Hi I really need some help and would totally appreciate it. I had been dating this girl for 4 years and we recently broke up a couple of days into college. We said it would just be a break and we would get back together once we got the whole "being free" out of our system. We both agreed we needed space. She has been my life the past 4 years and I care about her so much and want nothing but happiness for her. While here I met a girl who is like no other I have met before. She has had a lot of past relationship traumas whereas I had only been with one person my entire life. We had sex and I've been spending a lot of time with her which I totally enjoy. She makes me feel so... different than my girlfriend... not necessarily better, but different and I like it. I am so confused and have absolutely no idea what to do. I have told her that I just got out of a 4 year relationship. I don't know if I want to just jump into a new thing but I really like getting to know her. I also don't just want to stop and say I can't do this because I like her and then ill be just another terrible person who used her and then bailed. She's a totally cool girl but after 4 years I'm so confused and scared that I can't sleep at night because I'm so worried that I'm going to make the wrong decision and I can't bare to hurt either of them
Please any thoughts would help its really tough to deal with