Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Credit (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=84)
-   -   How I should craft my pro se defense against credit card lawsuit (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=467090)

  • Apr 25, 2010, 07:46 PM
    irismagnolia
    How I should craft my pro se defense against credit card lawsuit
    In February, I was served by a Sheriff's Deputy who presented me with a document from the Magistrate Court of Cobb County GA that said that Midland Funding LLC, Assignee of Citibank, N.A. that stated that they intended to sue me for $3,165.97 plus $74.50 court costs as of that date and all future costs of the suit. The attorney listed was Dennis Henry of Frederick J. Hanna and Associates, a so-called law firm/junk debt collector that has been discussed on many discussion boards in terms of their questionable collection practices.

    Because they didn't provide any information in terms of account information (I've had several accounts with Citibank in the past and I know my husband is paying on one that was in my name with Home Depot that he used was issued through Citibank), when the account was opened, etc. I filed my formal answer denying the debt and stating that the plaintiff had refused to verify alleged debt and was in violation of the FDCPA. I also submitted a request for production of documents and a request for admissions and had these documents notified and sent certified return receipt to both the Attorney's Office and the Magistrate Court within the 30 day response window.

    The attorney's office responded back with a letter asking for the opportunity to discuss the case in further detail and explore payment arrangements and sent another letter on the same day saying that pursuant to Uniform Magistrate Rule 40 discovery requests are not only disfavored by the courts but are also considered a nullity when filed without leave of court.

    I received notification from the court that my court date is on May 3. My question is how should I craft my defense? I've been unemployed since September 2008 due to a layoff and admittedly, most of my credit cards have taken a backseat to being able to keep a roof on my family's head and food on the table through my husband's income. Should I make a Motion for Dismissal due to the law firm's failure to answer my requests for production of documents and admissions? What if they bring the requested documentation to court instead? If after going to court, the judge decides in Midland's favor, should I wait to file bankruptcy then or should I do this before I go to court? Should I leave my checkbook at home in case they try to garnish my wages (which is unemployment)?

    Any advice is greatly appreciated.
  • Apr 25, 2010, 07:59 PM
    Fr_Chuck

    Not sure what leaving your check book at home, since they will ask you for social security number and name of your bank,

    First they are required to provide you with proof of debt, that is a federal law, so if they refuse to do so, you should have the case dismissed merely by their refusal to do so. You maintain at the start of court, that you dispute this is your debt and make them prove it is in court ( normally they can't)

    They were required to furnish this within a time frame of your request, so you still ask for a dismissal since they did not give you the info within proper time frame

    You may want to start not keeping your money in the bank,
  • Oct 17, 2010, 09:52 PM
    rolandstein
    Go to ezzani.com. I bought the book "how i beat capital one and legal recovery law offices" and used the motions, answer, and other strategies and they (3 credit card lawyers) quit early. It is only 15 bucks. He has about 12 affirmative defenses... that's just the start
  • Aug 12, 2012, 06:05 AM
    Tami Mann
    My case is identical to this. Can you please provide information as to the outcome of this case?
  • Jan 14, 2013, 08:10 AM
    andjustice4all
    I'm in court w/Midland too. I went to Gwinnet County courthouse and got a copy of the case Midland Funding v. Jill Sheridan. She won her case & I'm following her strategies. Copies of the case at the magistrate courthouse will run around $25-30. Some of her actual court docs are also online on her website and others through a keyword search:
    http://www.scribd.com/collections/3042742/Frederick-J-Hanna-and-Associates-Midland-Funding-v-Sheridan-Gwinnett-Georgia

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:14 PM.