I can not remember the title of this movie and it is killing me! There were a group of children who find a broken record piece in an envelope. The record is a major clue to solving an old mystery so they decide to look for all the other pieces. I remember that one piece was in a well. Eventually, they find the pieces, play the record, and end up at a merry-go-round. One of the kids scratches the paint off the eye of one of the horses and reveals a different color underneath. Once this is done, the ghosts of all the people affected by the record are released.

Please help me!

"Are You Afraid of the Dark?" The Tale of the Silver Sight: Part 1 (2000)

That's it! Thank you SO much!

I have been looking for this movie forever! I used to tell it to the kids at my daycare; freaked them out. =]

You're very welcome.