Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Religious Discussions (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=485)
-   -   Atheists. Why "religious" forums? (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=241644)

  • Jul 31, 2008, 04:12 AM
    starbuck8
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by ArtemisAlexis
    Actually starbuck8, i wasn't quoting you, i hadn't seen your post when i responded for the second time, you could probably have figured that out on your own by the way i was writing, and seeings as you have already worked out that i'm a new user and not use to navigating around the site, i find it doubly surprising that you couldn't figure out i wasn't responding to you.

    And i'm not even going to respond to the simpsons statement, your just not worth the effort:eek:

    Completey fine with me my dear. If you are going to answer someone else's post, just a tip, "quote them". I makes it much easier to know who you are speaking of, and who you are disagreeing with!

    I'm worth every second of effort I have put in to this site to help people, and I have gotten many thanks for doing so. You are not yet to be able to say the same. I was quite polite to you. Only asking you to get familiar with the site. Good luck to you!
  • Jul 31, 2008, 04:17 AM
    ArtemisAlexis
    Thank you, and thanks for the tip.
  • Jul 31, 2008, 05:20 AM
    jillianleab
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Altenweg
    I'm actually surprised that so many discussions about God happen between atheists and Christians, what do we hope to accomplish by doing this?

    Personally I believe in everyone's right to believe whatever they want, I won't try to persuade you to believe in God, if you don't try to persuade me not to. What matters to me is not what you believe, but what kind of person you are, if you're a good person that's all that matters.

    Group hug? ;):)

    It's not about accomplishing anything, it's about having stimulating conversations. It's about sharing ideas and learing about other people. Most of the people on these boards are firm in the belief or lack thereof; it doesn't mean we can't have civil conversations and learn something from one another.

    <<Hug>>
  • Jul 31, 2008, 05:25 AM
    jillianleab
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by starbuck8
    I have read through all of your posts in this thread. I want to say that I am very happy with my beliefs, and I am glad to read others also. However, I do want to say, if not believing in anything makes some people, under a guise of being a non-believer, spew venomous words, and be full of hatred, I will stick to my belief in God. Which incidentally, I would have regardless.

    To be fair, there are several theists on this board who do the same thing. There are several who have been banned for being so hateful.

    Quote:

    I know this isn't the belief or actions of all atheists, but the two I have encountered on this thread seem to be very self-righteous, and absorbed in a world of their own. They attack others on a personal level, and act like school yard kids.
    Thank you for distinguishing between the ones who behave this way and the ones who don't; I agree with you! Some people need to grow up! :)
  • Jul 31, 2008, 07:24 AM
    sassyT
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by WVHiflyer
    I could just as easily say the correlative: The religious try so hard to convince others of their faith because deep down they don't really believe.
    And it would be just as 'true.'

    Here is that irony again. You (an athiests) are the one who is here promoting your atheistic Darwinistic beliefs on a religious forum. So how is it that you claim we are the ones trying to convince you of our faith?? I don't get it.. lol seriously. You voluteered yourself to come on a religious discussion so its not like relgious people are the ones going on atheist forums to promote their beliefs.
    So really, maybe the reason why you athiests are here is to try and convince us of your faith because deep down you don't really believe there is no god.
  • Jul 31, 2008, 07:25 AM
    0rphan
    Hello everyone,
    Having read all the posts on this board, I now feel terribly sad... I can see quite clearly now, how all the religious wars began... which were also quite unnecessary.



    Blessings
  • Jul 31, 2008, 07:31 AM
    excon
    Hello:

    I think Orphan is right. Religion HAS caused lots of wars...

    And, that's exactly why THIS atheist is here. Yes, it's true, 97% of the worlds population are believers. But, if I can convince one of them that what they believe is hooey, then I've done my job towards world peace.

    See? It has NOTHING to do with religion.

    excon
  • Jul 31, 2008, 08:00 AM
    NeedKarma
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by excon
    Yes, it's true, 97% of the worlds population are believers.

    A little less than that:
    Major Religions Ranked by Size
  • Jul 31, 2008, 08:03 AM
    sassyT
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by ArtemisAlexis
    Wow sassyT, you're a very angry young Christian, you need to get some help.

    Im sorry you got that impression but it is actually quite the contrary.. I am a very happy Christian and was under the impression that I could come one a religious forum to have civil discussions on religion with other believers of different religions. Well, I was wrong because religious forums seem to be full of (ironically), for the most part, angry athiests who want who are just here to convince believers that they are "illogical"," irrational" and stupid for believing in god in an effort to propagate and promote their own atheistic beliefs.

    Quote:

    First you say that you 'never said this was a religious forum' and then you start the next sentence with 'this is a religious forum', then you verbally attack some poor guy for responding to a question you specifically designed to be answered by atheists.
    You are mistaken. Go back and read what I said. I said "i never said this was a Christian forum" But yes I did say it is a religious forum because indeed it is.

    Quote:

    What is your deal? Your obviously looking for an argument and then running into playing the victim, if your representing Christians in this OPEN forum, then your really giving them a bad rep.
    Like I said before... If athiests like yourself think they can come on a religious forum to insult, mock and make condescending remarks about religion and think that I am going to be quite and take the abuse they better ask somebody.. lol
    Being a Christian does not mean you let people walk all over you. We still have the right to stand up for ourselves especially from all the HATE speech we experience on this site.

    Quote:

    At first I felt a little sad for you being harassed whilst trying to speak to other like minded people on these religious forums- but now I can see that you're the one creating all the problems.
    Again you are sadly mistaken. The Problem is athiests like Cred. And a few others who from day one have been terrorising and harassing Believers. I have had normal civil discussions with people like Lobroster(atheist) who I don't have a problem with. I am the most outspoken believer here because I don't stay silent when my religion is attacked, so naturally all the athiests here hate me but I don't really care. :cool: :)
  • Jul 31, 2008, 08:08 AM
    sassyT
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by ArtemisAlexis
    Also, you say 'Almost 80% of Americans are Christians', this reminds me of a poster in the Simpsons, it read: 50 million smokers can't be wrong!

    Ha ha ha ha, and by the way Unicorns never used rhetoric to commit genocide.

    Just because America was founded by Christian people doesn't make it a Christian country, thats why your bill of rights gives all Americans religious freedom.

    If you really want to live as a true Christian you'd move out of the USA and to the middle east where Christianity begun.

    You obviously have some serious anger issues.. but I will just let it go. :rolleyes:
  • Jul 31, 2008, 08:09 AM
    NeedKarma
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by sassyT
    But yes i did say it is a religious forum because indeed it is.

    Please see Post # 68 on this thread.
  • Jul 31, 2008, 08:34 AM
    Alty
    Sassy enough! This is a religious discussion board, not the Christianity board. From my understanding (I was told by the mods) this forum was set up specifically for Atheists and other people who did not have a specific forum to go to. There is a Christianity board, and other religious boards, this one is for discussion, for anyone, and everyone. If you only wanted Christians to answer your post then you should have posted on the Christiantiy board. But you posted here and asked atheists to join in, so why are you complaining that they're here?

    Please try to have a rational discussion about different beliefs, allot of us have already managed to do that, there are just a few that want to continue to fight.
  • Jul 31, 2008, 08:42 AM
    asking
    I have some questions, one for Sassy and two for everyone.

    Sassy, Do you include creationism and antievolutionary biology are part of your religious belief? That is, if you criticize evolution and someone criticizes your argument, do you feel that's an attack on your religion?

    My second question is for everyone: Do you believe that religious Freedom includes the right to not practice any religion, i.e. atheism and agnosticism or simple nonreligiousness? Or does that seem objectionable to you?

    And, in a related vein, if it's polite to not make fun of someone's religious beliefs or criticize them, is it also part of being polite to not criticize atheists for lack of belief? Or do you think those things are really different?
  • Jul 31, 2008, 08:58 AM
    excon
    Hello asking:

    Well, maybe you should have started your own thread. Anyhow, I'll answer:

    There is a difference between criticism and making fun of somebody - a BIG difference. As a matter of fact, it's that difference that causes problems. One is attacking someone's belief, which is what we're here to do, and one is attacking the other person, which we are NOT here to do.

    If people could tell the difference, it would be a lot more peaceful around here - indeed, in the whole world.

    That was the second question. Here's the answer to the first: If you are NOT free to practice NOTHING, then you're NOT free at all.

    excon
  • Jul 31, 2008, 09:10 AM
    sassyT
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Altenweg
    Sassy enough! This is a religious discussion board, not the Christianity board. From my understanding (I was told by the mods) this forum was set up specifically for Atheists and other people who did not have a specific forum to go to. There is a Christianity board, and other religious boards, this one is for discussion, for anyone, and everyone. If you only wanted Christians to answer your post then you should have posted on the Christiantiy board. But you posted here and asked atheists to join in, so why are you complaining that they're here?

    Please try to have a rational discussion about different beliefs, allot of us have already managed to do that, there are just a few that want to continue to fight.

    Alternweg, why are you misinterpreting what I am saying? Of course I have no problems with Atheists coming on this religious forums as long as they are here to have civil discussions with us and not make attacks insults and condesceding remarks.

    Altenweg, you came into this later in the game that's why you don't understand what I am talking about. Since I have been on this forum I have seen some (not all) atheists call Christian/religious people names like "Ignorant", "Uneducated", reference to our input as "religious babble""Hot AIR" even "Bull S**t" just to name a few.
    Some athiests have said believing in God is like believing in the "Boogeyman".. I think that is an insulting thing to say about someone's religion don't you think?
    One guy here said Christians are nothing but a "political party engaged in such nasty organized behavior"
    This all sounds like bigoted hate speech to me...
    So my deal is, if atheists want to come and discuss religion they should learn to respect other people's beliefs and some athiests here may not agree but they are respectful which I appreciate.
    So this post is specifically directed to the rowdy ones.
  • Jul 31, 2008, 09:23 AM
    sassyT
    [QUOTE]
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by asking
    I have some questions, one for Sassy and two for everyone.

    Sassy, Do you include creationism and antievolutionary biology are part of your religious belief? That is, if you criticize evolution and someone criticizes your argument, do you feel that's an attack on your religion?

    Asking you and I have had heated but civil debates about evolution vs Creation and I have no problems with you because even though we don't agree you have never resorted to attacks and name calling as some of the people on this site.
    So no, I do not at all take offense to constructive criticism of my arguments. I understand we all don't agree and the best thing we can do is present our side of the argument. Which I do and anyone is free to agree or refute it. No problem, that's all part of the fun of debates. But it is when people run out of intelligent things to say and resort to play ground name calling and mudslinging and attacking one's religion.
    As I have said before, I disbeliefe in the theory of evolution is independent of my religious belief, it just based on the fact that I have not seen any conclusive evidence that I find satisfactory to qualify the theory as fact. So I don't know why when I refute evolution I get attacks from athiests calling my argument religious babble but at the same time they can not prove macro evolution. I just don't get it.. :(
  • Jul 31, 2008, 09:51 AM
    asking
    Sassy, biologists view creationism as a religious argument, since there is no known scientific basis for creationism. Even the conservative Republican judge in the Dover case concluded that creationism and intelligent design were, at heart, religious arguments. That's the view of people who accept modern biological thought on evolution.

    I have no problem with your viewing your belief in creationism as separate from your personal religious beliefs, but I think a lot of the confusion may arise from people assuming that your attacks on evolution are religious dogma, which leads to religious arguments. I don't think anyone enjoys those much.

    It is frustrating for some of us to have to defend something that we view as proved (evolution) from someone like yourself who knows "just enough to be dangerous." That is, I feel macroevolution has been proved and I have presented some of the evidence in other threads.

    You have said you are not personally satisfied with any evidence for evolution--although I have to say that biology for the last 100 years IS satisfied, so this lack of satisfaction with the evidence is particular to you and other people who are mostly not practicing biologists. I have asked you what sort of evidence could satisfy you as to the truth of evolution, but if you answered, I didn't see it. I feel that a serious conversation about evolution would have to start with that, because I can't keep guessing what evidence might satisfy you. If your discussion of evolution is in fact a scientific discussion (and not religious), then it's incumbent on you to state your terms--that is, what would it take to prove that new species can form?
  • Jul 31, 2008, 10:51 AM
    Alty
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by sassyT
    Alternweg, why are you misinterpreting what i am saying? Ofcourse i have no problems with Atheists coming on this religious forums as long as they are here to have civil discussions with us and not make attacks insults and condesceding remarks.

    Altenweg, you came into this later in the game thats why you dont understand what i am talking about. Since i have been on this forum i have seen some (not all) atheists call Christian/religious people names like "Ignorant", "Uneducated", refference to our input as "religious babble""Hot AIR" even "Bull S**t" just to name a few.
    Some athiests have said believing in God is like believing in the "Boogeyman".. i think that is an insulting thing to say about someone's religion dont you think?
    One guy here said Christians are nothing but a "political party engaged in such nasty organized behavior"
    This all sounds like bigoted hate speach to me...
    So my deal is, if atheists want to come and discuss religion they should learn to respect other people's beliefs and some athiests here may not agree but they are respectful which i appreciate.
    So this post is specifically directed to the rowdy ones.

    Sassy, I have been on this site much longer than you, and I have fought with certain people about religion before you even came on this site, so no, I did not come into the game later, I've been here all along, and I know what happens on these threads.

    You question atheists rights to come on religious boards, I'm trying to explain to you that this particular board, The religious Discussions board, was started for atheists (that's what I was told), so that they would have a place to talk about their beliefs. So, having said that, you are posting on their board, not the other way around, understand? If you had posted this on the Christian discussion board then you might have a case, but even then it's doubtful because you specifically asked atheists to answer your thread. Be careful what you ask for, you might get it. ;)

    We all have to learn to respect each other, it's not just the atheists, it's the Christians too, until that happens, there will not be a rational calm discussion about our different beliefs.

    Don't judge a whole group on a few people.

    I know that you are very passionate about this, but you have to calm down, read everything that is said as a statement, not an attack against you personally. Okay?
  • Jul 31, 2008, 11:04 AM
    michealb
    The problem is that Sassyt's views are religious dogma and no physical evidence will satisfy her.

    As we increase education and access to the new ideas and the internet. You will see fewer and fewer fundamentalist.

    Also SassyT christians come to atheists forums as well and are often very rude.
    EvilBible.com Discussion Forum &bull; View topic - Why do so many christians come here?
  • Jul 31, 2008, 11:16 AM
    Alty
    Maybe that's why I don't mind discussing this with rational people, because my beliefs aren't as "set in stone" as others.

    I've said many times that I do believe in God, but not the bible and not church, so that makes me possibly the strangest believer in this group.

    I have no problem talking with people who don't believe, in fact I have many friends on this site and off that are atheists.

    I do have a problem with people who only want to fight, name call and make fun of others beliefs, those are the people I butt heads with, because I don't like their attitude, it has nothing to do with their beliefs.

    Michealb, I know that I could have a rational discussion with you, and most of the other non believers on this site, it's just a few people who ruin it for everyone.

    In all fairness, if anyone should get off this thread it's probably me, I'm not a Christian, nor am I an atheist, I am what I am and believe what I believe and I'm never met anyone with the same beliefs I have.

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:33 PM.