White-Rodgers Thermostat 1F86-244 not working in AUTO during the day
I have a White-Rodgers Thermostat model 1F86-244 and I seem to be having a problem with its operation during the day. For the past few days when I get home from work the room temperature is really cold (thermostat is set at 68, but the room temp is about 56) as if the heat has not been running during the day. The thermostat is normally set with the fan to AUTO and the temp on HEAT. When I get home, if I switch the thermostat to OFF and then back to HEAT, it will kick on and start to heat up and the fan will come on to blow air. After a while, the house will eventually heat back up, and it will work properly throughout the night and morning, but once I get home from work the next day, it's the same all over again. I worry about leaving my animals at home during the day if the heat is not coming on, especially as it starts to get colder.
I have tried just about everything, including resetting the thermostat according to the instructions and I have replaced the AA batteries in it. It is not a programmable model, so it should be keeping the same temperature for which it is set. This has happened several days in a row, so I do not expect that any kind of power outage is causing the problem. The thermostat is only a few years old, but should I have it replaced, or is there something else I should check? Furnace is a Rheem natural gas, forced air unit and it seems to be working OK after I turn the thermostat off and back on when when I get home.
Please help!
Thanks!