Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Relationships (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=277)
-   -   My girlfriend changed after we got back together (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=433916)

  • Nov 8, 2009, 01:38 PM
    brokenheartls
    My girlfriend can't decide between me and her ex
    Me and my g.f are together for about 4 months now.. and its all good
    Until one day she told me she has strong feelings for her ex , she was with him for almost 1.5 years , she doesn't call him or msn or any other IM programs...
    But she says she misses him a lot , so she called him and said that she loves him ,
    And she also loves me.. a lot..
    She thinks I'm better than him in every way , but she doesn't want to take the risk of coming back to me and having no future with me, because we are different religion , but she said I'm better , nicer , and more attractive than him , but it doesn't stop her from loving him..
    I helped her a lot , I told her that she could take her time , she should sleep on it and tell me what's on her mind and I was very understanding , I didn't push her to do something she didn't want to do , so now she keeps asking me for help , I said if your happy with him then go with him.. I only want my g.f to be happy :( ,
    And now she can't decide.. she said she wanted help.. and here I am now asking for your help..
    I hope you good people have good answers... because she is very very confused..
  • Nov 8, 2009, 01:45 PM
    redhed35

    She made her decision,now she should follow through... dont be a shoulder to cry on...

    She said she loves him,let them figure it out..

    There comes a time when being the nice guy gets confused with being the emotional cruch..

    I'm sure she has friends,advice her to talk t othem or her boyfriend.

    Its time to protect your own heart and head space and get some perspective on the situation.

    My advice for you is to start no contact... my advice for her,is too leave you alone to get over her.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 01:45 PM
    itried

    You can't help her. She needs to help herself by taking a step back from the two of you and deciding what's best for her. While she's doing that you can do the same for yourself.

    My advice would be to leave her alone because if you stay with her during this time of conflicted feelings it WILL end badly. Take a step back and carry on with your life. Who knows, you may end up finding someone else who you really like and most importantly likes you as well. Don't be anyone's second choice.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 01:51 PM
    brokenheartls

    I'm very confused , we told each other that we should take some time for ourselves , she doesn't talk to her ex a lot about her problem , she talks to me ( her b.f ) and I really want to find a solution for this problem.. I don't want our relationship to end I love her too much , I know 4 months aren't a lot , but this is the first time I fall for someone this fast , I need help , I don't want her to make the wrong decision , I just want her to be happy...
  • Nov 8, 2009, 01:55 PM
    redhed35

    Even if her being happy is not being with you?

    She seems very confused and unhappy,and so do you..

    Perhaps you should consider no contact to get some perspective.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 01:58 PM
    brokenheartls

    I want her to be happy... even if she is not with me..
    If she is happy , then I'm happy
  • Nov 8, 2009, 01:58 PM
    bjohnrupp

    Take my advice... Start no contact immediately- this is the only chance you have right now. Make her miss you and think she may have lost you. If she truly loves you she'll come back but if she doesn't she'll go with him.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 01:59 PM
    itried
    Look man, I feel for you and you need to know that everyone has been there. But, and this is a big BUT, you should understand that during this time she is most definitely not being truthful and honest with you. She's trying to spare your feelings so she will tell you whatever it takes to get you off her back or to shut you up. She's always going to miss this guy and it will always eat away at her until she can't take it anymore and she has to explore the feeling by going to him.

    Back off, leave her alone, keep your dignity and walk away. Tell her to call you when her head is healed. Maybe you won't want anything to do with her then or maybe you will. What's important is that you were able to keep control of a situation that will rapidly disintegrate into chaos.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 02:03 PM
    brokenheartls

    So I should leave her alone.. give her time to think..
    And let her decide by her self ?
    And if she asked for my help ?
  • Nov 8, 2009, 02:18 PM
    bjohnrupp
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by brokenheartls View Post
    so i should leave her alone..give her time to think..
    and let her decide by her self ?
    and if she asked for my help ?

    YES! Leave her alone- disappear from her life completely... dont respond to any emails, texts, IM'S and delete her from your Facebook... she is not being fair to you and is stringing you along if things don't work out with her ex. Trust me I've been through this back in August. My ex fiancé was seeing both of us (without me knowing) and then got rid of me so she can be with her ex who she always loved... Do not say a word to her starting now- if you wait until later to start no contact you will lose at her game.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 02:35 PM
    brokenheartls

    I don't understand... why is she doing this to me ?
    Doesn't she love me enough ?
    Or does she love her ex more ?
    I'm confused... if I'm better in every way
    Aren't I the right one for her ?
  • Nov 8, 2009, 02:51 PM
    bjohnrupp
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by brokenheartls View Post
    i don't understand... why is she doing this to me ?
    doesn't she love me enough ?
    or does she love her ex more ?
    im confused... if im better in every way
    aren't i the right one for her ?

    She loves you but not as much as you love her and she has stronger feelings for her ex because she was with him longer and still loves him. No she doesn't love you enough- I know this sounds harsh but I know from experience- if she did she wouldn't be putting you through this hell... sounds like she loves him more... you're probably a better/nicer guy for her but she still has strong feelings for him so you have to let her go.

    Trust me I know this is not want you want to hear but don't let this girl put you through hell. Its going to take a long time to get over her but you have to start now. I'm sure she was beautiful and you loved everything about her but she's only playing/using you and won't think anything of getting rid of you once her ex will commit to her.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 03:11 PM
    spidy_six

    Dude I am into a similar kind of situation. The best thing to do now is leave her alone. You are only there until she needs you, if she is saying that she loves her ex a lot and if that person has at least 10% of softcorner for her you gone for a toss. By the end of the Day you will be asking another question in the same forum that how should I forget her. So brother my honest advice to you is leave her alone and do your work if she has feelings for you she MAY come back other wise you can get a better one in your life. Don't be confused I am telling you this based on my past experience you are in a big trouble, come out of it before its too late.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 03:29 PM
    brokenheartls

    She told me she wants to see me alone , and then on another day see her ex and talk...
    Is this the right thing to do?
    I mean what if she saw him and loved him more ?
    Or what if she kissed him and didn't tell me? This is my biggest fear I don't want him to kiss him , helpp
  • Nov 8, 2009, 03:31 PM
    brokenheartls

    I don't want her to kiss him ***
  • Nov 8, 2009, 03:41 PM
    bjohnrupp
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by brokenheartls View Post
    she told me she wants to see me alone , and then on another day see her ex and talk...
    is this the right thing to do ??
    i mean what if she saw him and loved him more ?
    or what if she kissed him and didnt tell me ?? this is my biggest fear i dont want him to kiss him , helpp

    How old are you? Im sure she has kissed him... maybe even more... its possible she's been having sex with him. I'm telling you right now disappear and don't talk to her anymore- she's with him now.:(
  • Nov 8, 2009, 03:47 PM
    brokenheartls

    No I'm like 18 and she is 16.5 no one has sex here...
    She didn't see her ex for 4 months and now she is going to see him some place.. so they could talk so she could pick him or pick me..
    Any way my biggest fear is that she feels weak and just kisses him..
    I don't want this to happen..
    She is going to see someone she missed.. they will hug I'm sure of that.. but I don't want her to kiss him it will kill me
  • Nov 8, 2009, 03:51 PM
    brokenheartls
    Before this happened...

    We had good times.. we fought sometimes..
    But when I fight I just go see her and she feels weak and forgives me.. that's her problem when she sees someone she loves she gets weak...
    I'm afraid that this is what will happen if she goes and sees him.. she will feel weak and may kiss him
    I'm sure she won't tell me because she is not completely honest
    And she doesn't want to hurt my feelings..
    How can I trust her not to kiss him when she feels weak..
    Help that's another problem damn
  • Nov 8, 2009, 05:52 PM
    spidy_six
    Dude are you concerned about your girlfrnd or her virginity? Stop thing that what hppns if she kisses him, its common you can't expect a virgin in your life. If you are the right person she will come back to you if not do what ever you want you will get nothing.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 05:54 PM
    spidy_six
    Dude are you concerned about your girlfrnd or her virginity? Stop thinking that what hppns if she kisses him, its common you can't expect a virgin in your life. If you are the right person she will come back to you if not do what ever you want you will get nothing.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 06:30 PM
    supermannnnnn
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by bjohnrupp View Post
    How old are you? Im sure she has kissed him...maybe even more...its possible shes been having sex with him. I'm telling you right now disappear and dont talk to her anymore- shes with him now.:(

    OMG listen to john... Your girl is already having sex with him... Trust me... You're the person she comes to as 2nd choice. She is not treating you like a MAN. You are the BACK BURNER. She is disrespecting you as a MAN and you are letting her. You must IGNORE HER starting right now.

    After applying NO CONTACT starting right now, the very 2nd thing you need to do is BETTER YOURSELF as a MAN!

    Learn to dance, learn to cook, WORKOUT, learn new skills, buy new clothes, make new friends, do anything to better yourself.

    Lastly, once you applied NC + bettered yourself = you have just turned the tables on her. You will be winning this game. And you will have played the cards right.

    She will be the one wanting you back. Make her FEEN FOR YOU, until you see it through her actions. NOT WORDS! Only then, it will FINALLY be YOUR TURN TO CHOOSE if you want HER BACK! HAHAHAHA! =)

    Let the fishing line loose, and watch how fast the fish swims towards YOU!

    Pull that fishing line, and watch how fast that fish PULLS AWAY from you!

    Good luck.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 07:04 PM
    bjohnrupp
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by supermannnnnn View Post
    OMG listen to john... Your girl is already having sex with him... Trust me... Your the person she comes to as 2nd choice. She is not treating you like a MAN. You are the BACK BURNER. She is disrespecting you as a MAN and you are letting her. You must IGNORE HER starting right now.

    After applying NO CONTACT starting right now, the very 2nd thing you need to do is BETTER YOURSELF as a MAN!

    Learn to dance, learn to cook, WORKOUT, learn new skills, buy new clothes, make new friends, do anything to better yourself.

    Lastly, once you applied NC + bettered yourself = you have just turned the tables on her. You will be winning this game. And you will have played the cards right.

    She will be the one wanting you back. Make her FEEN FOR YOU, until you see it through her actions. NOT WORDS! Only then, it will FINALLY be YOUR TURN TO CHOOSE if you want HER BACK! HAHAHAHA! =)

    Let the fishing line loose, and watch how fast the fish swims towards YOU!

    Pull that fishing line, and watch how fast that fish PULLS AWAY from you!

    Good luck.

    Listen to me and Superman- We both know from experience!! I'm telling you I was stupid and didn't listen to people at 1st and for 1 1/2 months after she dumped me I'd respond to my ex fiancés texts and so I blew it. Looking back now I wish the SECOND she mentioned going on break I wish I would have started no contact. I'd have her possibly so don't blow it like me.:confused::mad::(
  • Nov 8, 2009, 08:44 PM
    brokenheartls

    Holy.. I'm arab... only 1% of girls have sex here at this age :O
    I'm concerned about her kissing her ex not having sex !
    I'm arab-christian.. we don't just have sex.. girl won't accept it.. 99% at this age are virgins... trust me, I'm from Israel BTW ,
    Now I'm just concerned she will have even stronger feelings for her ex and just kiss him when she sees him... and not tell me :( I'm really afraid this will happen..
  • Nov 8, 2009, 08:48 PM
    supermannnnnn

    OHHH.. LOL.. If your so sure of this , then that's great for you! I tend to think kissing leads to touching leads to sex AS FAST AS you can say 123...

    In America nowadays, kids are having sex as early as 12 years old, 7th grade, jr high school... That's when I lost my virginity...

    LOL. You seem kind of young. How old are you?
  • Nov 8, 2009, 09:26 PM
    brokenheartls

    I'm 18.. she is 16.5 , I need help.. kissing in public won't lead to public sex trust me, I just don't want her to cheat on me..
  • Nov 8, 2009, 09:28 PM
    bjohnrupp

    Broken hearts- just because your girlfriend is Arab doesn't mean she's not having sex. How do you know only 1% of the girls have sex? Why are you so worried about her kissing him? Just move on, move on MOVE ON!!
  • Nov 8, 2009, 09:31 PM
    brokenheartls

    Look I have been awake for 22 hours.. finding an answer to her questions.. while her ex is probably smoking and sitting with hot chicks.. and not caring at all.. and my g.f is peacefully sleeping
    I'm the only one doing the hard work here.. please give me positive answers.. if I get dumped I won't get hurt.. because I already did ;)
  • Nov 8, 2009, 09:35 PM
    bjohnrupp
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by brokenheartls View Post
    look i have been awake for 22 hours.. finding an answer to her questions.. while her ex is probably smoking and sitting with hot chicks.. and not caring at all.. and my g.f is peacefully sleeping
    im the only one doing the hard work here.. please give me positive answers.. if i get dumped i wont get hurt.. because i already did ;)

    Were all giving you great advice. Do you want us to sugarcoat everything and just tell you what you want to hear? You can do whatever you want but I wish I listened to everyone else when I had my chance. I didn't and I got burned real bad. You have one chance- don't blow it.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 09:41 PM
    brokenheartls

    I'm really glad you good people helped me and I thank you a lot , I just want positive answers... my heart is already broken..
    So I won't get hurt a lot if she dumps me although I love her a lot!
    I just want her to do the right thing
  • Nov 8, 2009, 09:47 PM
    bjohnrupp

    She already did dump you- she's trying to let you down easy. Listen man- you will find someone eventually... you are still very young!
  • Nov 8, 2009, 10:15 PM
    supermannnnnn
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by brokenheartls View Post
    look i have been awake for 22 hours.. finding an answer to her questions.. while her ex is probably smoking and sitting with hot chicks.. and not caring at all.. and my g.f is peacefully sleeping
    im the only one doing the hard work here.. please give me positive answers.. if i get dumped i wont get hurt.. because i already did ;)


    Like john said. If you are here looking for people to sympathize with you , then you are on the wrong forum.

    If you want REAL answers then we already told you what to do.

    Listen to what you said...

    1) That other guy smoking , sitting with hot chicks...

    2) You GF doesn't even care and is SLEEPING.

    3) You are on this forum, crying and sobbing, and heartbroken...

    I will tell you something and I WILL NOT sugar coat it.

    You are the one being played! LOL..

    1) That other guy is the ALPHA MALE! With the hot chicks because he understands how to play. We already taught you what to do to beat this other guy... Or at least have the BEST CHANCE at it. We taught you how to become Alpha.

    2) Your GF could care less about you and is peacefully , carelessly, sleeping! LOL... You are not her priority!

    3) You are here, all sad... Is that acting like a REAL MAN??

    You answer this question.

    Good Luck.
  • Nov 8, 2009, 10:28 PM
    bjohnrupp

    Listen dude- Superman is right- she could care less about you anymore. Don't feel bad- our ex'es could care less about us at the end. As soon as you could drill this is your head you can start to move on... right now she's playing you bad. I got played because I was a wuss that didn't know better.

    I know you're hurt but there's nothing you could do or say to get her back. You're pushed all the way down to the lowest form of friend there is. That's what my ex did to me- all I was good enough for was a text once a week after she dumped me. Man up and don't take this bs. Trust me- you'll thank me later!
  • Nov 8, 2009, 11:47 PM
    brokenheartls

    I just went to her school.. she completely ignored me and continued walking.. I told her go to your ex I don't need you anymore and went back home... and then I talked to her sister ( 15 years old ) and she was on my side.. and told me although her ex is an.. she loves him more.. and I am like a rebound here or something.. maybe I should just let her go
  • Nov 8, 2009, 11:48 PM
    brokenheartls
    Her ex is an a**hole... that doesn't care..
    She will miss me someday..
    You don't know what you got until you lose it !
  • Nov 8, 2009, 11:51 PM
    bjohnrupp

    Told you man... now you have closure ----its over
  • Nov 8, 2009, 11:54 PM
    brokenheartls

    Its funny how people are attracted to the a**holes..
    And not to those who are nice and caring..
    Weird
  • Nov 8, 2009, 11:57 PM
    brokenheartls
    There is another way... my g.f listens to people who are experienced , my best friend may talk to her and solve this...
    She always listens to him because well.. he was an a**hole himself
    And now he is way nicer.. he will surely know what to say..
    I think I could count on him.. because he once solved a problem in our relationship... she just hates to admit that she is wrong.. she admits it to other people but not to me...
    I think he could at least solve something...
  • Nov 9, 2009, 01:10 AM
    bjohnrupp

    Well good luck man- you never know what could happen... were all pulling for you. You're right- a lot of girls do like the a$$holes but guys like me and you just have to be ourselves. If they don't like us for who we are than to hell with them. I'm not going to pretend to be someone I'm not just so a girl will like me.
  • Nov 9, 2009, 11:23 PM
    brokenheartls

    Me and my friend and my g.f talked.. she still loves me
    But she still didn't pick between me and her ex
    And she said that we should talk more with my friend because he did help us a lot.. and maybe he could bring us back together
  • Nov 10, 2009, 01:38 AM
    brokenheartls

    The problem now is : why doesn't my girlfriend tell me her problem..
    She said she is comfortable with my friend..
    She cried when she talked to him..
    That never happened when she talked to me
    Why is she not comfortable with me?

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:09 AM.