Originally Posted by
emopunk7
I apologize for the harshness above. I don't think they understand what you are trying to say. I will save the day.
You are saying that you and your girlfriend broke up at one point. Then you got back together. Then you broke up again, except during this time, you began to have eyes for someone else. Nonetheless, you are now with your girlfriend again, but you are not in love anymore. Now you want to know if you should leave your current girlfriend and chase the other girl. Even if the other girl says no, you will be fine single. I see no wrong on your part at all. So you're not in love anymore. You are thinking of ending things before chasing a "what if". This is very admirable.
The advice is simple. Break up. Then chase the other girl. I think you already know how to handle it. Perhaps you are just scared. Life is short. You can't force yourself to love. You are not married so, break up and then and only then, do your chasing. Keep us updated!