I lived for 11 and a half years in US and I returned to brazil in 08/2012. I paid my taxes all this years, and I have a 9 Years old doughter who was born in US. Will I qualify for the 2013 immigration reform?

How were you paying taxes if you were an illegal? Because you needed either a SSN or an ITN number to do that, and they didn't hand them out to illegals. If you were here on a VISA legally or a Green card... you would have had those.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by smoothy

How were you paying taxes if you were an illegal? Because you needed either a SSN or an ITN number to do that, and they didn't hand them out to illegals. If you were here on a VISA legally or a Green card...you would have had those.

---

The same requirement to pay and file taxes applies equally to people legal or illegal. People who don't have an SSN can get an ITIN to file taxes.

I don't disagree the obligation isn't and wasn't always there... it's just that you can't pay SSI.. and FICA as well as your other taxes... without it... and they don't hand them out to people who aren't here legally. They aren't even happy to hand them out to people that are... as I found out trying to get one for my wife years ago... which they flat out refused to do until she was issued her green card.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by smoothy

I don't disagree the obligation isn't and wasn't always there....it's just that you can't pay SSI..and FICA as well as your other taxes....without it...and they don't hand them out to people who aren't here legally. They aren't even happy to hand them out to people that are.....as I found out trying to get one for my wife years ago....which they flat out refused to do until she was issued her green card.

---

Times have probably changed then. ITINs are issued regardless of immigration status NOW. Both resident and non resident aliens may have payment obligations under the IR code.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tickle

Times have probably changed then. ITINs are issued regardless of immigration status NOW. Both resident and non resident aliens may have payment obligations under the IR code.

---

Tough to do when employers are required in many cases to verify they are even here legally... since most illegals use false papers... and fake Id's. And paying taxes under someone else's ID doesn't mean they actually paid THEIR taxes...

Otherwise why even bother with the VISA process.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by smoothy

Tough to do when employers are required in many cases to verify they are even here legally...since most illegals use false papers...and fake Id's. And paying taxes under someone elses ID doesn't mean they actually paid THEIR taxes....

Otherwise why even bother with the VISA process.

---

Could be some people are actually more honest than you expect them to be.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tickle

Could be some people are actually more honest than you expect them to be.

---

On a side note, the Visa process isn't all that easy nowadays, to enter US or CDA, and not guaranteed after paying fees and jumping through hoops to comply to all regulations. Once an applicant is over here and in front of the interviewing official, entrance can be denied on a small technicality and back they go!