Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Relationships (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=277)
-   -   Dumped for another or rebound? (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=236544)

  • Jul 19, 2008, 03:51 AM
    Sammie66
    I hope it's normal to feel this way. I just have to accept that she's going to be in the background for a while at least and I might just have to distance myself from it.

    I don't like how it's worked out. She basically told me that I was this horrible person but still wants to be friends and she isn't going to go away. I'm usually the kind of person that would be friends with anyone, but it's an impossible situation. Anyone got any ideas?

    I can just envisage my brother and his wife going out for meals with my ex and her new man. It makes me sick. I just feel betrayed by everyone at the moment.
  • Jul 19, 2008, 06:01 AM
    Sammie66
    All this stuff is just mad.

    No contact, arguments and all that. Feeling like I might cry all the time.

    It feels so surreal. She's online just now on msn. Don't know whether I should talk to her or not. Probably not.

    I wish I could just have a normal conversation with her. It's weird.
  • Jul 19, 2008, 07:31 AM
    talaniman
    When you have those thoughts and feelings, which is absolutely normal, that's when you get busy. Even the smallest task will change your focus. Keep away from the notion to contact her in any way. Those actions only stir up the old feelings and makes them worse, so physically get up, and get busy, trim your mustache.
  • Jul 19, 2008, 10:34 AM
    Sammie66
    I spoke to her on msn. Bad move. I avoided discussing us and just chatted briefly about her/my work and looking for jobs. It felt really strained. I just said "got to go, later" and signed off because it was awkward.

    It makes me sick to think that she is "in love" so soon after. I went to the cinema with a friend and it was quite a sad love story film (Wall-E) and I almost cried.

    I was truly in love with this girl and I totally ruined it by panicking and ending it when I got cold feet and it made her look elsewhere for love.
  • Jul 19, 2008, 10:52 AM
    Ithappenstoall
    I was reading through your story, first off let me say that I am really sorry for what is happening to you and I can def see where yo are coming from, I am kind of going through the same thing right now and yes it hurts and I have done some of the same things like calling her and talking to her online but trust me it is not worth it, it has been a month and half from my 3 year relatioship and it sort of happened suddenly , and you keep thining that you screwed up but you cannot do that, you cannot think of what happened in the past or what you did, it will only drive you crazy, again been there.
    What I think you are going through is that you have no one else right now, believe me if you were talking to someone you would def be feeling better. You need time for yourself to think about what you want. It is about you now, stop thinking about her, what she is doing... it is for the best (I can tell you my story soemtime if you want to try and relate to it just let me know) This is where I am now. If you need help go see close friends and family, see what they think about this or better yet what they thought about her.
    From my experience , everyone that I knew told me that they were happy she had ended it with, because she was making me act like someone else, and making me feel insecure.
    Be strong buddy... it is not worth it.
  • Jul 19, 2008, 11:12 AM
    Sammie66
    Hey, I would like to hear your story. It's good to share problems.

    I've always been quite low on confidence and my friends and family noticed how I grew when I was with her. I was on top of the world for a good while. Now I'm back to what I was like before.

    I was reading this just now
    What Went Wrong? When Relationships Go From Hot To Cold
    It's quite good.

    I broke up with her at the early stages, but then realised I loved her. I think she broke up with me at the point where the "Honeymoon period" ended for her. She told me her previous relationships had fizzled out, so maybe she expects the relationship to be intense and as exciting all the way through. Don't get me wrong, it was still exciting for me, but I think I loved her on a deeper level. I could see us being together forever.

    My brother thinks I was more in love with the idea of love rather than her, but he has no idea how much I adored her.

    The thing I like to think of is that even after it ended when I smiled, she couldn't help herself smiling and nobody can take that away.
  • Jul 19, 2008, 07:22 PM
    Sammie66
    Another thought as I go on and on...

    I wish she could tell me what she really wants from me. She never told me while we were together and she isn't telling me now. Maybe she doesn't know and that's the whole problem.

    Does she genuinely want me as a friend? Or does she want a backup in case her new man isn't good enough? Has she moved on so quickly that I mean nothing to her and she can handle me as "just a friend". I know that she couldn't do that when I ended it once. I'm quite a logical person, so this emotional stuff is very alien to me!

    I just constantly feel like I might cry at the smallest thing. Only thing that seems to cheer me up is getting drunk at the weekends with friends.
  • Jul 19, 2008, 08:45 PM
    talaniman
    Quote:

    I'm quite a logical person, so this emotional stuff is very alien to me!
    That is exactly why you take the time for the emotional dust to settle, and do other things, so you gain a better perspective on your situation, and you can formulate coping strategies to deal with these situations.

    Quote:

    Only thing that seems to cheer me up is getting drunk at the weekends with friends.
    Yeah, that's how we did it in the old days and let me tell you, don't know what was worse, the hangover, the heartbreak, or the humility of drunken behavior that your buddies are only to willing to remind you of.
  • Jul 19, 2008, 11:38 PM
    Ithappenstoall
    OK well in a nutshelll I was going out with for 3 years, I was her first evetyting (sex, long relatioship), everything was going good, we had some ups and downs along the road but overall it was fine... now that I think of it she would drive me crazy sometimes with ridculous stuff but I would not see it then.. like she would get pissed at me for forgetting something that she told me 4 months ago. But that s besides the point. So we went on a trip together and came back and a few weeks later she called it off saying she needed time to think. I responded by saying that yes we need some space to figure things out. THat led to nothing really just that kept contact for 2 weeks here and there and one night I saw her out and she was being different. So I confroted her the next day saying that something was up and she said that she could not do this anymore and whatnot... and she had the guts to tell me that she had a thing for this guy that I had my suspicions about (even though she told me that that had no influence and her decision to break up)... now let me tell you I did evetything for this girl or at least a lot, would treat her like a queen, spending a lot for her caring for her. YOu see I felt that this was nice, I was comfortable and that this was going somewhere for a while a we had even spoken about this (her idea). But hey it didn't trun out that way and like I said eeryone is happy that it didn't because now that it was over they told me what they really thought about her (some did while I was with her but I would not listen), so that helped me get better. I am now working overseas and before I left we saw each other and it was an emotional meeting (whihc made me feel good to be honest, she even called the day of my flight), but later on I found out that that same night she had hooked up with that guy in a club... wish made me feel crazy. Now let me tell you , this guy is not the right person for her I know it because I know him... that does not mean that I am the right person... but I know he is less suited for her. At first I thought so many times of telling her that, but hey why should I, she messed up so it is her mistake to make if she gets serious with him? I could give her 20 times what that other guy could (financialy, culturaly... ) but hey she wants to go this let her, so many other girls that would be lucky to be with me.

    Now that you know a little bit about this this is what you need to do, let her make her mistake and if it is meant to be she will see it. You cannot froce someone to be with you. If you love them you need to let them go, and if they love you back they will come back to you. The pain you feel is good because it shows what kind of person you are, you took the risk to fall in love and you had a connection with someone, you at least did that. Now like me things did not really work out, but think about this way if you weer 3 years down the road and this had happened it would have been worst, better have this happen now when you have nothing together (kids, house,. ) then a couple years down the road where it would have been worst.

    Now I know this is still crazy but it will go away, I am sure that when you go out with your friend and those girls that you will have a good time and it will help you relax. It helped me when I did that. I am still not completely myself but I am much better and you will be to.
  • Jul 20, 2008, 02:34 AM
    Sammie66
    Hey thanks man, that does sound similar. It's the same here - I feel like this guy won't give her what she needs.

    She was my first and I made a few mistakes, like she told me how she hated that I wasn't affectionate in public. Now I'm quite a shy person, so it wasn't my instinct. However, if she had told me while we were together or made the move herself then I would have been happy to kiss/hug in public. I think most of these little things are just her making excuses though.

    Her new boyfriend maybe does all these things and makes her feel loved when I maybe didn't quite do that. He's had many girlfriends so has had the experience. I'm worried that somewhere down the line, the initial excitement wears off and she'll realise that they aren't suited or that she misses me (not that I'm being arrogant).

    She just never gave me a hint that she was unhappy and most of the things she says she wanted, so did I.

    Like I say, it feels like like she's looking for this perfect relationship to love, rather than loving the person.
  • Jul 20, 2008, 02:55 AM
    Ithappenstoall
    Perhaps, but now you need to stop thinking about what she is thinking... let her to whatever, you did all those things and that is good, if you were good t oher she will realize sooner or later... I tend to believe that everything will work out... you need to start looking at it like that because trust me is the truth, you were happy before you met her so why can t you be now. That s what I try and tell myself everyday, I have so much to give and hey if she says she can't be with me , then I will find someone in my own time. The key is to remember that you are doing this for you and not to try and to do all this to get her attention or get her back. She use to live with a friend who told me that she didn't deserve me and why am I still trying to fix things, she told me that I needed to look myself in the mirror and see what I am really worth, she also told that she was surprised that I was with her that long. Take a good look at yourself and see what do you want to do. Remember that we usually act irrationaly when we lose something, we start acting childish in the sense that we want to get back what we do not have, like a kid who just got his toy taken away from him, suddenly begins to cry because that toy is so important. If you are afraid of where you are now, hey I am afraid to but hey we have to work with. Try and get you confidence back in thinking that you are not the only one going through this and that when people tell everything will work out... they mean it honestly
  • Jul 20, 2008, 03:10 AM
    Sammie66
    I know that I should just walk away and move on. She's the one with issues, not me.

    I just feel teary eyed all the time at the moment. I actually cried for a month.
  • Jul 20, 2008, 08:17 AM
    Sammie66
    I still don't understand how she was so in love with me one minute, then a week later so in love with someone else that she moved in with him. It doesn't make sense to me at all.

    It's like I meant absolutely nothing to her, but I know it's not the case. I imagine she'll marry this guy. I wish I knew what was going through her head. I'm just such a wreck just now.

    It's like she decided on a whim that I wasn't the one for her and she's moved on and decided that this guy is the one without any reason. I wasn't that bad a boyfriend and she never complained. She was still doing loving things for up until the week she dumped me.

    It's as though this guy telling her he fancied her suddenly made her want to leave me. How could she be so fickle.
  • Jul 20, 2008, 01:25 PM
    Sammie66
    You guys must be sick of me now. I'm just so up and down right at the moment.

    I think she decided I didn't love her and acted on that. It's horrible. I loved her more than anything and maybe I did neglect her a little, but I don't think I did enough to warrant what I got. All she needed to tell me was that she was upset, not finish it.

    I held back from saying 3 things when we were together which would have probably saved my relationship. I didn't say them because I thought they were a bit foolish and rushed but I regret not saying them.

    1. I was lying in bed watching my ex sleep and she opened her eyes and said "What?" to which I replied "nothing" when I was thinking "I love you so much"
    2. My ex was telling me that she was wanting to move flats. I thought "Move in with me" but said "have you got any friends to move in with"
    3. We were lying in bed and my ex was telling me that it was her period the next day and we were talking and she said "It's good because at least it means I'm not pregnant" which I immediately thought "I would love it if you were pregnant" but said "yeah I guess"

    I held back from showing her how much I loved her. #1 should have been obvious to her that I adored her if I was just looking at her.
  • Jul 20, 2008, 11:24 PM
    Ithappenstoall
    Hey man... as long as you are talking to us and not to her it s good
  • Jul 20, 2008, 11:37 PM
    Sammie66
    I just had a dream about her and woke up really missing her.

    This is the worst I've felt for a bit. It's maybe because I'm tired. It's horrible
  • Jul 20, 2008, 11:37 PM
    Ithappenstoall
    Now you learned from this... think of it this way, we learn through our mistakes and you will know now how to act in this particular situation the next time around. I believe in never playing games, always being honest with yourself and with who you are. I told my ex that I was falling for her 5 months in and that took our relatioship to the next level and forward almost up to 3 years. Do I still think of her yes, do I wonder what she is doing or if she is with that other guy sometimes, BUT I always , always tell myself that if she doenst want to be with me, why do I keep doing this to myself. You seem like a good guy so why dwell on someone who clearly does not feel the same or doesn't know what she wants. YOu have no idea but I was in such a similar situation not too long ago and now after almost 2 months apart you start to realize that you are not the one missing out that much but she is, she had the chance to be with you and she blew it. DO NOT THINK about what has happened or what you should have said or what you didn't say. YOu need to let the past be the past and now focus on what is ahead On another note you need to be NC (if you are not doing that already) and be strong about it. So women don't know what they want and bam when they realize it it s too late. This shows you the knid of person they really are and not the person you thoought they were or imagine.
    Bottom line... do not think about the past, it will only hurt you.
  • Jul 21, 2008, 11:28 AM
    Sammie66
    Hey thanks man.

    I was pretty low this morning. I had my text all written out and was about to send it when I realised that it won't change anything. So I didn't send it. Breakthrough? Maybe.

    Then this afternoon I suddenly got really calm and thought "oh well, that ship has sailed". It wasn't a nice feeling, but a hell lot better than this "waiting for something to happen" feeling I've had.

    I get to the stage where I feel really teary eyed and have a lump in my throat. Does this sound familiar?

    I think she just got it into her head that I didn't love her and even though she wanted to be with me (I'm sure she did the day before she broke up with me. I could see it in her eyes) I just hurt her again on the Friday and it pushed her over the edge. Maybe she was waiting for me to slip up. I don't know. But to be with someone so soon and in love so soon and move in so soon. It HURTS.
  • Jul 21, 2008, 03:17 PM
    Sammie66
    She said her feelings began to change one night when she went home from mine because she had a sore back and was just going to bed. Her workmate (and new man) texted her and insisted that he went to hers even though she said "no" with chocolate to cheer her up and this made her "feel special".

    This was maybe a couple of weeks before she dumped me. This guy was blatently trying to get into her pants and she fell for it.

    Am I the only person that thinks this is ridiculous. I mean I offered to go to hers with her, but she said no because she was just going to sleep.

    Was she just using me? Is it more likely that she asked him round rather than him texting her? I mean, how did he know where she lived!?

    If she asked him over that night and was just using me as a safety net then she was just using me and it is sick. It makes more sense.
  • Jul 21, 2008, 04:14 PM
    Sammie66
    Or it was because I'd hurt her by dumping her and she was too scared of getting hurt again so didn't let herself commit.
  • Jul 22, 2008, 09:30 AM
    Sammie66
    Today has been up and down again.

    Was completely indifferent this morning. Couldn't care less about her.

    Then I got thinking again. Things still don't add up for me. The day before dumping me she was speaking about the future and saying "I want my friends to be your friends" and my mate said he could see she adored me.

    It's like someone convinced her, maybe herself, that I didn't love her. I did hurt her a bit that week, but nothing particularly bad. Just me being a bit of an idiot as usual.

    One thing I hate is how her story changed. In the beginning it was all about how we didn't fit, and I asked if there was someone else and she said "no, but I might start seeing someone from work" and next thing it was "I was looking forward to his texts more than yours" after she told me they hadn't really texted and it wasn't like that. I don't know which one to believe. All I know was she was really into me one minute, texting me all the time, and then a few days later she wasn't. Maybe she changed her story to be about him rather than me as her allegiance changed.

    I wish I could go back to the week before and undo the mistakes that led to the breakup. Bottom line is she decided to leave me for someone else, whether she liked/likes him more than me or not and there's nothing I can do.

    Love is cruel. One lesson I have learned is that I am a complete wimp. I'm scared of hurting people and scared of getting hurt. And that's why our relationship failed. We were both feeling the same.
  • Jul 22, 2008, 11:16 AM
    talaniman
    If you go back and reread your thread, you will see your caught in a very vicious loop, fueled by your rejection. You are your biggest enemy and must endeavor to break that cycle you allow yourself to be dragged in.
    Quote:

    Then I got thinking again.
    Every time you get to thinking, get up, and do something physical, shaving, cycling, polish your Sunday shoes, anything, to change your focus from her, to something else. That way you will not have to re-feel those feelings she left you with, nor ask the same questions over again, for which there is NO ANSWER FOR!!

    If you have a good friend, let him know you'll call him to distract yourself, but never talk about her, that may help. If need be make out a to do list, and keep it handy, for those times you "get to thinking".
  • Jul 22, 2008, 11:31 AM
    hjpan
    She's just another piece of scratch paper. Throw her in the trash can and don't contact her at all. Even if she texts or calls you, don't answer/respond. Seriously, you have NOTHING wrong except spending less time with her than before. I was in the same situation as you were; I dated my girlfriend (now ex) of one year four months. I told her way before that I was going to be busy and I will be neglecting her for a bit. She said she'd understand and accept the situation.

    A week before finals, she dumps me and tells me she has no feelings for me anymore cause I'm never there to be with her.

    For me, I feel like sh*t and my feelings are up & down...
    Recently, I started to work out a bit, read more dating books, visit some friends and teachers etc.

    The best idea I can suggest to you is to forget about her and go on with your life.

    Or even better, show up in front of her house with a nice car and a hot girl =]
  • Jul 22, 2008, 04:39 PM
    Sammie66
    I guess it all boils down to the fact that she cheated on me (maybe not physically) by getting close to this guy and hiding her "friendship". The hard part is that she doesn't regret it at all.

    I really hope she gets what she deserves. I'm not even sure she told him she was seeing someone.

    Thanks everyone for your continuing support
  • Jul 22, 2008, 06:43 PM
    hjpan
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Sammie66
    I guess it all boils down to the fact that she cheated on me (maybe not physically) by getting close to this guy and hiding her "friendship". The hard part is that she doesn't regret it at all.

    I really hope she gets what she deserves. I'm not even sure she told him she was seeing someone.

    Thanks everyone for your continuing support

    Join the NC Calender thread!

    https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/other-...ii-227290.html
  • Jul 23, 2008, 09:36 AM
    Sammie66
    Feeling better today. This website is good for venting.

    I think after me breaking up with her she decided we weren't going to last and that she had to move on. I think she got it into her head that I didn't love her and was just using her so it would be OK for her to use me while she was finding another relationship.

    She completely betrayed me.

    It's just so tragic because she didn't have to move on because I did love her. I just had fears that took time to get over. Unfortunately what she has done has put the fears back even worse. I hate how she has made me feel empty and as though I am just existing.

    I think when I told her that I loved her she did get a shock, because she (or someone else - probably her new man) had convinced her that I didn't. But her excuse that "It was too much a shock to go back" is just crap.

    I worry for her because I get the impression that he loves himself more than her. I'm in complete turmoil because I want to hate her, but I can't and I want her to feel the pain I do, but at the same time I don't.

    I just wish she'd never taken that stupid ing job. I even said to her at the time that we'd drift apart and she'd fall for a barman. I said it not because I didn't trust her, but just that I was gutted we wouldn't see each other anymore and it's the kind of thing that happens all the time. I reminded her of that after we broke up and she said "Nice to see you had faith in us" and I said "Well, you're the one that has run away" and she started to cry.

    I miss her.
  • Jul 23, 2008, 09:51 AM
    Sammie66
    Just went on to my sister in laws bebo to wish her congratulations for getting a new job. Of course there are messages from my ex there discussing the job. I don't know how I'm meant to deal with this. My ex is now closer to my sister in law than me. It was my brother that told me about her getting the job.

    Is this going to ruin the relationship with my family? I can feel myself distancing myself from my sister in law because it hurts every time I see her texting or speaking about her pole dancing class she takes with my ex. The only way I can stop the hurt is to hurt my sister in law by distancing myself.

    Anyone been in a similar situation?
  • Jul 23, 2008, 10:02 AM
    talaniman
    I think you should do what it takes to heal, and make explanations later.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 12:26 AM
    Sammie66
    It's really tough because if it affects my sister in law, it affects my brother, then my parents etc etc.

    The way it ended annoys me, she clearly still wanted to be with me, but instead of working things through, she decided that she had to move on. She didn't put the effort in to communicate with me and just bottled everything up. When we argued after we finished she was bringing up things from the really really early days when I was just getting to know her. She never told me that these things annoyed her.

    What I don't understand is how this guy is suddenly the love of her life and I was just a blip.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 12:38 AM
    Sammie66
    After a month of being dumped I sent her a long heartfelt email telling her how I felt about her. I ended up saying "I love you because you are crazy" or (nicer) words to that effect.

    Next thing is her bebo status is "X is crazy" which means that my opinion still held value with her then.

    Now we just don't talk. I think it makes it easier for both of us. She is still getting over me although she is with someone else. It doesn't make sense to me.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 07:27 AM
    talaniman
    As long as your still trying to figure out her actions and thoughts, your not thinking of yours, and that means your not taking your own feelings to heart. Don't be confused, ask yourself what's more important, and you will see as the emotions settle a more realistic view of what was really going on, through more objective eyes.

    I understand your rants, as we all do when we are coping with the shock, and rejection of a break up, but at some point positive proactive action has to be taken, especially since she is still close to your family.

    I think it important that you talk individually to them, as their support through this would be great. There is no reason why you must lose your own family after this loss, and you won't, with some honest communication. Remember your healing comes first, and I think they will understand.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 09:25 AM
    Sammie66
    I blew NC. I'm an idiot. She didn't reply which is good, but I hate myself for failing AGAIN.

    I sent her a text asking why she never ever told me when I had upset her - this is what I see as the main problem. We NEVER argued and I noticed that she would always agree with me on things, never make the first move on anything and I tried to get her to do this. I tried so many different ways to get her to tell me her frustrations but she never gave in. She just bottled it up until the end.

    As soon as I sent it I sent another saying "don't bother replying. theres no point" then about an hour later I sent "That night you were in work till 4am, you weren't working were you (She probably was having after work drinks with her new man). You cheated on me in every way possible and lied to me. I was only ever honest with you"

    Then I sent "Sorry. Don't even know why im speaking to you"

    Then I sent "Sorry. I'm now the psycho ex. I've just never been so hurt and betrayed before and you seem to think i was horrible to you. I was only ever honest. I miss you"

    So now I'm all wound up. What an idiot. I hope she changed her number.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 10:30 AM
    talaniman
    Look at what you have done to yourself, did it help??
  • Jul 24, 2008, 11:12 AM
    Sammie66
    No. I was being stupid. I've been doing so well. I just got a bit depressed at work and thought about her.

    https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/relati...ed-133537.html

    I'm scared that this story is similar to mine, except I loved her. I didn't meet her parents though and was reluctant to hang with her friends after the first breakup.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 11:16 AM
    hjpan
    People screw up... just don't contact her again...

    For me, I wish my ex got a new boyfriend who she fuqed, gotten pregnant, and her boyfriend runs off..

    I just hope that happens to her.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 11:17 AM
    Sammie66
    I wish I could hate her but I loved her too much.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 11:39 AM
    talaniman
    I get she was your first, and know how hard that is. You fell hard in 7 months and being honest she was a stranger you barely knew, but those intense feelings got the best of you and now you must cope with the, and the feelings of rejection, and the pain and shock that its over.

    You just need to get busy, getting yourself back, and deal with the pain with positive actions. Reread the 4 stickies, and really study them.
  • Jul 24, 2008, 11:40 AM
    hjpan
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Sammie66
    I wish I could hate her but I loved her too much.

    Compare my relationship of one year four months?

    That's nothing... not to offend you but 7 months is not a very long time...
  • Jul 24, 2008, 11:49 AM
    Sammie66
    Time is nothing, it's how you feel about the person and how it ended.

    Every situation is different. I just wish I wasn't such a psycho just now
  • Jul 24, 2008, 12:10 PM
    Romefalls19
    Yea man, you seriously need to delete her number from your phone. You are letting this broad into your head way too much. She has you by the b*lls, I'm going to be completely blunt with you as I have followed your story from the beginning. Feel free to hit me with a reddie but you will thank me later.

    DELETE everything you have in ways to contact her, phone number, myspace, Facebook, cut the string to the tin can(old people know what I'm talking about). Reclaim your manhood from her by showing her you are strong enough to walk away like a MAN. Sure she broke your heart, she's a cold calculated b!tch, what more is there to say? NOTHING! Take all of her crap that's in your room down and box it up. Hang pictures of some nice attractive models or motivational quotes(that's what I did) If you don't stop the way you are acting you are either going to have one or both of the following happen 1. You will be known as the pyscho stalker or 2. Restraining order

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 11:34 AM.