Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Family Law (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=120)
-   -   Child support from unwilling father, uninvolved father (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=173697)

  • Jan 17, 2008, 10:09 PM
    v_e
    Child support from unwilling father, uninvolved father
    I am currently pregnant with my first child. The father is not involved. What rights does the baby have to collect child support from him?

    Is it ethical to force financial child support, when he does not want to be involved? Yet, he has said that he will provide support. He says that and then doesn’t actually do it. As of today, I haven't asked him to provide a dime. He has just stated that he will. I want him to be involved with the pregnancy, and he doesn't want to be. More important than financial support is emotional, spiritual, physical, educational and family support. How can I have him be involved in the child's life?

    What rights does the baby have to collect support from the bio father, when the mother makes more than the father? I make more money than he does.

    Also, he has impregnated two other women before, and gotten off scott-free. The 2 other women aborted the babies. He wants me to do the same, but I don't want to.

    His and my relationship has been on/off again for the past 8 1/2 years. He thinks that I got pregnant on purpose, which is not the case. Or that I lied about my medical history, and knew I could get pregnant. The doctors told me that it would be difficult to get pregnant, but not impossible. I told him all of that and more. What rights does he have if he claims that I did this on purpose?

    I don't want to be hard line or tough, but this wasn't a one night stand. He says one thing and does another. I'm so confused.


    :confused:
  • Jan 17, 2008, 10:25 PM
    oneguyinohio
    You have every right to collect financial support. I don't think you can force involvement from the father however.

    The financial support may have to wait until the child is actually born. The amounts are often based on a comparison of the two parents income.

    Then, based on the total of the two incomes, the court arrives at an amount of support for the child. The percentage of the total that the father earns... such as if he earns 40% and you earn 60% when both of your incomes are added together... is the percentage of the court determined support.

    I am only saying that is how cases I am familiar with were handled. It might be different in different areas.
  • Jan 17, 2008, 10:34 PM
    dollface_93
    You can't make him want to be there, just stay upbeat yourself, I know it's hard but by you keeping the baby and being excited about it may help him come around eventually.
    It doesn't matter if you make more $ or not you are still entitled to support payments.
    I have been though this before to, if you want to talk further about anything just let me know!
  • Jan 18, 2008, 11:21 AM
    this8384
    I'm sorry for the lack of compassion, but you need to hear the truth:

    Kick his sorry butt out. 8 1/2 years or not, this guy's a deadbeat and not someone you're going to want your child around. He doesn't care now and odds are he's not going to care in the future. He got 2 other women pregnant and didn't want those kids; why would he suddenly become responsible and involved? You deserve so much better and so does your child! You are not garbage; stop letting him treat you that way!
  • Jan 18, 2008, 12:52 PM
    dollface_93
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by this8384
    I'm sorry for the lack of compassion, but you need to hear the truth:

    Kick his sorry butt out. 8 1/2 years or not, this guy's a deadbeat and not someone you're going to want your child around. He doesn't care now and odds are he's not going to care in the future. He got 2 other women pregnant and didn't want those kids; why would he suddenly become responsible and involved? You deserve so much better and so does your child! You are not garbage; stop letting him treat you that way!



    Did you read the thread, they obviously DO NOT LIVE TOGETHER! I have been there and yes the father did come around and we are now in a awesome relationship and he is the best father ever, Not ALL men Are complete jerks!
  • Jan 18, 2008, 08:46 PM
    v_e
    Thanks to everyone who replied.

    This is off the subject of law, but in response to the replies that were given.

    Yes, I have kicked him out of my life. Twice: over the span of 8 years. [We dated Jun 99 through Dec 99, and then I broke it off. We dated again Jan 02 through Aug 02, and then I broke it off. We were "Just Friends" Aug 02 through Dec 03, and then I broke that off too. We dated again March 05 through Sept 07, when I told him I was pregnant with his baby. After I told him, I am pregnant, then he breaks it off.]

    I have never lived with him, nor do I plan to live with him now. He keeps coming back to me, pursing me. And no, it wasn't because I gave him sex. He came back twice, before I putt-out even once. I want to believe that he cares about me, even if he doesn't love me. He knows that care about him, deeply, even love him. But for my own sake I have kicked him to the curb.

    The FOB is not the common dirt bag that hits or abuses women, but is a wolf in sheep's clothing. I can see that now.

    I will wait till the baby is born (Due date is April 14, 2008) and then file for support. Since he doesn't want to do this the easy way, the mature and adult way, we'll have to do it the hard way. I can't allow myself to put my feeling in front of the needs of my child. Whether he likes it or not, this baby is coming soon. The baby will need love and support.

    And as a message to all you fathers out there... help the mother during the pregnancy. It's tough to do this alone.
  • Jan 18, 2008, 09:31 PM
    dollface_93
    Yeah for you, stay strong! I will keep you on my prayers!
  • Jan 18, 2008, 10:51 PM
    mariposa11
    Your child has the right to be financially supported by BOTH parents, regardless of their desire to be a parent. Even if you make more money than he does, if you are the primary caregiver of the child you will receive some amount of monetary compensation if you choose to seek it. Not wanting to raise the child does not negate dad's responsibility to help provide for the child. He can claim you tricked him all he wants. At the end of the day he chose to have sex rather than abstain, and is accountable for the consequences. He may not want a baby, but it is ultimately your decision and with time he may very well change his mind.
  • Jan 19, 2008, 08:32 AM
    JudyKayTee
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by v_e
    I have never lived with him, nor do I plan to live with him now. He keeps coming back to me, pursing me. And no, it wasn't because I gave him sex. He came back twice, before I putt-out even once. I want to believe that he cares about me, even if he doesn't love me. He knows that care about him, deeply, even love him. But for my own sake I have kicked him to the curb.

    The FOB is not the common dirt bag that hits or abuses women, but is a wolf in sheep's clothing. I can see that now.

    I will wait till the baby is born (Due date is April 14, 2008) and then file for support. Since he doesn't want to do this the easy way, the mature and adult way, we'll have to do it the hard way. I can't allow myself to put my feeling in front of the needs of my child. Whether he likes it or not, this baby is coming soon. The baby will need love and support.

    And as a message to all you fathers out there... help the mother during the pregnancy. It's tough to do this alone.



    Sorry to be tough on you but you are covering for him, enabling him, excusing him, even now. He IS abusive. He IS a "common dirt bag." Emotional abuse is every bit as serious and disabling as physical abuse and walking away is abuse, accusing you of getting pregnant deliberately IS abuse. (He must think he's a better "catch" than he appears to be on paper). On the other hand, were you aware two other women had abortions at his insistence when you were involved with him? That would appear to say loud and clear that he does NOT want to be a father.

    Yes, you should file for support but you cannot force him to be involved in the child's life - and I know you know this, but you can't make him love the baby, support the baby or love and support you.

    And the message should also be to pick the possible father of your baby very, very carefully because you'll be stuck with him for a very long time.
  • Jan 19, 2008, 09:27 AM
    George_1950
    Kudos, madam, for keeping your baby! May I recommend you find not only the best pediatrician in your community, but also the best lawyer. You will need to consider your estate, your executor, and the guardian for your child. Your attorney should get dad's agreement to provide your baby with health insurance and life insurance.
  • Jan 19, 2008, 09:34 AM
    this8384
    I applaud you, v_e! That baby is lucky to have you... I know you care a lot for your unborn child and I commend you for going through with having it even though the baby's father isn't making the effort. The father doesn't need to hit women to be a dirtbag - the fact that he walks away from his responsibilities makes him enough of one. I believe every child deserves the best in life, and I can tell that's what your baby will get from you. Congratulations!
  • Jan 19, 2008, 09:58 AM
    JudyKayTee
    [QUOTE=v_e]. The 2 other women aborted the babies. He wants me to do the same, but I don't want to.I don't want to be hard line or tough, but this wasn't a one night stand. He says one thing and does another. I'm so confused.


    Did you know about the 2 other women and the (insisted upon) abortions when you were involved with him?
  • Jan 19, 2008, 10:00 AM
    JudyKayTee
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by George_1950
    Kudos, madam, for keeping your baby! May I recommend you find not only the best pediatrician in your community, but also the best lawyer. You will need to consider your estate, your executor, and the guardian for your child. Your attorney should get dad's agreement to provide your baby with health insurance and life insurance.


    I think I'd go less with Attorney agreement and more with a Court order - let the Court review the circumstances and make its award. Attorney agreements are great if they don't need to be enforced... or you can come to an agreement.

    That's what the Courts are for.
  • Jan 19, 2008, 10:36 AM
    s_cianci
    Legally he is required to provide financial support for the child. The circumstances surrounding the birth, your medical history and what you may have told him about it, whether you got pregnant on purpose or not, etc. are totally irrelevant. You'll have to file a motion in Family Court to enforce that obligation. You, he and the child may have to submit to a DNA test after birth to prove paternity. As far as anyone's moral responsibilities, that's a matter of individual conscience. In my own opinion, as the child's mother and primary custodial caregiver, you should strive to get everything your child is entitled to. Even though you may make more than he does, he should still contribute to the child's financial needs to the extent that his income permits and the court will determine just what that is, using the guidelines established by your state.
  • Jan 19, 2008, 04:24 PM
    v_e
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by JudyKayTee
    Sorry to be tough on you but you are covering for him, enabling him, excusing him, even now. He IS abusive. He IS a "common dirt bag." Emotional abuse is every bit as serious and disabling as physical abuse and walking away is abuse, accusing you of getting pregnant deliberately IS abuse. (He must think he's a better "catch" than he appears to be on paper). On the other hand, were you aware two other women had abortions at his insistence when you were involved with him? That would appear to say loud and clear that he does NOT want to be a father.

    Yes, you should file for support but you cannot force him to be involved in the child's life - and I know you know this, but you can't make him love the baby, support the baby or love and support you.

    And the message should also be to pick the possible father of your baby very, very carefully because you'll be stuck with him for a very long time.

    Thanks for all the advice.

    No, I didn't know that he had gotten two other girls pregnant until after I was pregnant. Like I said, it's been an on/off again relationship. The other two girls had abortions. It may have been their choice. I never stated that he forced them into that. He told me that information.. . So who knows. How can I find it out? Hell, I don't think I even want to know.

    The relationship between him and I is/has been developing over 8+ years. It isn't something that is just today. Overall, he's the same as any guy out there. No better, no worse. He's attractive but not hot. He has a steady job. He's in the military; severed two tours of duty during this war. He's smart. He has issues: everyone does. He has ADD. So do a lot of people.

    I have issues too. The difference is my parents taught me to take responsibility. His parents are still making excuses for him. Even at age 27, they want him to excuse what he’s doing. “He can’t help put a crib together, because he has ADD.” My response is WHAT!? It doesn’t make any sense to me.

    It’s to the point where recreational sports (paintball) and video games are more important to him than putting the crib together. Mind you, he didn’t buy the crib, baby furniture, car seat, play yard, baby clothing, baby toys or anything else that the baby will need. I have, or will. I simply asked him to put the crib together and paint the room. I also bought the paint. And I suppose that’s what gets me the most; he has money and time to do something expensive like play paintball. Blow a hundred plus dollars in a single day. But to spend two hundred dollars on something that is for his child, that his child will use for the next 1 to 5 years and needs… no. He doesn’t have money for that.

    I am enabling him? Yes. I can see that. I didn't plan for it to turn out like that. Do I deserve better? Yes. Do I love him anyway? Yes. Is this a major part of why I’m not married to him? Yes.

    I have tired different approaches; bargaining, yelling, ultimatum, talking to his family, and more. Yes, I have tired. My family (God bless them) has tired on my behalf.

    Mind you that after each one of these approaches, he says “okay I’ll help. I’ll go to the doctor appointment with you, to find out the baby’s sex. I’ll put the crib together.” Then the actions are different. He’s said one thing, and then does another.

    Should I have chosen a different father? Yes. But let me put to you this way, the FOB is only 1 of 2 people that I’ve slept with in my entire life. I’m not a person to go with any Joe Schmuck that comes along. But that’s why this is an “oops” accident. That’s why this is out of wedlock.

    Despite everything it’s a happy accident for me.

    --still confused, but gaining clarity and strength :confused:
  • Jan 19, 2008, 07:15 PM
    George_1950
    v_e writes: "But to spend two hundred dollars on something that is for his child, that his child will use for the next 1 to 5 years and needs… no. He doesn't have money for that."
    It may be that his appreciation for what your are going through has not dawned on him yet; it may be that he will need to feel your baby kicking, or see your baby's face and smile for the first time.
  • Jan 20, 2008, 08:01 AM
    JudyKayTee
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by v_e
    Thanks for all the advice.

    No, I didn't know that he had gotten two other girls pregnant until after I was pregnant. Like I said, it's been an on/off again relationship. The other two girls had abortions. It may have been their choice. I never stated that he forced them into that. He told me that information . . . so who knows. How can I find it out? Hell, I don't think I even want to know.

    The relationship between him and I is/has been developing over 8+ years. It isn't something that is just today. Overall, he's the same as any guy out there. No better, no worse. He's attractive but not hot. He has a steady job. He's in the military; severed two tours of duty during this war. He's smart. He has issues: everyone does. He has ADD. So do a lot of people.

    I have issues too. The difference is my parents taught me to take responsibility. His parents are still making excuses for him. Even at age 27, they want him to excuse what he’s doing. “He can’t help put a crib together, because he has ADD.” My response is WHAT!?!?! It doesn’t make any sense to me.

    It’s to the point where recreational sports (paintball) and video games are more important to him than putting the crib together. Mind you, he didn’t buy the crib, baby furniture, car seat, play yard, baby clothing, baby toys or anything else that the baby will need. I have, or will. I simply asked him to put the crib together and paint the room. I also bought the paint. And I suppose that’s what gets me the most; he has money and time to do something expensive like play paintball. Blow a hundred plus dollars in a single day. But to spend two hundred dollars on something that is for his child, that his child will use for the next 1 to 5 years and needs… no. He doesn’t have money for that.

    I am enabling him? Yes. I can see that. I didn't plan for it to turn out like that. Do I deserve better? Yes. Do I love him anyway? Yes. Is this a major part of why I’m not married to him? Yes.

    I have tired different approaches; bargaining, yelling, ultimatum, talking to his family, and more. Yes, I have tired. My family (God bless them) has tired on my behalf.

    Mind you that after each one of these approaches, he says “okay I’ll help. I’ll go to the doctor appointment with you, to find out the baby’s sex. I’ll put the crib together.” Then the actions are different. He’s said one thing, and then does another.

    Should I have chosen a different father? Yes. But let me put to you this way, the FOB is only 1 of 2 people that I’ve slept with in my entire life. I’m not a person to go with any Joe Schmuck that comes along. But that’s why this is an “oops” accident. That’s why this is out of wedlock.

    Despite everything it’s a happy accident for me.

    --still confused, but gaining clarity and strength :confused:


    You're certain clear headed and clear eyed about the situation - and yes, this is a happy accident. Maybe he's got to work his way through this - ? I don't know. Maybe he's just conflicted - oh, look, now I'm defending him!
  • Jan 20, 2008, 11:04 AM
    v_e
    Well, thanks everyone for the supportive ear. Thanks for the advice.

    I know that we are getting off the subject of law... I'm sorry.

    I know that in this forum, you can't understand why I've been with this guy for so long. It's impossible for me to explain it. I have trouble explaining it to myself, especially now. I hope that he is in denial and will eventually come around, if not for me, then for the baby. But, I can't understand why it's taking so long. I can't understand why his parents are continually defending him that he can't help. His hands are not tied behind his back. He's not stupid, but he IS acting that way.

    Does he think that because I'm a strong person, who... yeah-up makes more money than him... that he is not needed? I can't understand it. I didn't make the baby by myself. It's not like I'm a millionaire. It's not like I even make six figures. Why does he think that his role stops now? Why does he think that his role won't start again until after the baby born, if at all? I've read What to Expect When You're Expecting and other books, I can't find anything about a dad having this kind of difficulty. I've asked him to be involved in naming the baby, total cost to him $0 - Zero Dollars. I've asked him to be the labor partner. Again total cost to him $0 - Zero Dollars. Time involved, 3 nights 6 to 9 pm, over the course of 3 weeks. From my other posts, you can see that I've asked for him to be involved financially. He isn't. Most books recommend that the mother involves the father as much as possible by asking the father to do small things. I have.

    Yet, none of that matters. He isn't involved. He doesn't even call me anymore. In all this time, he hasn't once asked how the baby is doing. I have always offered that information, because he's ready to hang up the phone and isn't going to ask.

    I know he wants space, so I haven't called him in nearly 4 weeks. The last time I spoke to him was on Christmas Day.

    After I went to the doctor at the 22 week mark, I showed him the ultrasound pictures. Yeah it's a boy! Yeah everything looks good so far! That's a real concern for me, because I do have medical history and am now high risk. I have invited him to visit any of the doctor appointments. I have one every week because I visiting both the OB-GYNE and the high risk OB Fetal Specialist. Sometimes I have two appointments in a single week. His response was staring off into space and changing the subject to something unimportant.

    I'm trying to be as unemotional and reasonable as humanly possible. Do I sound like a crazy obsessed person?

    Yet, this is really, really, really and truly bothering me.
  • Jan 20, 2008, 11:12 AM
    s_cianci
    Quote:

    I know that we are getting off the subject of law... I'm sorry.
    Yep - family law is a very emotional field. Most people who are directly involved with family law matters base their arguments on emotions and not on facts of law. Must be very frustrating for people who work in the field.
  • Jan 20, 2008, 11:24 AM
    George_1950
    You could watch a movie together, "Knocked Up"; have you seen it?

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 07:05 PM.