+
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tomder55
Not anti-vax .It is anti-vax mandate
It is both.
Quote:
Does the vax stop transmission ? No
Are you serious? The vaccine prevents getting the disease. THAT prevents transmission when you don't have the disease. Do some vaccinated people get and transmit? Yes, but that number is infinitesimal. The reward overwhelmingly outweighs the risk,.
Quote:
So then it not a public health issue
Of course, it's a public health issue.
Quote:
It is a personal choice issue and proponents of big government mandates have no compelling case for overriding individual choice .
"Big" governments have NOT mandated the vaccine. The federal government has mandated the vaccine for ITS EMPLOYEES, which they have a perfect right to do just like any employer.
Quote:
The most compelling argument for them is that they prevent hospitalization.
No, the most compelling argument is that they prevent the disease. That leads naturally to prevention of hospitalization and death.
Quote:
But if you are going to force health decision by government fiat where does it end?
There is no government fiat forcing health decisions by fiat.
Quote:
Over 30 million Americans have been diagnosed with heart disease .647,000 people die of heart disease in the US every year. How do you prevent that ? By forcing everyone to maintain a certain weight ;to regularily exercise ? We don't and no one would accept that abuse of government power .
Good grief. No one has suggested the government force people to maintain a certain weight or to regularly exercise. You are bringing up non-existent situations.