Wow yea I took my time to read all of and it was very helpful. I can see where it was like the ocean ups and downs and sometimes calm. I can compare the situation that I'm in with yours but your girl at least said something to you about wanting the break. Mine she just went ahead which is really upsetting and just makes me feel really low. I'm 19 also ( I think I read somewhere where it said your 19. And she's 17 I know there's a gap and when people read this they will just consider it high school love blah blah.
I'm currently out of high school waiting for class to start I'm going to become a firefighter. And she's a senior in high school still. And really her thing was before I knew about this guy was that she wanted to have a "life" and be able to hang out with her friends. Like I have said before we really didn't have a healthy relationship together we were around each other every day living together. And I can and will take the blame for that because at times she would ask to go out and stuff and I would say sure but I would make her feel bad and so it was like she felt as if she had to stay. And I know that pushed her really far away.
And this "new" guy is a part of all her friends at school so it just sucks because like I have these mood swings where I'm confident that oh he's just a rebound guy they are only happy because she had her cake and was able to eat it to. And then I become really low and thinking ah crap I'm never going to be with her again...
I know right now she's miserable I can see her myspace well not the whole thing but her status and I can tell me giving her clothes back to her put a lot of stress on to her.