We just put in a new sink drain and try as we might, it doesn't seem to be housed in there correctly. We are having a difficult time getting it seated level, and there is a gap (which my husband filled with putty). The gap is nearly 1/8" all around, not flush like the other (original) side. The diameter of the outside rim/flange is 4 1/2 ". Supposedly the one we bought is standard, but it is not quite 4 1/2". If we get one that advertises that it is 4 1/2", rather than just "standard", will that make a difference.

Also, the sink is about 35 years old. Are we just not going to be able to find a good fit because of obsolescence?

Lastly, is that putty thing going to work? Three days into it, and it's still---well, like putty! Would not using the sink for a few days help?

Or do we just need to call a plumber?

Thanks!

If you are talking about the basket strainer that fits in the middle of the sink, they are all standard size but if you got one that is made of plastic it may be a little shorter in length. The way to install this strainer, if that is what we are talking about, is to make a rope out of the putty and put it under the rim of the strainer and push it down into the opening in the sink. Then use the rubber ring next to the underneath of the sink and then the paper ring and then the metal nut. Tighten the nut till is squeezes out the putty and pulls down flat to the sink.