Could light go through a gravitational field unbent?
Thank you for your input, to start with, I too have great respect for Einstein and his theories. I also am open to ideas that contradict his theories as well. After all, that's what physics is, trying out new ideas, and expanding them when we realize they aren't complete. In fact I have wondered myself if particles couldn't tunnel across the barrier of the speed of light. However, the problem is a bit more complicated, as would be expected, since quantum tunneling depends on the potential energy needed to go over the barrier in the first place. Well, the speed of light barrier would have to be regarded as an infinite potential well, making it difficult to figure out if quantum tunneling is possible for this barrier. Anyway, just speculations of mine.
I like your analogy of light passing through water to represent the way gravity bends light. According to the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, however, a particle can never be completely at rest since this would mean that its position was completely certain and its momentum would be infinitely uncertain. In otherwords the gravitons in a gravitational field would have to be moving, unlike the molecules in water. For water molecules, the light comes to them whereas with gravitons, the light comes to their area but they are not guaranteed to be there to interact with light. So then what happens if light goes through a really strong gravitational field but the gravitons aren't in the lights path at that moment. Does the light go unbent? I greatly appreciated your earlier insight and it just seems that I don't understand it well enough. If you wouldn't mind expanding on it a little I'd appreciate it. Thanks.