Two juveniles were charged with criminal damage in the second degree. They have already paid restitution for the damages they did and we have to go to court in couple of weeks. They have never been in trouble until this incident.
I'm a little concerned about what will happen to them. I know the law where I live says that if a person is convicted of this crime then the punishment is no less than one year and no more than five years in prison.
Does anyone know what could possibly happen to them? And does it matter that they have already taken care of the damage they did?
And should I get a lawyer for them?

Hello Irish:

What can happen? Nothing good! If you were facing five years in the slam, would you hire a lawyer for yourself? I'll bet you would. The state has one. These kids should too.

Does it matter that they've already taken care of the damage? Yes. How much? I don't know. Better than NOT taking care of the damage.

excon

First of all, the punishments you quote are for adults. If the juveniles in question are being dealt with the juvenile court system then all bets are off. The fact that they've already made restitution will definitely weigh in their favor. Hopefully it's documented. The judge will have considerable latitude in any sentence (s)he'll propose. My guess is that, for a first offense and restitution already made they'll get a short probation term and/or some community service.

Thanks that sort of sets my mind at ease and yes the restitution already made is well documented. I'm still going to get a lawyer for them anyway. Also the person whose property was damages is writing a letter in their favor for us to take to court. Hopefully that will help them out.

Perhaps the person who's property was damaged can be persuaded to drop the charge.

Hmm. No lawyer fees... worth a try!