Client threatening small claims action
Hello all,
I’m a sole proprietor professional resume writer. Client hired me to write a resume. I conducted phone consultation, sent additional questions and the client paid via PayPal. Shortly thereafter, client requested money back, stating financial problem, and I refunded since I hadn't started on resume yet and I felt sorry for them.
Three months later, client wants to restart process. We have another phone consultation, client answers questions, pays again via PayPal and I wrote and sent resume draft. Client was instantly furious, stating resume wasn't professional but wasn't able or willing to express specific concerns. Three conversations with repeated offers to edit draft are essentially nonproductive. Some edits were made and sent but client still very upset. Edits that the client was able to articulate were all in the “normal” range – a word change, a punctuation correction, etc. and I made them cheerfully and promptly.
My website states I'll produce unlimited edits as they are requested within 30 days. With nearly everyone, there is at least one set of edits and a second draft is produced. No “money-back guarantee” is stated or implied. At day seven or so, the client demands money back again stating resume wasn't as promised (not “professional”) but doesn't say specifically why they think so. I decline to refund this time, as work has been completed and delivered and client chose to end draft revision process voluntarily.
Now, client sends demand letter via email threatening small claims if I don't refund 75% of money paid (total was approximately $200). To my knowledge, client doesn’t have my address and lives 90 miles away in same state, different county. Client claims to have consulted an attorney who apparently informed them they’d be awarded filing fees and their money back in small claims court.
In my opinion, client got what they paid for - the same services for which I’ve received hundreds of thank you letters from happy customers and a robust stream of referrals. This is the first time in ten years anyone has ended the editing process unhappy, so I’m sorry about that, but I can’t be sure client wasn’t intending to swindle me all along, considering the unusually angry reaction and history of requesting money back.
I don't know whether to settle with client to make this go away or see how it plays out in small claims. What would you do? Any comments about how I should have handled this differently?
Thank you,
LP