I guess I'm finally over the baggy phase I was in, I'm thinking about going down to XXL or XL. I'm 6'4, rather thin. When I try on Large some of my skin is exposed so that's out of the question. Should I try on XL for a change?

I'm wearing a XXL shirt at the moment and it goes past my pants, it's not super baggy but it has a bit of bag to it. Blah I don't know I'm not good at this lol, they all feel equally comfortable I just don't want to have the shirt swamp me and actually look good for a change.

Any advice? Thanks in advance.

If L fits nicely, buy it in Tall so the bottom edge falls below your waistline. I really think you need to check out the Tall version. Try different styles, like polo with a collar or a hoodie or a mock turtleneck or a zip front.

I agree. With your height you should probably be shopping at a big and tall store or at least stores that have tall sized apparel.

Even GAP has tall sizes online. If you are slim PLEASE do not wear such wide shirts they will only make you look bigger. If you can't find anything you like belt your shirt at the waist to give accent to your waist.