Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Plumbing (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=259)
-   -   Repiping with Pex (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=263161)

  • Sep 23, 2008, 07:35 AM
    Stubits
    Repiping with Pex
    Thanks to all those who have helped thus far. I have decided I will move forward with repiping my house with Pex, but I have a couple of planning questions.

    1) What size PEX should I use? I am thinking 1" from the main, 3/4" branches and then 1/2" to the fixtures? Does that make sense?

    2) What is the best and most trusted/secure way to make the connections? Crimping? Compression?

    3) I do not know how to sweat copper joints, but I will be connecting to copper in a number of places. What is the best way to connect PEX to copper without soldering? Most of these connections will be behind the walls.

    4) Just a little nervous about running the PEX in the attic. I live in Washington, DC where it gets cold in the winter. The attic is of course unheated. Is it sufficient to insulate the pex with foam insulation? Currently the attic is uninsulated entirely, but I will be insulating it with fiberglass batting, would I want the pipes to run between two layers in the insulation? Under all the insulation? Above the insulation?

    5) Finally, how often do I need to attach the Pex to a stud, etc. If I can manage to run the piping from my attic all the way to the basement utility room (two floors down) without having to open a wall, and therefore only attaching at the top and bottom of the run, is that OK?

    Thanks!
  • Sep 23, 2008, 08:39 AM
    steven62

    Stubits,
    The sizes you suggest sound right, but you would normally use whatever size you might use in CPVC pipe, if that helps.
    I like compression fittings, but crimp rings have their place (tight fits etc.) and they are less expensive.
    Attaching to copper will most likely involve sweating on a barb fitting for the PEX.
    PEX will not freeze and burst, but insulating will keep the water flowing, especially in an attic, I would think. Keep your hangers loose, as PEX changes size 1.1" per 100' per every degree temp rise, so it needs to be able to move, or it will make noise.
    Also, check with the manufacturer of the PEX you are using for the proper fittings. PEX is not yet made to a standard, (Although some are more or less to a voluntary standard) so the fittings from one brand may not fit another!
  • Sep 23, 2008, 08:43 AM
    Stubits

    Thanks so much for the info. Very much appreciated.

    Are there any alternatives to sweating the fittings onto copper? Compression? Crimp? Sharkbite?
  • Sep 23, 2008, 08:46 AM
    ballengerb1
    All of the above but lets be clear, Sharkbite is a brand name and not a type of clamping. Watts and others also make similar fittings that slip into place and hold your connections. Compression should not be enclosed in a wall cavity but most codes will allow a Sharkbite or its equivalent.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 08:49 AM
    Stubits
    Ballenger:

    Thanks for the clarification. I am confident you are comfortable sweating copper joints, but what is the best, most secure option otherwise?

    Also, any thoughts on the other questions? Are you in agreement with Stevens 62?

    Thanks!
  • Sep 23, 2008, 08:55 AM
    ballengerb1
    Steven seems on the money. You can crimp a PEX line but the crimper can run you $120 and its not always cost effective to try to rent them. Sharkbite connector are aound $5 each but no tools required, that's my route.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 09:00 AM
    Stubits

    OK, so you are saying I could actually do the whole repiping using sharkbites?

    I was planning to crimp pex to pex and just use the sharkbites for pex to copper.

    Sharkbites hold up over the long run? This will be a whole house repipe.

    Also, how often does pex need to be tied down? One of the major runs involves going from my basement to my attic, probably about 40 ft or so, and it is possible I would just connect it at the top and bottom of the run, is that OK? Will the pex flop around or make noise?
  • Sep 23, 2008, 09:17 AM
    ballengerb1
    I think we need some of our plumbers to come on board regarding how longShakebites are good, I have only used them for about 5 years but Tom and Mark probably know better. I'll connect them to this question. On your last question, every 10' would be my approach.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 09:19 AM
    Stubits
    I guess another question might be, how tough is it to learn how to sweat pipes? I guess that would be the best approach, and in fact, there are only really 5, maybe 7, pex to copper connections?

    Is it a skill I can learn? I hear if it works, it works, if it doesn't, you know right away, right?
  • Sep 23, 2008, 09:26 AM
    steven62

    Local codes may have a distance in mind for attachment, but it could conceivably go 40' up with attachment top & bottom.
    The noise comes from it being confined but not immobilized, especially on the hot water side. If it has room to grow without rubbing much or bumping, it will make less noise. If it is confined it will tend to "creak" as it slowly slips past whatever is confining it, but it shouldn't flop as it is fairly stiff.
    I like the idea of the Sharkbites, but never used them.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 09:31 AM
    ballengerb1
    I sent Tom and Mark a note but they are both offline at present. Sweating cooper isn't really rocket science. Clean the inisde of the female and outside of the male with a round brush or emery cloth. Apply flux to both, slide together. I'd recommend a cheap propane torch but when you buy your solder don't get electrical solder, buy plumbing solder. They look alike but aren't. You can also buy connectors that already have a rinfg of solder inside them. Heat the connection by directing your flame to the female fitting about a half inch away from the actual joint. Touch your solder to the joint and tap a few times until you see it starts to melt, remove the flame and feed solder in and around the joint until it wicks around the joint, wipe with a rag. When you are ready to test all of your connections have a friend or two help you watch for leaks and/or drips. If you have a leak all the water needs to be removed from the area to resolder. I am not a licensed plumber so my approach my not be accepted by all but when I get a leaker I first try just reheating and adding a touch more solder. Most plumbers would likely tell you to disassemble, clean and start over. I'm just too old to do that.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 09:48 AM
    Stubits

    Guys, this info in invaluable, I feel great about this project. We just bought our first home and I have been loving the opportunities to get my hands dirty.

    Thanks.

    I look forward to Tom and Mark's input!
  • Sep 23, 2008, 09:48 AM
    massplumber2008
    Stubits...

    Bob asked me to pop over and see if I could help a bit.

    Sharkbite fittings are good for repairs and for some transitions but I would not rely on them for whole house transitioning... otherwise sweating/soldering is best overal.l

    It is not hard to solder... just takes a little practice.. glad to talk you through the basics if you want.

    In fact, if you will be stubbing pex pipe into a room you will most likely want to transition over to copper pipe before stubbing into room so you can use the more traditional fittings/shutoffs available at home depot, etc... AND you won't have to stress the tubing trying to bend it to 90 degrees (inside wall this can be hard with pex.. so we transition over to copper then use copper 90 to stub into room) and you will have something rigid to attach a clip/hanger too.

    PEX piping must not go any closer than 18-24" near any appliance that heats water... this means water heater and boiler. You will need to transition using copper fittings here as well.

    Check out this link for a little more info. On PEX systems:

    AOL Search

    Also, I would not insulate the pex pipe in the attic... Instead, I would have you run the pipe so it is as close to ceiling as possible... then you will install at least 12-24" of batt insulation over the pipes. There must be no insulation between ceiling and pipe... ok? The idea is to create an insulation gradient such that the pipe is on the warm side of insulation (ceiling side) and always protected from freezing. Let me know if have questions on this...

    So, let me know what you think here... I'm glad to help more if I can.

    MARK
  • Sep 23, 2008, 10:01 AM
    Stubits
    Mark-

    This is EXCELLENT! Thanks so much. I think I will learn how to sweat joints, probably not a bad skill to have in general.

    The advice of transitioning to copper at the stub outs is well taken. I will definitely plan on doing so, thanks!

    Also, thanks for mentioning the hot water heater. I will make sure to do so.

    On the insulation... thanks! This is great information and not a problem at all, as the attic is entirely uninsulated and I will be doing the insulation at the same time. I guess I will run the PEX first and then do the insulation. Now, could I insulate the PEX as well, to avoid the hot line from sweating? Or totally unnecessary?

    So, not sure if you saw my earlier question about sizing, does it sound right, 1" from the main, 3/2" branches and 1/2" to the fixtures?

    What are your thoughts on how often I should connect/attach the Pex.

    Finally, at least this time around, do you see any trouble running PEX in the AC/Heat chase? That is to say, can I run the PEX in proximity to our AC/forced air heat ducts?

    Thanks!
  • Sep 23, 2008, 12:45 PM
    massplumber2008
    Hello...

    If you were to insulate anything it would be the COLD water pipe as it is the cold water pipes that sweat in certain conditions... not hot water.

    It cannot hurt to insulate the cold water if you think sweating could be issue.

    I would not insulate the hot water as it is hot water that always freezes before cold water does and I want your hot water pipe to pick up as much heat from the room (through ceiling) as possible... just be sure to cover pipe as discussed earlier (run pex first... like you said).

    Running pex system--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Run 1" main and then run 3/4" pex to all fixtures (hot and cold) except the toilet... toilet can be 1/2" pex.

    1/2" pex is really closer to 3/8" copper tubing as it reduces to 3/8" at all fittings... 3/4" pex is really closer to 1/2" copper tubing again, because fittings are reduced below 3/4"... so for best VOLUME for showers, etc... run 3/4". Not that 1/2" won't work.. it will... just will have a slightly smaller volume available when others use other fixtures in house.

    Pex is so easy to work with I say you hang it using your own common sense. Code tells me I need to clip/hang every 6 feet or so... in my area. As Steve62 said, just don't clip/hang too stiff... allow for expansion/contraction.

    I don't see any problem running these pipes in AC/HEAT chase at all... just keep pipes maximum distance from duct work and you should be fine.

    SOLDERING---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Bob already took you through basic steps... I just wanted to list it all out for you...

    1) Drain pipes of water... drain to lowest fixture in home and open all faucets in house (including outside faucet)

    2) Take plumber's sandcloth and clean copper tubing about an inch on end of pipe... clean very well.

    3) Take cleaning brush and clean fitting(s)

    4) Flux the inside of the fitting (both sides if elbow fitting or if tee fitting all three sides of tee) and flux the pipe end (about 3/4") with a flux brush and self-cleaning flux.

    5) Connect fitting and pipe end together. Do not solder just one side of a fitting unless you have a pipe in the other side of fitting.. will burn other side.

    6) Apply heat to fitting so the heat is drawing the solder into the fitting. Here, you will see that bubbles begin to form at the fitting... as bubbles decrease it will be time to apply LEAD-FREE SOLDER. ALWAYS apply solder to the bottom of the fitting first..then apply solder to the top of fitting.

    The blue part of the flame should be about 1/4" or so from the fitting... the idea here is to heat the fitting and then draw the solder into the joint not by melting solder with flame but by heating the joint so it actually sucks up into fitting (why flame needs to be behind fitting drawing solder in).

    After you have soldered joint can give it a quick, light wipe with rag if you want.

    Always be sure to wear GOGGLES when soldering... especially in the beginning and when soldering where dripping solder can BOUNCE of surface and up into your face.

    Practice on a few fittings first. One big trick to fitting copper tubing and soldering is to CRIMP the fitting onto the pipe using a pair of pliers... but note here that I am talking about a little crimp and then a 1/4 turn or so to lock the fitting in place...

    You can also check out these websites for a video on soldering:

    http://www.askthebuilder.com/How_to_...pe_Video.shtml

    http://www.schooltube.com/video/9770...er-Pipe-Module

    Both these guys show one side of fitting being soldered... don't do that as discussed above.

    MAPPGAS (available at home depot) is best torch for homeowners... burns hot.

    Also, be sure to have a FIRE EXTINGUISHER handy... just in case!

    Always solder any threaded fitting first.. let cool, then apply pipe dope or teflon tape if needed (male fittings) and THEN can install and tighten using wrench/pliers.

    And finally, wash the pipes after you solder them... I use baking soda and water to break down any acidic residue left from the flux!!

    Let me know if/when more questions...

    MARK
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:10 PM
    Stubits

    Mark-

    This sounds fantastic.

    Frankly, I was set on hiring a plumber to come in repipe, but after hanging out on here for a while I am confident I can pull this off myself. Although PEX is completely up to code here, I only found one plumber who would run it and he said that the cost of PEX and copper repipe would be the same... sounds a bit off to me given the huge cost difference in materials.

    Thanks for explaining the insulation issue. I think I will avoid insulating the pipes all together, not sure if sweating would be an issue here. I will make sure to run all the pipes under the insulation.

    I had no idea about the relative sizes of PEX, thanks for clarifying that; we've been living with suboptimal water pressure for months now (we just moved in), I don't want to have the same problems now.

    What distance should I keep the pipes from the ductwork? The chase isn't huge, so there isn't lots of extra room. What would be the minimum?

    Can you just gut check this setup for me? I can include pictures or a diagram if it will help.

    At present, we effectively have two major branches, one that feeds our basement bathroom/kitchenette/laundry room/primary kitchen and the other that feeds our upstairs bathroom. The basement bathroom/kitchenette/laundry room/primary kitchen are all done and interconnected in copper, but fed off galvanized steel, I know where the main connection point is.

    In the repiping, I will have 1" coming from the main to our utility closet where it will tie into our hot water heater. Additionally, there will be a 3/4" supply line running off the 1" main to the upstairs bath (via the attic) and a second 3/4" supply line running off that 1" main to the basement bathroom/kitchenette/laundry room/primary kitchen. Similarly, out of the hot water heater I'll run a 3/4" supply line to both of those locations.

    Given that it is a repiping, I am not planning on using a manifold/home run system. Will this work? Will we still have good water pressure throughout? Is there anything I can/should do differently?
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:15 PM
    ballengerb1
    Stubuts, we never mentioned this but have you checlked the permit requirements in your area?
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:18 PM
    Stubits

    Ballenger:

    Each of the plumbers I brought in, reputable, licensed, bonded and insured, indicated that they would not suggest getting a license for this work. I have confirmed that PEX is allowable under code.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:23 PM
    ballengerb1
    I think you meant permit, not license. You can call the building department and ask that question without telling them who you are. I'm gun shy of doing work without a permit when I am fairly certain one is required.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:25 PM
    massplumber2008
    Stubits... just maintain max. distance you can in chase and you will be fine... keep pipes from touching duct work.

    I posted some soldering sites at my last post so check them out... also added more info. As you were typing your post so be sure to reread my last post... ok?

    Otherwise, all sounded fine to me... ;)

    Good luck!
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:27 PM
    Stubits

    Mark-

    Yes, I noticed the instruction manual on soldering, I seriously can't thank you enough.

    Bob- I agree with you. Plumbers suggested not getting a permit because the inspectors cause a lot of trouble on repiping older homes here. Also, DC won't allow homeowners to get permits for ANY plumbing work at all.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:30 PM
    KISS

    Stubits:

    Many of the questions obou t PEX can be answered in the Radiant heat Instal book link I posted. Fastening, how far away etc.

    Soldering - a couple of tidbits:

    Damp rag.

    Practice with a few fittings like an elbow with a short length of pipe with the pipe verticle and the elbow on top.

    This will make it easier to get the feel, because the solder will run up hill based on capilary action. Always heat the more massive area first. e.g the fitting

    By practicing, you'll get a better feel as to when to test.

    The lines need to open so there is a place for gasses to go.

    They must be free of water. There is a "bread trick" when things get tough and you can't seem to get the water out.

    Finally:

    There are heat shields. The hardware store variety isn't very good. www.smallparts.com has a really nice shield.

    While the joint is cooling - DO NOT DISTURB.

    There are two types of couplings. One had a dimple or a ridge and the other is straight through. The latter is a repair coupling. It allows you to but two pieces of pipe together when the ends are constrained.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:31 PM
    massplumber2008
    Same in my area Stubits...

    Nothing like encouraging people to do the right thing...huh??

    Keep us posted as you go...

    MARK
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:34 PM
    Stubits

    Wow guys, thanks! This is all so helpful. I won't be getting started on this for another couple of weeks, but this is just what I needed... and my wife is starting to resign herself to the fact that I'll be doing this, your confidence has helped.

    One more quick questions... what brand of PEX do you recommend? I guess along those lines, what type of connection do you like best, compression? Crimp? Anything I should stay away from? I hear that Zurn has had some trouble.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:38 PM
    massplumber2008
    I am a huge fan of the VIEGA system... only system I use so can't speak about other system.

    Viega is a crimp with sleeve system... check it out at:

    Viega | Plumbing, heating, gas, drinking water, drainage and bathroom design

    Tools can be rented at local plumbing supply house... sometimes.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:42 PM
    Stubits

    Which of the three, ViegaPEX & ViegaPEX Ultra or Viega FostaPEX would you suggest for this job?
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:45 PM
    massplumber2008
    I run viega fostapex for all my hot and cold water pipes. This type pipe is stiffer than ordinary pex... less difficult to handle and just looks less like spaghetti as it forms nice clean runs.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:46 PM
    massplumber2008
    Bob has worked with zurn pex I think... wait till he pops back and see what he thinks of that...
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:46 PM
    Stubits
    Excellent... and what do you pay on average for 100 ft of 3/4"?
  • Sep 23, 2008, 01:47 PM
    massplumber2008
    Hmmm.. don't know off the top of my head... but wayyyyyyyyy cheaper than copper... wayyyyyy cheaper!
  • Sep 23, 2008, 02:10 PM
    ballengerb1
    My only price sheet for Zurn is a little old. http://www.zurn.com/images/pdf/PEXPriceGuide.pdf The big issue with Zurn was not the PEX but their brass connectors were failing premature. You can always use somebody else's fitting even though the issue was resolved in think in 2005.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 02:12 PM
    Stubits

    Bob-

    Do you use Zurn? If so, have you heard of any problems with it? I hear they have a class action lawsuit out against them.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 02:18 PM
    ballengerb1
    We kind of bet each other to the punch, reread my post #31. I have no problem with their PEX but Mark does way more than me.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 02:20 PM
    Stubits

    Bob-

    Sorry to have jumped the gun, thanks for the clarification.
  • Sep 23, 2008, 02:30 PM
    afaroo

    Stubits,

    Click on the link below will give you a rough idea about the price and also there is a contact number for the pexsuply to call them for any question

    FostaPEX - FostaPEX PEX-al-PEX - Viega FostaPEX - Buy FostaPEX
  • Sep 23, 2008, 08:35 PM
    EPMiller
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Stubits View Post
    T<snip>
    1) What size PEX should I use? I am thinking 1" from the main, 3/4" branches and then 1/2" to the fixtures? Does that make sense?

    Somebody above said use the same sizes as you would with CPVC. That's correct. If you can look at a code book you can figure out the minimum sizes required. Rule of thumb: Cold: 3/4" to the 2nd to last or last tee on the line. Hot: 3/4" to the first major use tee or use a manifold and run dedicated lines to each bathroom group, laundry, kitchen. Long runs of 3/4 waste a LOT of water until it gets hot. I've never used 1" PEX in residential domestic supplies. Usually when you have to flow that much water it is not heated. Just use PVC unless you are worried about freezing.

    Quote:

    2) What is the best and most trusted/secure way to make the connections? Crimping? Compression?
    If you aren't going to crimp, you will get a WHOLE LOT of money in the fittings. Sharkbite tees are $9 and up each around here. Crimping probably is the biggest advantage of pex. I would use CPVC if I couldn't crimp. Really, a dual nest (1/2" and 3/4") crimp tool retails for about $150 to $170 locally. That's probably still cheaper than all the compression fittings you will use in a house. If you can afford to do the job yourself, you can afford to buy the tool. Sell it on Craig's list when you are done. :) Actually now that I think of it, donate it to me, I don't own one personally, my work supplies the crimpers, but I would love one! :D

    Another thing, I try hard not to use joints in concealed spaces. (Remember why we don't use Qest anymore? :rolleyes: I'm still have a lingering concern about pex too even though I use it all the time.) I like bend supports whenever possible inside walls to eliminate joints. Tees are the biggest problem. Do them in the basement or behind access panels and run continuous tubes to the stub outs.

    Quote:

    3) I do not know how to sweat copper joints, but I will be connecting to copper in a number of places. What is the best way to connect PEX to copper without soldering? Most of these connections will be behind the walls.
    Here you should learn to sweat copper. Practice on a piece of tube that you cut out. I can't quite trust even the brass 'Sharkbite' fittings for 30+ years. I hardly trust the plastic ones long term even when I can see them. I have installed a couple of sharkbites in walls when it wasn't avoidable, but I work very hard to only use them where I can get to them. Use the sweat/crimp adapters.

    Quote:

    4) Just a little nervous about running the PEX in the attic. I live in Washington, DC where it gets cold in the winter. The attic is of course unheated. Is it sufficient to insulate the pex with foam insulation? Currently the attic is uninsulated entirely, but I will be insulating it with fiberglass batting, would I want the pipes to run between two layers in the insulation? Under all the insulation? Above the insulation?
    I'd be nervous too. Put your pipes in the warmest area of the attic. Which is BELOW the insulation. Slip on foam is a very good idea. It should be required for hot lines. Buy unsplit 6' lengths at a plumbing supply house, slip it on as you go and use the split stuff for what you have to do after the pipe is installed. The good split stuff has adhesive in the joint so it stays together.

    Quote:

    5) Finally, how often do I need to attach the Pex to a stud, etc. If I can manage to run the piping from my attic all the way to the basement utility room (two floors down) without having to open a wall, and therefore only attaching at the top and bottom of the run, is that OK?
    It must be supported minimum every 32" horizontally. Hot lines work best supported every joist. I forget vertical, but it isn't a lot farther. I don't know off hand what is required for a fished run or even if that is allowed, but if you can put it in foam insulation (and DON'T stretch the stuff) so that it can't rub anything, I might try it if I knew it was supported correctly at the top. One of those 'chinese finger trap' things might work.

    I mustn't have refreshed my browser enough, I missed half of the posts. I like the Wirsbo brand of pex. We use a lot of Zurn at work, it seems fine so far, just isn't as pretty. Some of the Zurn is in for 10 years and isn't giving us any trouble. Also I disagree on not insulating the hot line. The biggest problem is heat loss during use, not needing to gain heat while laying in the pipe. Also, I haven't read my code book lately, but I do think that pex must be supported much closer that what some have said. But maybe that's just the local inspectors here.

    EPM
  • Sep 28, 2008, 02:11 PM
    Stubits
    This is wonderful information. Many thanks to each of you.

    I will be moving forward on this project in the next couple of weeks, after the summer heat breaks and hopefully before the cold sets in (will make working up in the attic much easier).

    I think I have the sizing figured out now, I erred in my original post when I suggested using 1" from the main. I measured the current copper main today and it is only 3/4", so I will do 3/4" from the main and to each of the two major groups and then 1/2" to each fixture.

    I will definitely use crimp connections. I was just curious if there was a preference between the standard crimp connection and Wirsbo's expansion connection, but it seems like everyone favors crimping. The cost of the tool is negligible in comparison with what I am saving doing this myself.

    There will only be a VERY small run of pipes in the attic. I will definitely run it under the insulation, but I am definitely confused about whether to insulate. I understand insulating as a means of reducing heat loss, but I don't want to do it if it would in anyway encourage freezing. Can anyone explain this topic a bit more? Any further suggestions?

    As far as supporting the PEX, a couple of questions? Does something like this, Sioux Chief 555-23 - $9.95 - Sioux Chief - Tube Talon for 1/2" & 5/8" & 3/4" PEX Tubing (Bag of 100) - 555-23, allow for expansion? Would this be appropriate and acceptable for use? EPM, what is the "chinese finger trap" thing you are speaking of? Any links?

    Ok, and a totally new topic, what about a gravity hot water recirculating loop? How complicated would it be to install one in this application? Does it work well with PEX? I was planning on using a "mini manifold" up in the attic to split the 3/4" supply line to 1/2" lines to each supply. They make one that has 3/4" in and 3/4" out, such as this http://www.pexsupply.com/categories....D=740&brandid=, can I just run a line back down to the hot water heater?

    Thanks!
  • Sep 29, 2008, 12:36 PM
    Stubits
    This is wonderful information. Many thanks to each of you.

    I will be moving forward on this project in the next couple of weeks, after the summer heat breaks and hopefully before the cold sets in (will make working up in the attic much easier).

    I think I have the sizing figured out now, I erred in my original post when I suggested using 1" from the main. I measured the current copper main today and it is only 3/4", so I will do 3/4" from the main and to each of the two major groups and then 1/2" to each fixture.

    I will definitely use crimp connections. I was just curious if there was a preference between the standard crimp connection and Wirsbo's expansion connection, but it seems like everyone favors crimping. The cost of the tool is negligible in comparison with what I am saving doing this myself.

    There will only be a VERY small run of pipes in the attic. I will definitely run it under the insulation, but I am definitely confused about whether to insulate. I understand insulating as a means of reducing heat loss, but I don't want to do it if it would in anyway encourage freezing. Can anyone explain this topic a bit more? Any further suggestions?

    As far as supporting the PEX, a couple of questions? Does something like this, Sioux Chief 555-23 - $9.95 - Sioux Chief - Tube Talon for 1/2" & 5/8" & 3/4" PEX Tubing (Bag of 100) - 555-23, allow for expansion? Would this be appropriate and acceptable for use? EPM, what is the "chinese finger trap" thing you are speaking of? Any links?

    Ok, and a totally new topic, what about a gravity hot water recirculating loop? How complicated would it be to install one in this application? Does it work well with PEX? I was planning on using a "mini manifold" up in the attic to split the 3/4" supply line to 1/2" lines to each supply. They make one that has 3/4" in and 3/4" out, such as this http://www.pexsupply.com/categories....D=740&brandid=, can I just run a line back down to the hot water heater?

    Thanks!
  • Sep 29, 2008, 12:59 PM
    KISS
    Gravity recirc.
    I think all that's required is a check valve, ball valve and removal/reinsertion of the drain.

    In the loop, you usually return the furthest fixture's hot water to the drain of the hot water heater, so a check valve is required probably at the fixture.

    Then this needs to be plumbed into the drain. You need a valve and the ability todrain the recirc-loop.

    You may have multiple loops. Not sure how that complicates things, but you would have to return the last fixture on every LOOP to the drain of the water heater.

    Does this make sense?

    You don't want the drain to supply the water, so that needs a check valve. Your return should handle the flows of all the connected fixtures in the loop.
  • Sep 29, 2008, 06:25 PM
    EPMiller
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by KeepItSimpleStupid View Post
    Gravity recirc.
    I think all that's required is a check valve, ball valve and removal/reinsertion of the drain.

    In the loop, you usually return the furthest fixture's hot water to the drain of the hot water heater, so a check valve is required probably at the fixture.
    <snip>

    I really question a gravity recirc loop in this situation. If your lines are mostly vertical and straight, then yes, but unless you really chill the return line, if you have a convoluted install I don't think it will work well enough to be worth the cost of parts. Also, most garden variety check valves have enough resistance to opening that you will need a serious temperature differential to get any flow and even then it will be insufficient. And if it does work, you are creating a small in-wall and attic heating system that will continually take heat off your water heater. Think wear and tear on the elements and kWh $$.

    If you want to save water (which I think is the reasonable thing to do), put a Grundfos or Taco recirculator system in and then time it to run only during the times you actually use hot water. Rather than a timer I personally prefer a momentary switch that is manually operated for 10 secs or however long it takes to bring the hot water to the end of the line, and not run the system otherwise and save both water and electricity.

    If you do a recirc loop, just tee it into the cold supply above the water heater, but below the inlet shutoff valve and expansion tank. Some of the systems I maintain have sediment problems and returning the loop at the drain valve just stirs things up and makes draining the sediment out impossible. BTDT, repented and replumbed.

    Those plastic pex supports that you link to are fine. Probably a bit more expensive than the individual size ones, but great otherwise.

    PLEASE insulate your hot lines. It will pay for itself, especially if your hot water use is intermittent but mostly within the same hour or so block(s) of time. They will NOT freeze faster inside insulation. They will only thaw slower if they do freeze. Also the reason I recommend insulating both the hot and cold lines in the attic is because usually when run under insulation they don't get supported very well and so they can rub as they expand and contract. If against a nail or really rough surface you can imagine what will happen down the road. Also cold line sweating in unconditioned spaces can be a problem.

    Hope that helps a bit. I could go into greater detail, but my wife says I spend too much time on the computer as it is. :D

    EPM

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 03:10 AM.