Originally Posted by KalFour
Liar,
Most people are capable of committing a crime in a fit of passion. And statistically, the rate of repeat offending (with crimes like murder at least) is quite low. Some people do repeat the crime over and over, but most don't. This man might be capable of re-offending, but there's a pretty good chance that he won't.
Starbuck,
By turning himself in, would he really be proving anything? He's being selfishly afraid to do so, and it's perfectly understandable. That doesn't make it right, but what do you expect him to do?
It might be great if he gives himself up... but would you?
"Does he sound like a dangerous, manipulative, tempermental man? YES! Even if he is lying. Does a stable man go around telling someone he has murdered a man. There can only be two reasons for this really. Either he murdered this man in cold blood, or he has a manipulative reason for telling such a lie. In either case that makes him dangerous."
- Again "in cold blood" assumes a deliberate and premeditated attack. We don't know that. And the majority or violent crimes are committed during an impassioned rage.
"As far as her destroying the life of a man that made a MISTAKE???? Murder is NOT a mistake in this instance. It is a CRIME! The man needs to be punished. If people could just go around murdering other people and then just say...we'll I'm sorry, and gee it was yrs ago anyway!...well how many murderers do you think would be out there running free. There are enough of them now as it is. I'm sure the murdered boys family wouldn't accept a simple apology now would they?!! Would you if it was your son or family member?"
- Yes, it's a crime. And what do we have a justice system for? To punish, yes. To protect also. As a deterrent for other criminals. And to rehabilitate criminals.
Punishment is for vengeance, something I personally disapprove of. In fairness, if anyone every harmed my sister or something, I'd have no qualms about harming them right back. But that doesn't stop it from being a selfish desire, and often one with no real purpose.
Protecting the community from people who might re-offend is important, but as I've already said, a crime of passion usually won't happen twice. Deterring other criminals is important too, but if he's not bragging about getting away with murder, he's hardly encouraging others to follow in his footsteps. And is going to prison really going to help him become a functioning member of society? Prisons don't rehabilitate the way they ought to. They expose the inmates to other criminals, where they can share ideas. And getting out of prison leaves one with no real prospects - who'd hire an ex-con? Who'd get romantically entangled with a convicted felon? The label itself becomes a life sentence, even if they only served for a short period of time. People can't just do time, find redemption, and move on with their lives. Instead, they spend their time in a horrible environment, then come out to be on the fringe of society until they die.
I don't approve of him getting away with murder. He probably does deserve to be punished. But who are you decide? Who are any of us? And what would be the point? Is it really justice?
You're right though. There AREN'T two sides to the story. There are many more than that. Nothing is black and white.
Kal