Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Islam (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=423)
-   -   Why at this time non muslims are much much advanced in science than muslims? (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=498767)

  • Aug 16, 2010, 12:31 PM
    tanzeelaanum
    Why at this time non muslims are much much advanced in science than muslims?
    I am saying this because I am particularly interested in physics at this time and I think that science would be the most appropriat language for expressing our religon to non muslims.but most muslims seem to be far away from the scientific knowledge and seem to be backward.we muslims are not fully equipped to answer non muslims' arguments.it seems we lack intelligence to advance in science.this picture of muslims is un-understandeable.On the other hand I find the most brilliant physicist Stephen Hawking stillsearching for the cause of his birth i.e.he is still far away from"hidayat" even after such struggle.I found my grandmother(illetrate) much better than Stephen Hawking!I am still confused why it is that Allah has blessed nonmuslims with such scientific knowledge.
  • Aug 16, 2010, 12:42 PM
    smoothy

    Because Allah (who is not my god) didn't bless anyone with anything Musim or not. Knowledge is earned through study and exploration. That is why the west is far more advanced than the Muslim world is.

    Most Islamic religious leaders wish to control what information you have and have acess to. In the west you are free to learn what you are capable of learning and are willing to learn.

    God blessed you with the ability to learn. What you do with that and how far you go with it up to you.

    Believing something that is false is not knowledge, that is what the uneducated do. Just because an elder or Religious leader says something is so, doesn't make it so.
  • Aug 17, 2010, 06:14 PM
    smoothy

    Simple anwer to all of this... no muslim nation is ahead of any western nation in Science or Physics. And haven't been for the last 1,000 years. You are only made ot believe this by religious leaders that feed you lie after lie. And shield you from the truth obout the outside world.

    Think Muslims Created the COmputer? THink Muslims created the Internet... think Muslims created the computer operating systems? Nope... all were non-western Muslims.

    Any Muslims travel to the Moon... any Muslims build a space station? What Muslims are top scientists? Physicists? Of course... you know the answer because I can't name one. Blame that on Islam and the Imams that what to control every part of your lives... They are tyrants that keep you from progressing like the rest of the world has.

    Allah isn't our god... and I won't even say what we think about him... but its not nice. Our God blessed us with the ability to learn... Our form of government gave us the Tools to do so... without some idiot religious leader telling us what to think, and how to think. THe west does no tollerate Child molesters... and it doesn't tollerate treating women as second or third class citizens. Women are equals to man in non-muslim west, not virtual slaves.

    God created us in his own image and gave us free will... he didn't create servants to Religious leaders.
  • Jan 9, 2011, 08:59 PM
    joenahhas
    You are wrong. Arabs are more advanced than all of western nations and the rest of the world. Real Arabs real time physics by Joe Nahhas . Google to joenahhas and click on scribd link
  • Jan 9, 2011, 09:01 PM
    joenahhas
    Comment on smoothy's post
    You are wrong. Arabs are more advanced than all of western nations and the rest of the world.
    Read Arabs real time physics by Joe Nahhas . Google to joenahhas and click on scribd
  • Jan 10, 2011, 05:53 AM
    smoothy
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by joenahhas View Post
    You are wrong. Arabs are more advanced than all of western nations and the rest of the world. Real Arabs real time physics by Joe Nahhas . Google to joenahhas and click on scribd link

    Is that what they teach you at your Mosque.

    Who invented Radio, The Internet, Computers, Satellites, TV, Telephoes, WHo Put Man on the moon, Who created MOST of the medial teatments out there today... It was the wast, it certainly wasn't Muslims.

    Just an FYI... today its 2011... The Muslim world stopped progressing at the year 700.

    You haven't proven One single thing that's more advanced in the Muslim world... And you are spewing out of your butt that Muslims are more advanced in everything while priving you are advanced in nothing. But then, if you lived in the real world this would be apparent to you.

    Run out of your meds?

    None of those people you mentioned are anyone of merit in today's world...


    Have you ever actually been outside a muslim area into the real world. We have electricv, Lights, Computers in our houses, We have INternet at home... TV's... we even have air conditioning and central heat. We don't NEED internet Cafe's because everyone has computers and we have free wifi at the Cafes, I have Internet, Cable TV and Phone in my home via fiber optic cable, I have several Cars... we have stores to buy things... and don't have to haggle with Mohammed on the corner to get some goat milk (yuck). Or females get to go to school, and GASP even have Jobs. And Drive cars if they want. We don't nake our wome hide under bags.
    OUr Hositals actually have durgs , Qualified Doctors, and any of the specialty equipment ready to use most of the Muslim world DREAM about having in their medical centers.

    If the Muslim world was so damned abvanced... why are you keeoping it such a great secret from everyone including your fellow Muslims? Did a Muslim doctor just discover pennicillin last month? We've had it for a VERY long time already.


    Why did the King of Saudi Arabia come to the USA for surgery if the Muslims were so advanced? They might be advanced compaired to the Sudan. Where baked Bricks would be an advancement over dried mud bricks.
  • Jan 14, 2011, 07:19 PM
    joenahhas
    If you are standing in front of your house and a car is moving away, then you would see as if the car shrunk. It is nit the car that is shrunk but your eye see a size of the car indicating a different location of the car and not a different size of the car. If a car has size A and you see it at a different location as size B then A = B + (A - B). If you want to see the car as a percentage of its size then divide by B to get: (A/B) = (B/B) + (A - B)/B or (A/B) = 1 + (A-B)/B this is real time scale. No if you want to measure a quanity C the multiply by C to get
    (A/B)C = C + [(A-B)/B]C
    Quantum mechanics = Newton's mechanics + relativistic mechanics
    This what the Arabs said in 950 AD
    Assume C = planet Mercury angular velocity space tarvel = [2(PI)/88x24x3600](36526/88)(180/Pi)(3600)=70.75
    [(A-B)/B]C = [(A-B)/B]70.75; A = Sun Mercury distance = 58.2 million kilometers
    B = 149.6 million kilometers = Earth disatnce from Earth
    (A-B)/B = 0.61

    [(A-B)/B]70.75 = 0.61 x 70.75 = 43 visual Illusions
    Go look at Mercury Perihelion advance in wikipedia by einstein
    he says the 43 seconds of an arc per century is time travel and it is a visual illusion

    Arabs do noot believe in time travel? You have a ticket from Eisnetin the time tarvel bus driver?
    Arabs do not believe in the big bang? Did you hear a big bang?
    Arabs do not believe in gravity waves? Did you catch a gravity wave?
    Arabs do not believe in dark energy? Did you funnel dark energy with a hose?
    Arabs do not believe in the atomic shells?
    Arabs do not believe that the world is made of nucvlear aoprticles that dies and rebirth a billion billion times a second?
    Europe sent Napoleon to Eygpty in 1882 to stop Eygpt from building an armada to protect its rising powers and science
    China Mangolia Persia India Russia and Earstern Europe attacked bagdad altogether in 1258 to stop the power of muslims
    Iraq sent a satalite around Earth in 1990 and all solid sate industreis were Iraqi made
    when you have constant wars there is little room to show greatness
    Arab scientists when they try to publish end up dead!
    And modern sciences mostly trash
  • Jan 14, 2011, 07:22 PM
    joenahhas
    Arabs and Muslims have had made and make great discoveries everyday but all of it stays in hiding because it means death not only by dictators but also by spies assassins secret police. Arab scientists have no protection but have certain death
  • Dec 21, 2011, 09:37 AM
    SALIDM
    Gooday My Friend, I wish to suggest to you a book 'THE QUR'AN AND MODERN SCIENCE' by Maurice Bucaille(French Academy of Medicine), This might help you in your question. Thanks SALI
  • May 7, 2014, 07:09 PM
    paraclete
    To answer your question, history shows that civilisations flourish and then decline. When they flourish they show great leadership and innovation but in decline they pass the baton to others. Islamic civilisation has been in decline for a long time, in many places just at subsistence level, that is not an environment where science and technology flourish. Religion doesn't lead to development, you can see in all societies that it leads to stagnation unless thought is allowed to be expressed and refreshed. Islam as much as any other and more than most has stymied thought, by it's emphasis on rote learning
  • May 7, 2014, 07:30 PM
    Fr_Chuck
    First, Muslims are not just in the Middle East, there are Muslims in Africa, in America, in China.

    Those living in America have the same education and same advancement as all Americans. The Muslims living in China are educated to the same levels as all others in China.

    The education system in some society is behind others. It has to do with where the government and society puts its importance.

    The issue with science is often, many who go into science, lose or question part or all of their religious beliefs.

    And of course, science is no way to explain religion, religion is explained though the Holy Teachings of that faith.

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 11:54 AM.