Is my accountant playing things too safe? In 2011 my company brought in a total of $82k and on my personal taxes I paid $1100.00 to Federal and $424.00 to state. The following year we made $73k and on my personal taxes I got 142.00 back from the feds, and paid the state 21.00. This year the company made $74k and now I'm looking at paying out $3000.00 in April. Doesn't seem right to me. Seems to be a bit much.