Hi Gemini and TwelveMonkeys,
I'm a little uncomfortable with the shrink4men website myself, just because some of the wording is the kind that actual abusive men use to try to falsely make it sound like it's the woman who is abusive.
For example, to take the very first thing on the page:
I don't think this is abusive. If a man is abusive and the woman threatens to leave if he doesn't stop, she's not being abusive. Same in reverse, if a man threatens to leave because he's unhappy in the relationship, that's not abuse. That's setting limits. The two people may not agree about those limits, but that's something to talk about. A grown man is not a child who can be "abandoned."
If the named threats (children, money, career) are directed at keeping a man in a relationship and controlling his behavior, then it may well be abuse. But the "threats" listed at shrink4men are the kinds of threats that abusive men project onto women when she wants to LEAVE the relationship, not force him to stay in it. In fact, these are the very threats women typically hear when they want to leave an abusive relationship. He says, "If you leave, I will take the children from you, I will take the house, I will make sure you lose your job; you will live on the street."
The page goes on to talk about losing access to children. But instead of reassuring men that this is an empty threat, it argues that it is worth it to leave. Even abusive men often get half time custody of their children. There's no reason a good dad would have less. So it is not reasonable to assume he will lose access to his children if starts from the assumption that he will have them half time.
I am not sure if I am being very clear. But I think that this particular web site serves to justify men who are themselves abusive (and expect, for example, to lose their children). That's NOT to say that the men who read it are all abusive!
What Abuse IS:
Abuse is a pattern of controlling behavior. (And people who are leaving a relationship are not normally trying to control the other person.) I believe TwelveMonkey's wife is abusive. But I think TwelveMonkeys will get a more accurate sense of what constitutes abuse from a website such as the
National Domestic Violence Hotline.