To LCOHIO,
Our private water company was adamant that we pay for the 240,000 gallons of water - which we did NOT use. I got the media involved. The local ABC station came to the house and did a story - two local (small) newspapers wrote front page stories about the water usage. We basically made the owner of the private water company look like a greedy fool. The meter definitely malfunctioned. It was a Sensus Meter. I spoke with one of their engineeers outside of Pittsburgh, PA. I believe his name was Scott. The private water company eventually sent our meter back to Sensus for an evaluation and their evaluation was that the meter probably malfunctioned because of dirt in the lines. It was at that point, the owner of the water company said we didn't have to pay him. So - that's what worked for us. I recommend getting the media involved. Good luck!