vile a thing. But the men would not hearken to him: so the man took his concubine, and brought her forth unto them; and they knew her, and abused her all the night until the morning: and when the day began to spring, they let her go." (Judges 19:24-25)
    According to the logic that the Bible is a guidebook, complete truth, then apparently the rape of man's daughter is acceptable (I apologize if I step on any toes here).

    We have to have the strength to look deep within ourselves and be honest about the difference between what we want to be true and what is actuality; or at the very least to think more clearly, openly, and intelligently about how we judge and treat others and view our wonderful universe.

    Zeitgeist - The Movie - Watch the original at the bottom of the page first. A worthwhile 2 hours.

    That's my 2 cents
  • Oct 25, 2008, 03:35 PM
    arcura
    NeedKarma,
    Live well and be happy.
    Life is short compared to eternity.
    Peace and kindness,
    Fred
  • Oct 25, 2008, 04:30 PM
    NeedKarma
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by arcura View Post
    NeedKarma,
    Live well and be happy.
    Life is short compared to eternity.
    Peace and kindness,
    Fred

    Thanks mate. I know this life is short, especially when you have young children and you watch them grow up. That's why I'm making the best of it. There's no second chance!
  • Oct 26, 2008, 08:56 AM
    gromitt82
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by shadowwatcher View Post
    your god can't help you now!

    Would you mind explaining what situation are you referring to when you state that GOD can't help me now? For I'm enjoying another day of my already very long life just because God's Will is that my time IS NOT JUST DUE!
    I'M READY TO GO WHEN MY TIME ARRIVES and I do hope GOD will then help me THEN to go.
    Other than that, I do not want anything else. GOD has been very generous with me by giving me a wonderful wife, 4 magnificent sons and 7 beautiful grandsons. I'm enjoying a pretty good health for my age and so are all the members of my family. In another year, GOD permitting, I will be able to celebrate my Diamond Wedding (60 years). So can you please tell me what else can I ask for.
    Perhaps you are thinking of material possessions. But in that connection I have ALL I need, so I fail to see what you are talking about.
  • Oct 26, 2008, 10:30 AM
    gromitt82
    xxxariesxx



    religion is such a touchy subject. It's really great that people talk about it and share ideas though, it's the only way we grow.

    it is not touchy! We make it touchy which is different! Ever since man started to reason, probably one million years ago, man has felt the need to believe in something supernatural to explain what he was doing down here.

    personally i don't believe in practicing religion. It's an aspect of a culture and society, not a given law of existence.

    it is not a law of existence but un undeniable need of mankind. For every person who does not feel that need there are thousands who just do and must, somehow, satisfy it.

    christianity is the norm in western society, just as buddhism would be in asian societies, or islam in the middle east (very generally speaking). Does this mean that we have the adacity to think that we are better than these people too? We are not any better and we know no more.

    i do not think that religions based on love one another (most of them) claim any priority amongst themselves. In any case, true christians do not claim to be better persons than those who are not.
    in the way of spirituality we should still have a lot to learn from islamic or hinduism... it’s a terrific demonstration of sheer faith when one can witness in the middle of cairo, when the muedzin at noon calls to prayer and hundreds of people, until then peacefully minding their own business, kneel down in the squares interrupting traffic to pray with their face looking at mecca.

    religion is not something universal; it is a product of our environment.

    sorry to dissent. Religion is absolutely universal.
    what is not universal, eventually, is the lack of religion.

    one thing i think is really upsetting is that some try to claim that religion brings people together. Religion causes a lot more distance and separation between people than it brings together.

    i agree with you here. But that is not the fault of religions. It is the fault of those who impart the religions and use them to suit their unqualifiable goals and purposes by taking advantage of the faith (and in many cases superstition) of their followers.

    it's rare that someone would find a religion if they are happy and productive.

    you are obviously thinking in terms of what is going on in the western world where we have been flooded by a deluge of materialism. But even so, your statement does not correspond to reality. The usa is supposed to be one of the countries with a higher standard of living and productive and, yet, it is possible the most religious country of the western world.

    it's only after some kind of distress.

    with all due respect to your statement, allow me to say that i know more distressed people among those who do not believe in anything than amid those who believe in some sort of reward in another life.

    if we all, everyone in every belief, took a step back and saw how completely the same we all are, many things in the world would be quite different.

    again this is not the fault of mankind but of its eventual leaders. i’ve had to travel for 0ver 40 years through the whole world because of my job.
    i have never had any problems with people of different cultures, colours or religions. All the problems i had to fight against were the outcome of laws and behaviours imposed by the rulers of such countries.

    i think it's fascinating how willing we are to believe something so unconditionally without delving deeper into it.

    some may not delve enough, because they are satisfied without having to look into any further. Still, many do investigate and research! i, for one!

    some believe that homosexuality is wrong because the bible states it is wrong. And everything the bible states must be completely true, correct?

    as seem to be the fashion –which never ceases to dumbfound me – you take only the bible to criticize.
    but, speaking only of homosexuality practically all religions consider it a sin and in many places is punished with the death.

    " (judges 19:24-25)
    according to the logic that the bible is a guidebook, complete truth, then apparently the rape of man's daughter is acceptable (i apologize if i step on any toes here).

    the bible also says that the universe was created in 6 days! The bible can be interpreted in many ways –depending on who reads it and when it was written – when the book of judges was written (probably over 4000 years ago) women were just third class citizens, and in many cultures they still are...
    since you are obviously reading the bible perhaps you will be kind enough as to quote me some verse of the new testament who encourages the rape of any woman!

    we have to have the strength to look deep within ourselves and be honest about the difference between what we want to be true and what is actuality;

    you are right here, except that many os us, all over the world, we believe in what we want. But i cannot describe what is actuality unless you refer to what we can see and touch. But this is only real at earthly level. Nobody can say what will be real after our short stay over here...

    or at the very least to think more clearly, openly, and intelligently about how we judge and treat others and view our wonderful universe.

    here you are defintely right, in my opinion, at least. If we should understand that there should not be differences amongst us and we should look more often to our firmament, perhaps we should avoid a lot of problems.

    zeitgeist - the movie - watch the original at the bottom of the page first. A worthwhile 2 hours.

    it is obvious that peter joseph is just another atheist. The part where he describes the horrors of the war and terrorism and the wonders of our universe is fine although not new. When he starts speaking about religion in my opinion he is just talking rubbish. But as i say, this is my opinion and he can say what he wishes. But i will not waste any time commenting on his line of thought. To caesar what belongs to caesar...
  • Oct 26, 2008, 10:42 AM
    southerngalps
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by gromitt82 View Post
    Would you mind explaining what situation are you referring to when you state that GOD can't help me now? For I'm enjoying another day of my already very long life just because God's Will is that my time IS NOT JUST DUE!
    I'M READY TO GO WHEN MY TIME ARRIVES and I do hope GOD will then help me THEN to go.
    Other than that, I do not want anything else. GOD has been very generous with me by giving me a wonderful wife, 4 magnificent sons and 7 beautiful grandsons. I'm enjoying a pretty good health for my age and so are all the members of my family. In another year, GOD permitting, I will be able to celebrate my Diamond Wedding (60 years). So can you please tell me what else can I ask for.
    Perhaps you are thinking of material possessions. But in that connection I have ALL I need, so I fail to see what you are talking about.

    It seems as though this person puts this on all their posts. They did so to one of mine. God had nothing to do with my posts.

    ;)
  • Oct 26, 2008, 10:43 AM
    southerngalps
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by shadowwatcher View Post
    your god can't help you now!


    I didn't mean to quote yours, sorry. This is the one.

    ;)
  • Oct 26, 2008, 11:32 AM
    Capuchin
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by gromitt82 View Post
    ..shouting..

    Wow, caps lock sure helped you to get your point across there, champ.
  • Oct 26, 2008, 11:47 AM
    inthebox
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by xxariesxx View Post

    One thing I think is really upsetting is that some try to claim that religion brings people together. Religion causes a lot more distance and separation between people than it brings together. Sure there are occasions when someone "finds God" and so becomes connected to society again. But is that because they actually believe there is a God, or were they searching for a connection to humanity that that was able to fufill?

    Some examples for there are too numerous to state:

    YMCA
    Salvation army
    Mother theresa
    God's Pantry
    Any local Christian pregnancy center

    It is the Jesus' example of service to others that " brings people together" :)

    I will concede that there are not enough of us living out our faith.
    Or those who use religion for their own goals. :(

    Quote:

    Originally Posted by xxariesxx View Post

    It's rare that someone would find a religion if they are happy and productive. It's only after some kind of distress. These things might offend people but they can't be ignored.

    Yes. "blessed are the poor in spirit." I can't tell you how strong, to me, the testimony is of one who has sinned [ drug user, gang member, promiscuous, criminal etc... ] and is now a Christ follower. Or the person who has cancer, or a sick child - and they rely on their faith in God even more.

    Yes, people come before the Lord in their time of need, for comfort, with a broken spirit, desperate: for they know that the solution is not within themselves, or money, or other people. Yes, this is me!

    Yes, that is me! I'm productive [ family, med professional ] and I am happy in the Lord's blessings and His guidance :)


    Quote:

    Originally Posted by xxariesxx View Post
    We separate each other based on if our religion accepts them or not (although that is always counter to what religion teaches). It is only another category to further separate the human race. If we ALL, everyone in every belief, took a step back and saw how completely the same we all are, many things in the world would be quite different.

    Absolutely agree.
    I am a sinner. God forgives me. God loves me. I should forgive and love others because of this and because my sin is no better than anyone elses'
  • Oct 26, 2008, 03:30 PM
    arcura
    gromitt82
    I also would like to see his answer to that.
    Peace and kindness,
    Fred
  • Oct 26, 2008, 03:49 PM
    gromitt82
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by arcura View Post
    gromitt82
    I also would like to see his answer to that.
    Peace and kindness,
    Fred

    We shall see, I hope!
    Have a good night!
  • Oct 26, 2008, 04:14 PM
    xxariesxx
    "Religion is such a touchy subject. It's really great that people talk about it and share ideas though, it's the only way we grow.
    IT IS NOT TOUCHY! WE MAKE IT TOUCHY WHICH IS DIFFERENT! EVER SINCE MAN STARTED TO REASON, PROBABLY ONE MILLION YEARS AGO, MAN HAS FELT THE NEED TO BELIEVE IN SOMETHING SUPERNATURAL TO EXPLAIN WHAT HE WAS DOING DOWN HERE."

    - You are right that we make it a touchy subject. You are also correct that man has felt the need to believe in something "supernatural" to explain existence, which comforts him not because it is true, but because he needs it. We have science now; we don't need to speculate.

    "Personally I don't believe in practicing religion. It's an aspect of a culture and society, not a given law of existance.
    IT IS NOT A LAW OF EXISTENCE BUT UN UNDENIABLE NEED OF MANKIND. FOR EVERY PERSON WHO DOES NOT FEEL THAT NEED THERE ARE THOUSANDS WHO JUST DO AND MUST, SOMEHOW, SATISFY IT."

    - Again you are right. We have to satisfy our needs. I'm not claiming people don't need a religion to be comforted; I'm only saying it's a product of those needs.

    "Christianity is the norm in western society, just as Buddhism would be in Asian societies, or Islam in the middle east (very generally speaking). Does this mean that we have the adacity to think that we are better than these people too? We are not any better and we know no more.
    I DO NOT THINK THAT RELIGIONS BASED ON LOVE ONE ANOTHER (MOST OF THEM) CLAIM ANY PRIORITY AMONGST THEMSELVES. IN ANY CASE, TRUE CHRISTIANS DO NOT CLAIM TO BE BETTER PERSONS THAN THOSE WHO ARE NOT.
    IN THE WAY OF SPIRITUALITY WE SHOULD STILL HAVE A LOT TO LEARN FROM ISLAMIC OR HINDUISM... IT’S A TERRIFIC DEMONSTRATION OF SHEER FAITH WHEN ONE CAN WITNESS IN THE MIDDLE OF CAIRO, WHEN THE MUEDZIN AT NOON CALLS TO PRAYER AND HUNDREDS OF PEOPLE, UNTIL THEN PEACEFULLY MINDING THEIR OWN BUSINESS, KNEEL DOWN IN THE SQUARES INTERRUPTING TRAFFIC TO PRAY WITH THEIR FACE LOOKING AT MECCA."

    - You are absolutely right and I'm glad that you stated this. More people should prove they feel this way as well. If one is going to believe in religion he should definitely respect all of them.

    "Religion is not something universal; it is a product of our environment.
    SORRY TO DISSENT. RELIGION IS ABSOLUTELY UNIVERSAL.
    WHAT IS NOT UNIVERSAL, EVENTUALLY, IS THE LACK OF RELIGION."

    - Religion would be universal if every person on this planet believed in it. That's not the case. It's not like the law of gravity. You're right that the lack of religion is also not universal.

    "One thing I think is really upsetting is that some try to claim that religion brings people together. Religion causes a lot more distance and separation between people than it brings together.
    I AGREE WITH YOU HERE. BUT THAT IS NOT THE FAULT OF RELIGIONS. IT IS THE FAULT OF THOSE WHO IMPART THE RELIGIONS AND USE THEM TO SUIT THEIR UNQUALIFIABLE GOALS AND PURPOSES BY TAKING ADVANTAGE OF THE FAITH (AND IN MANY CASES SUPERSTITION) OF THEIR FOLLOWERS."

    - Religion IS man and his goals and needs. He takes what he has been taught from it; regardless of who leads him. And if there is so much discrepancy on what is right or wrong in the religion itself, "a religion divided is no religion at all."

    "It's rare that someone would find a religion if they are happy and productive. It's only after some kind of distress.
    WITH ALL DUE RESPECT TO YOUR STATEMENT, ALLOW ME TO SAY THAT I KNOW MORE DISTRESSED PEOPLE AMONG THOSE WHO DO NOT BELIEVE IN ANYTHING THAN AMID THOSE WHO BELIEVE IN SOME SORT OF REWARD IN ANOTHER LIFE."

    - You made a comment in my first sentence that the USA is one of the most productive and religious countries in the world. I don't dispute that; I stated "find a religion." Not already have grown up taught and believing in one through life.
    Also it is a matter of finding religion through distress, not being distressed to find religion. Not everyone that is distressed will find religion, but if one finds religion, it is almost surely because they were distressed.

    "If we ALL, everyone in every belief, took a step back and saw how completely the same we all are, many things in the world would be quite different.
    AGAIN THIS IS NOT THE FAULT OF MANKIND BUT OF ITS EVENTUAL LEADERS. I’VE HAD TO TRAVEL FOR 0VER 40 YEARS THROUGH THE WHOLE WORLD BECAUSE OF MY JOB.
    I HAVE NEVER HAD ANY PROBLEMS WITH PEOPLE OF DIFFERENT CULTURES, COLOURS OR RELIGIONS. ALL THE PROBLEMS I HAD TO FIGHT AGAINST WERE THE OUTCOME OF LAWS AND BEHAVIOURS IMPOSED BY THE RULERS OF SUCH COUNTRIES."

    - Who do you think originally imposed religion on the people? It HAS always been a leader and fueled through our society. These leaders were children at one point too; they were taught the same things that everyone was taught. They cannot be made to be completely at fault. On a side note, the USA has more prisons than any other country. So really we are one of the "imposed by the rulers of such countries."
    It is much better to think of ourselves as human. Not Christian, Islamic, etc.

    "I think it's fascinating how willing we are to believe something so unconditionally without delving deeper into it.
    SOME MAY NOT DELVE ENOUGH, BECAUSE THEY ARE SATISFIED WITHOUT HAVING TO LOOK INTO ANY FURTHER. STILL, MANY DO INVESTIGATE AND RESEARCH! I, FOR ONE!"

    - Great. More should do that same.

    "Some believe that homosexuality is wrong because the Bible states it is wrong. And everything the bible states must be completely true, correct?
    AS SEEM TO BE THE FASHION –WHICH NEVER CEASES TO DUMBFOUND ME – YOU TAKE ONLY THE BIBLE TO CRITICIZE.
    BUT, SPEAKING ONLY OF HOMOSEXUALITY PRACTICALLY ALL RELIGIONS CONSIDER IT A SIN AND IN MANY PLACES IS PUNISHED WITH THE DEATH."

    - You're right, it's the same for many religions. It doesn't matter which I quote, the result will be the same for nearly all. I chose the Bible because people can relate to that better than anything else.
    My point is that, is homosexuality wrong? And if so, what are we basing that off? We are basing it off religion. Is that right? No. As respect for another human being it is not right.

    "(Judges 19:24-25)
    According to the logic that the Bible is a guidebook, complete truth, then apparently the rape of man's daughter is acceptable (I apologize if I step on any toes here).
    THE BIBLE ALSO SAYS THAT THE UNIVERSE WAS CREATED IN 6 DAYS! THE BIBLE CAN BE INTERPRETED IN MANY WAYS –DEPENDING ON WHO READS IT AND WHEN IT WAS WRITTEN – WHEN THE BOOK OF JUDGES WAS WRITTEN (PROBABLY OVER 4000 YEARS AGO) WOMEN WERE JUST THIRD CLASS CITIZENS, AND IN MANY CULTURES THEY STILL ARE...
    SINCE YOU ARE OBVIOUSLY READING THE BIBLE PERHAPS YOU WILL BE KIND ENOUGH AS TO QUOTE ME SOME VERSE OF THE NEW TESTAMENT WHO ENCOURAGES THE RAPE OF ANY WOMAN!!"

    - I had only wanted to make the point that there are selective passages which people practicing a religion tend to look over or follow. If people are going to say that the Bible is everything true, then they cannot be selective in what they follow in it. Something that is up to so much interpretation should not be an unending source of dependence.

    "We have to have the strength to look deep within ourselves and be honest about the difference between what we want to be true and what is actuality;
    YOU ARE RIGHT HERE, EXCEPT THAT MANY OS US, ALL OVER THE WORLD, WE BELIEVE IN WHAT WE WANT. BUT I CANNOT DESCRIBE WHAT IS ACTUALITY UNLESS YOU REFER TO WHAT WE CAN SEE AND TOUCH. BUT THIS IS ONLY REAL AT EARTHLY LEVEL. NOBODY CAN SAY WHAT WILL BE REAL AFTER OUR SHORT STAY OVER HERE...

    or at the very least to think more clearly, openly, and intelligently about how we judge and treat others and view our wonderful universe.
    HERE YOU ARE DEFINTELY RIGHT, IN MY OPINION, AT LEAST. IF WE SHOULD UNDERSTAND THAT THERE SHOULD NOT BE DIFFERENCES AMONGST US AND WE SHOULD LOOK MORE OFTEN TO OUR FIRMAMENT, PERHAPS WE SHOULD AVOID A LOT OF PROBLEMS."

    - I am happy that we can see eye to eye on this, that although we can believe in different things we really should all strive to further see how much the same we are and work towards solving a lot of issues.
  • Oct 26, 2008, 04:28 PM
    xxariesxx
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by inthebox View Post
    Some examples for there are too numerous to state:

    YMCA
    Salvation army
    Mother theresa
    God's Pantry
    Any local Christian pregnancy center

    It is the Jesus' example of service to others that " brings people together" :)

    I will concede that there are not enough of us living out our faith.
    Or those who use religion for their own goals. :(



    Yes. "blessed are the poor in spirit." I can't tell you how strong, to me, the testimony is of one who has sinned [ drug user, gang member, promiscuous, criminal etc... ] and is now a Christ follower. Or the person who has cancer, or a sick child - and they rely on their faith in God even more.

    Yes, people come before the Lord in their time of need, for comfort, with a broken spirit, desperate: for they know that the solution is not within themselves, or money, or other people. Yes, this is me!

    Yes, that is me! I'm productive [ family, med professional ] and I am happy in the Lord's blessings and His guidance :)




    Absolutely agree.
    I am a sinner. God forgives me. God loves me. I should forgive and love others because of this and because my sin is no better than anyone elses'

    I do not disagree there are numerous programs and others who have brought people together through religion. As a whole, through history and even today, there is much more separation caused by it however.

    About you finding God through your hard moments in life, I don not want to offend you in any case. I'm glad you are you doing much better now and seem to be happy, and I wish you the best.
  • Oct 26, 2008, 04:36 PM
    Credendovidis
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Capuchin View Post
    ... Many atheists would love to believe in God...

    May I enquire to your source of this wild claim?
    I know many Atheists. But I do not know a single Atheist who would love to believe in God.
    What a nonsense claim!!

    :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

    .

    .
  • Oct 26, 2008, 07:45 PM
    arcura
    xxariesxx,
    Thanks for your opinions.
    They were interesting,
    Peace and kindness,
    Fred
  • Oct 28, 2008, 07:06 AM
    ernestpaquin
    Hello, this is Ernest Norman Paquin, thank you for responding to my inquiry more or less instead of question. I would not kill the Son of God not for any reason, I'll add that; if people want to free themselves from sin than they can join the many millions who free themselves and start over every year on New Years... and no one has to die, you see? Anyway, my book entitled "Find Me, Eve" is available on most online bookstores. It is about time traveling back to the Garden of eden and setting things right. I personally do not believe that the Adam and Eve scenario happened they way it popularly believed. It entered my mind shortly after I asked God "how to make the world a better place" it was revealed as being an accident of scientific nature with time travel being not only the cause but also the answer. I mean even if "the apple" part is true then perhaps Eve did take a bite and turned and said, "this tastes wrong, here Adam you take a bite and tell me why,". Perhaps Radioactive fallout from the time travel accident contaminated everything back then, the apple for example.
    If you are interested in knowing more of my story then you can find me through Yahoo, Google and maybe even Roadrunner, in your search type in keywords; Ernest Norman Paquin or Find Me, Eve. Thanks and I hope you enjoy the story.
  • Oct 29, 2008, 05:49 PM
    Credendovidis
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Capuchin
    ... Many atheists would love to believe in God...

    May I enquire to your source of this wild claim?
    I know many Atheists. But I do not know a single Atheist who would love to believe in God.
    What a nonsense claim!!

    And I still do not see any source information posted here by you.
    So it must have been nothing but an empty hot air wild claim...

    :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

    .

    .
  • Oct 29, 2008, 06:46 PM
    michealb

    I think what he means by we would love to believe is that we understand the desire to think that something is guiding everything that somewhere someone is in control. I can understand that it scares people to think that no one is guiding the ship per say. I understand that, it can be a scary thing that the bad stuff happening to you isn't because of some story that always leads to a happy ending if you just follow some simple rules but just the hand you were dealt and it's up to you to make the most of your hand.

    So there you go one atheist who would love to believe in God, Santa Clause, the Easter Bunny and the tooth fairy. I bet even you would like it if there were simple rules to follow for immortality in heaven. Just because we would like something to be true doesn't weaken our position it just means we understand their position to a point.
  • Oct 29, 2008, 08:02 PM
    arcura
    Michaelb.
    Thanks for that post.
    I think you are on to something there.
    I enjoyed it.
    Fred
  • Oct 30, 2008, 02:23 AM
    Unknown008

    I second that... it's interesting.:)
  • Oct 30, 2008, 08:37 AM
    ernestpaquin
    Hey fellas, this is Ernest Norman Paquin. I am not certain if the recent post(s) pertain to me being and atheist. I am not. I am so convicted to my beliefs that God not only thought me up but all of us , using of course extreme technology and design. I repeat that I am a new member to this (chat-post) of sorts so if it helps you can call me Ernie. Thanks, and take care.
  • Oct 30, 2008, 09:07 AM
    Capuchin
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by michealb View Post
    I think what he means by we would love to believe is that we understand the desire to think that something is guiding everything that somewhere someone is in control. I can understand that it scares people to think that no one is guiding the ship per say. I understand that, it can be a scary thing that the bad stuff happening to you isn't because of some story that always leads to a happy ending if you just follow some simple rules but just the hand you were dealt and it's up to you to make the most of your hand.

    So there you go one atheist who would love to believe in God, Santa Clause, the Easter Bunny and the tooth fairy. I bet even you would like it if there were simple rules to follow for immortality in heaven. Just because we would like something to be true doesn't weaken our position it just means we understand their position to a point.

    Thank you for clarifying for me, sometimes it's hard to find the right words :)
  • Oct 30, 2008, 12:58 PM
    arcura
    Ernie,
    Welcome aboard.
    I hope you have a nice journey with us.
    Peace and kindness,
    Fred
  • Oct 31, 2008, 01:31 AM
    Unknown008

    Yup, Ernie, welcome in the thread! Your book sound interesting... oh yes, this is not a chat room, but more a question-answer board and discussions by means of posts. Hope you'll be in the discussion too! Just need to keep cool if some statements seem... not appropriate or offensive, OK?

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 11:49 AM.