Quote:
My problem is that when taking a shower or running water for dishes, the water gets ice cold every time the pump comes on.
That is strange. From the quote above, it seems that the pump is constantly cutting off/on, so I would think this is not really connected to the pump, unless the poster is saying that when the pump cuts off, the hot water comes back on. Is that the case? If not, then the problem would seem to be with the hot water heater. Broken dip tube, or bad heater element on the bottom.