This is the exact message I received from Globe Union International: Please note that Globe Union is one of the manufacturers of the Glacier Bay/Pegasus program for Home Depot. There are several companies who make these products; Glacier Bay is not a company in itself, but a brand name owned by Home Depot. If we can trouble you for a model number, or a photo of the faucet, we can determine the manufacturer and model number.
In cases where a complete replacement is required, Home Depot will exchange the faucets. It's possible that this wasn't accepted as an exchange because you may not have had your model information with you. Once we have determined the model number we can put you in touch with Home Depot's customer care department so that they can make the exchange as easy as possible for you.
Please forward photos at your earliest convenience and we will get started.