Possible defective phone jack and goo
I have Comcast Digital Voice with two phone jacks in my house (not including my telephony modem). Last night, I noticed that the phone in my living room had no dial tone, but the phone/fax in my bedroom did. I unplugged my living room phone, put it in my bedroom and it worked just fine. Then, I took the phone back to the living room and plugged it up, then called my landline from my cell phone. The phone on the dial-tone-less jack rang. I had a friend pick it up and we were able to hear each other, but there was static on the line and it eventually gave out. Does this sound like something that can be easily fixed by buying a $3 phone jack from Home Depot? I'd rather not get Comcast out here and charge me $50 for something I can do for less than $5 and 30 minutes of my time. My telephony modem has all the lights lit up that indicate normal operation, so that's why I think the problem may be with the living room jack and not with any inside wiring.
Also, my phone jacks are all baseboard-mounted and when I looked inside the connector, I saw a goo-like substance with the consistency of melted plastic or rubber cement. My other jack doesn't have this. Is this goo supposed to be there?