I have a crush on Guy 1, this jaw-droopingly, cute, popular, funny and handsome guy. Then here comes Guy 2, and he likes me, he's from my old school and I made the biggest mistake of liking him last year. The thing is, I can actually picture Guy 2 being my ideal perfect boyfriend. He's definitely sweet, nice, funny, cute and I get along with him so well. While Guy 1 is all pretty new for me since he's one of the new kids. I can't bring myself to like Guy 2 and not like Guy 1. Please help? Any advice or tips or suggestions? Anything would help. :)

-Jen

What are we supposed to tell you? You know these two guys better than we ever will. Pick the one that treats you the best and makes you happy.

See which one shows more interest in you and go with that choice.