Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Family Law (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=120)
-   -   Child support confusion! (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=279815)

  • Nov 11, 2008, 04:33 PM
    rhiannahunt
    Child support confusion!
    So I am getting married to a wonderful man. He has a child with another woman. We both of course love this child and see him. We don't have anything in court about paying child support. We are planning on doing so very soon. I do not work because I stay at home with our 14 month old little girl. So he makes the income. Roughly he makes maybe 3000.00 a month. Does anyone know how much I'm looking to be paying for child support? Does the courts take it into consideration that she is remarried? Do they take it in consideration that we have a child also to take care of? :confused:
  • Nov 11, 2008, 05:54 PM
    cdad

    Since he isn't paying child support at this time and if he is held liable for arrears then they could take up to 65% of his gross. He needs to take care of this right away.
    He should have been paying all along. And you might be getting a look into your future.
  • Nov 11, 2008, 05:57 PM
    rhiannahunt
    Ok he has check stubs for paying her monthly. Its just not court ordered.?
  • Nov 11, 2008, 06:11 PM
    cdad
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    Ok he has check stubs for paying her monthly. Its just not court ordered. ??

    Who set this amount for support ? Was the amount set as a agreement between them or is this money he gave her he figured he could afford. Also how old is the child ?
  • Nov 11, 2008, 06:18 PM
    Fr_Chuck

    How did they get a divorce, and set up child custody with no child support order?

    So my guess 400 a month or so at least.

    No he beig married has no bearing
  • Nov 11, 2008, 06:23 PM
    rhiannahunt

    Well they never got married. And she was the one who set the amount.
  • Nov 11, 2008, 06:24 PM
    rhiannahunt
    And he's 4
  • Nov 11, 2008, 10:52 PM
    cadillac59

    You asked a lot of questions all in one, and they are good questions.

    Every state has a child support guideline- not the same guideline but a guideline that is used throughout that particular state (i.e. a uniform guideline) -and the reason for this is that the feds mandated that all states adopt a guideline of some sort quite a few years ago (early 90's I believe as a part of welfare reform). Some states (like Nevada) have a bone-headed guideline that is a simple percentage of a low-time parent's income and nothing more. Others use a percentage plus additional factors. California's guideline is the most sophisticated of them all and we have to use a computer program to calculate support. Our guideline takes just about everything into account: the gross incomes of both parents, tax filing status, the timeshare percentage, other tax issues and on and on.

    You asked: Does the courts take it into consideration that she is remarried? Do they take it in consideration that we have a child also to take care of?

    Yes to all of these. If the child's mom is remarried and files a joint return with her husband her tax liability for one-half of her husband's income is taken into account (if the new husband earns more than she does this will INCREASE the support she gets from the child's father; if he earns significantly less than she does it will decrease her support). The baby you have together can qualify your to-be-husband for a hardship deduction which will reduce his support liability. But this is California law. Check with a local family law attorney if you are not in California to see if this is true in your jurisdiction.
  • Nov 12, 2008, 03:01 PM
    rhiannahunt
    Ok So he makes the same amount that my fiancé does. And she currently is not working. But is very capable of working. We moved to a different state, and we visit him about every three months. She wants to do a parenting plan. We agree and we are paying to get it filed. But right now she is telling us he can't see us here until he's seven. To me it doesn't make sense to do the parenting plan if she is not going to let us see him until he's seven. I thought we should just go to the court and get this child support handled. Its 250.00 dollars to file the parenting plan.

    And about 3 months ago a incident happened involving the son being abused by her husband. We took him to a hospital and they ruled it abuse. My husband doesn't think he has as much rights as her. We want custody. It is still under investigation with CPS and they aren't helping us at all. All the husband got was parenting classes.
  • Nov 12, 2008, 05:59 PM
    cadillac59
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    Ok So he makes the same amount that my fiance does. And she currently is not working. But is very capable of working. We moved to a different state, and we visit him about every three months. She wants to do a parenting plan. We agree and we are paying to get it filed. But right now she is telling us he can't see us here until hes seven. To me it doesnt make sense to do the parenting plan if she is not going to let us see him til hes seven. I thought we should just go to the court and get this child support handled. Its 250.00 dollars to file the parenting plan.

    And about 3 months ago a incident happened involving the son being abused by her husband. We took him to a hospital and they ruled it abuse. My husband doesnt think he has as much rights as her. We want custody. It is still under investigation with CPS and they aren't helping us at all. All the husband got was parenting classes.

    I get the impression that the child is not in California because of your use of the term "parenting plan" (sounds like Washington state terminology to me), an expression that we rarely see anyone use here (I frankly prefer the term to our fairly out-dated "custody/visitation" terminology).

    First, I cannot see any advantage to going to court to get a child support order. Check your local child support guideline, see what support would be, and then just pay it without an order. In California, there is no such thing as retroactive child support extending back before the date a case is filed in which child support is an issue so check to see if this is the rule in your jurisdiction as well (for example, if a child is 17 when a parent first files a case asking for child support and you appear in court 1 month after the case is filed, you only get 1 month's back child support, NOT 17 years of support, which is what many people believe for some odd reason- this is true even if the support obligor paid nothing for 17 years).

    Second, if the dad is being denied access to the child, he needs to file a motion for custody/visitation and see what happens in court. If the child was abused 3 months ago I would think the dad should have custody awarded to him and the mom supervised visitation until the details of the abuse are sorted out in court.
  • Nov 12, 2008, 07:04 PM
    rhiannahunt

    From what I know. The step father already went to court. The judge only gave him parenting classes and probation. We have the pictures of the abuse. The nose got almost broken, and handprints everywhere on his body. Bruises. Before the court hearing the step father had a no contact order with the son, but CPS found they went behind the order and was in contact. Nothing was done about that either. So basically we should get a lawyer? We are scared he will get hurt again.

    She, the mother is also saying we owe her back child support. She dropped the child support, basically because we had ben 50 percent of the time and saved her 500.00 a month of daycare.?

    Ps. You have answered so many of my questions! Thank you!!
  • Nov 12, 2008, 07:50 PM
    cadillac59

    This child needs to be out of that home he is in and with his father immediately. I'd file an emergency (ex parte) order seeking custody with no visitation to mom. And I'd get it too. If it were a client of mine I'd recommend doing it tomorrow, not waiting even one day. Attach copies of any documents you have to your motion but don't delay.

    I'd ignore the support request. Like I said, in California there's no support owed before any date a case is filed in which support is an issue.
  • Nov 12, 2008, 10:38 PM
    rhiannahunt

    When you say attach any documents. Does that mean pictures and all? And another question we want a lawyer and do we have to get a lawyer that lives where she lives, or can we get one down here?
  • Nov 12, 2008, 11:59 PM
    cadillac59

    You should offer documents to the court that show the child has been abused. That could include photos, yes.

    I'd hire a lawyer in the county in which you plan on filing the case which is probably where the child lives. I assume you live in the same state, correct?
  • Nov 13, 2008, 10:10 AM
    rhiannahunt
    No he lives in Washington and we live in Nevada. Thank you so much for your help
  • Nov 13, 2008, 10:27 AM
    cadillac59

    Has the child lived in WA the last six months? If so, you probably need to file in WA. If the child and the mom moved to WA from NV within the last 6 months and NV had been the child'a home state before that (I can explain what "home state" means if relevant) then you can file in NV.
  • Nov 13, 2008, 11:28 AM
    rhiannahunt

    Okay. Well yes he has always lived there in Washington. Do you know if lawyers take payments? We just got settled and have a good job. We don't have a big sum of money to do this. Do they take credit cards? Im so sorry I am asking you so many questions!
  • Nov 13, 2008, 11:49 AM
    rhiannahunt

    Also My fiance's mother wants to know if she can do anything about this. She has all the paper work. She also writes all the times that the mother drops him off. So my question is... Is there anything a grandmother can do?
  • Nov 13, 2008, 12:33 PM
    cadillac59
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    okay. Well yes he has always lived there in washington. Do you know if lawyers take payments? We just got settled and have a good job. We dont have a big sum of money to do this. Do they take credit cards? Im so sorry i am asking you so many questions!

    Washington has exclusive child custody jurisdiction so you have to file there. Do lawyers take payments? Some of them do. It's simply a matter between would-be client and attorney. And all of them I know of gladly take credit cards.

    I'm an attorney in California and a Certified Family Law Specialist (incidentally, I am also licensed to practice in Washington state but I don't maintain an office there nor do have any cases in Washington so you need to ask local counsel about their procedure, local rules and so on).

    Based upon what you've said I think you have a very good chance of obtaining custody of this child (I've seen people lose custody of their kids to a co-parent on weaker facts than yours).
  • Nov 13, 2008, 12:38 PM
    rhiannahunt

    Wow. Thank you so very much. I Learned so much. I feel so much better now. So should we get the child support handled first or just start fighting for custody!
  • Nov 13, 2008, 12:56 PM
    cadillac59
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    Also My fiance's mother wants to know if she can do anything about this. She has all the paper work. She also writes all the times that the mother drops him off. So my question is...Is there anything a grandmother can do?

    The only thing that comes to mind would be the possibility of a guardianship if you and your fiancé were unable or unwilling to have custody; but a guardianship requires a hightened showing of need and urgency. Most commentators/family law experts will tell you that if you are a non-parent and the child does not live in your household a guardianship will probably fail. To get one you have to show that it would be detrimental to the child's welfare to remain in the custody of the parent and that a guardianship is essential to serve the child's best interests, and I believe you have to show this by clear and convincing evidence (the next higher standard of proof beyond mere preponderance of evidence). This is a heavy burden. So, unless you have facts justifying CPS intervention and removal, a guardianship will probably fail. And if you have those compelling facts, then it's usually easier just to let CPS do its thing and ask for temporary placement of the child with the person seeking the guardianship. Now if the child has resided with a non-parent for a substantial period the rule is relaxed considerably and there is a presumption in the law that a guardianship should be granted (our oddly-written statute says that in cases of a "de-facto" parent, i.e. one with whom the child has resided for a substantial period and has assumed the day-to-day parenting role for the child, it is rebuttably presumed that changing custody to a parent would be detrimental to the child and that remaining with the de facto parent is necessary to serve the child's best interest--but, this presumption is rebuttable by preponderance of the evidence.. see how fun some of this family law stuff can be ! :)
  • Nov 13, 2008, 01:02 PM
    rhiannahunt

    Loads of fun! :) My fiancés mother writes everything down. Dates that the child has bruises, dates that the mother "forgot" to pick him up. She writes everything down that he says bad about his mother and step father. We have all the check stubs for sending her money ( replacing child support, when it wasn't in place) We had her sign a paper saying she was not asking for child support for some of the months because my mother in law always had the child. We have things that she has posted on her myspace saying she isn't happy with her husband and he controls her, to things like she thinks she is a bad mom. Can we use all of this?
  • Nov 13, 2008, 01:02 PM
    cadillac59
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    Wow. Thank you so very much. I Learned so much. I feel so much better now. So should we get the child support handled first or just start fighting for custody!?

    I would seek custody and at the same time ask the mom pay child support and attorney fees. You probably won't get a cs order or attorneys fee order ex parte (i.e. on shortened or no notice) but you could get the custody change ex parte. Once you get custody ex parte (or even if you don't) the case will be set for a follow-up hearing down the line and you can review the case then and ask for support.
  • Nov 13, 2008, 01:08 PM
    rhiannahunt

    Loads of fun! My fiancés mother writes everything down. Dates that the child has bruises, dates that the mother "forgot" to pick him up. She writes everything down that he says bad about his mother and step father. We have all the check stubs for sending her money ( replacing child support, when it wasn't in place) We had her sign a paper saying she was not asking for child support for some of the months because my mother in law always had the child. We have things that she has posted on her myspace saying she isn't happy with her husband and he controls her, to things like she thinks she is a bad mom. Can we use all of this?
  • Nov 13, 2008, 01:21 PM
    cadillac59
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    Loads of fun! My fiances mother writes everything down. Dates that the child has bruises, dates that the mother "forgot" to pick him up. She writes everything down that he says bad about his mother and step father. We have all the check stubs for sending her money ( replacing child support, when it wasnt in place) We had her sign a paper saying she was not asking for child support for some of the months because my mother in law always had the child. We have things that she has posted on her myspace saying she isn't happy with her husband and he controls her, to things like she thinks she is a bad mom. Can we use all of this?

    I think you can use this stuff. You have to keep the rules of evidence in mind but if the mom has made admissions that she's got parenting problems you can use that against her. Sure. The judge will decide what weight to give it.

    Mediation is mandatory in disputed child custody matters so much of these details come up in mediation and the mediator makes a recommendation to the judge of what to do (in most CA counties--a little different in a few others). You don't have mediation in true ex parte requests (the request for emergency orders-- we ought to re-name them "emergency requests" or something like that because everyone in our courthouse uses the ex parte calendar for silly non-emergency matters and the judges get mad and throw them out all the time --I've seen stuff on the ex parte calendar like someone asking to modify a visitation schedule because Sally wants to go to her friend's birthday party this weekend and it's dad's time and he has other plans!. that sort of junk).
  • Nov 13, 2008, 01:49 PM
    rhiannahunt

    What are the rules of evidence again? Can we use things like : April 21st. I watched sally (mom) pinch Luke (son) because he was crying and did not want to go home.? Then we took pictures the next day and there were bruises.
  • Nov 13, 2008, 02:02 PM
    cadillac59
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    What are the rules of evidence again? Can we use things like : April 21st. I watched sally (mom) pinch Luke (son) because he was crying and did not want to go home. ??? Then we took pictures the next day and there were bruises.

    Well, the rules of evidence are in this great big book you buy in law school and spend a year studying, or at least a semester anyway. And yeah, there's a bunch to know. But, many judges sort of give you a break on it in some family law cases (because there are no juries and things can be a little less formal). But keep in mind you can't use hearsay at a trial (we use some things at short-cause law and motion hearings that you couldn't use at trial, like written declarations because the local rules allow it).. Pictures are always okay if you authenticate them (who took them, when, where , under what circumstances). Forget about letters, and most written materials, even police reports are inadmissible hearsay (you have to call the police officer who wrote the report). Again, you have to check local rules. The easiest thing to keep in mind is to use live witnesses and have them relate what they saw, heard, that sort of thing.
  • Nov 13, 2008, 02:36 PM
    rhiannahunt

    OK. SO when the abuse happened the only people that were there was the father, our son and the step father bio son. They boys are the same age. Now the mother was apparently at the park with friends. Down the street. She got a call saying that she needed to come home right away and hung up. She got there and the paramedics and police were there. The police would not allow the mother to see or talk to the step father. The child had been bleeding from his nose, couldn't get the bleeding to stop for awhile. Then the mother took the soon to my mother in law. Where they called us, and we went to see the boy right away. We took pictures. And the child said that he was punched, then pushed. We took him to the hospital, and the nurse told us to take all his cloths off so we can see if there were any other marks. There were. There was a handprint on his bottom, and prints around his neck and back. We took pictures, and even the mother said, she ignored signs like her husband treating her son a lot different then his. Like disciplining worse and more often. CPS got involved. Made a no contact order, and caught them not following it. By the time his court hearing, the CPS Investigator guy didn't even go to the hearing and let the court know that they have been breaking it.

    Then we had a conference with CPS and family. But we were on the phone. And they gave the mother 20 hours of free daycare. And my mother in law offered to watch him over the weekends. Ok so you are probably wondering why they gave her this because she is not even working. Well she is pregnant. So that day she asked the fathers mother to watch her son because she was arguing with the step father, so of course she agreed. The mother left the son there over night so she can calm her husband down. The next day she came to pick her son up, and was acting very weird and a argument occurred with the fathers mother and her. Make a long story short. She took the son away and would not let the gma see him. Wouldn't let any side of our family see him for 2 months.

    About 2 weeks after this incident th court just gave him parenting classes and probation. Because of this the step father can't even see his bio son now. The mother of that son, says that they neglect him.

    About 3 weeks ago from today, I tried talking to the mother of the abused child and got her to let her son see my fiancés side of the family. So all is OK there. Then we went to visit about 2 weeks ago and she wouldn't even let us have the child over night, because she is scared we will kidnap him!

    When her son was around 2 in a half years old. She dropped him off with "of course" my mother in law to stay the night. Because she had to go to a different city to meet some guy she met on the internet.

    Now she has been emailing me because we "owe" her back child support. The only court papers we had for child support lasted 3 months and SHE is the one who ended that.

    Long story I know! But you are GREAT :)
  • Nov 14, 2008, 09:16 AM
    Sabbylynn

    I would be contacting the courts and a lawyer... for four kids I get 298 ( was 589) in child support in the state of Kansas.. I would also push four full cust of his son.. with the Abuse going on I would recommend it
  • Nov 15, 2008, 02:41 PM
    cadillac59

    That's quite a story and I feel sorry for this poor kid. You really have to intervene and not let this situation get any further out of control than it already is. That step-father should never have any contact with this child again (he has no parental rights anyway so why in the world is he even in the picture! ). The boy needs to be with his father (your fiancee) with the mom having supervised visitation at a licensed visitation facility. There should also be a no contact order with the step-dad. If she disagrees then custody still should temporarily switch to dad, supervised visitation to mom, and a full blown custody evaluation ordered to figure what is going on.

    Gosh, I wish you the best with this but this is unfortunately a not-too-uncommon case in family law. Messy.
  • Nov 15, 2008, 07:20 PM
    rhiannahunt
    My Fiancé is going back up there in a month. So should he just get a lawyer, when he's there, or go to the courts and get paper work? This will most likely be my last question! :)
  • Nov 15, 2008, 07:37 PM
    cadillac59
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    My Fiance is going back up there in a month. So should he just get a lawyer, when hes there, or go to the courts and get paper work? This will most likely be my last question! :)

    I think he should find a lawyer first. Try to find one that only does family law, if possible. Avoid the ones who have a combination of things they do. If your lawyer's practice is limited to family law he will most likely like what he does and be good at it (we tend to be good at things we enjoy).

    All the best.:)
  • Nov 16, 2008, 11:07 AM
    rhiannahunt
    Thank you very much. My fiancé wants to pay her money still, just so we all get along. Should we still do that?
  • Nov 16, 2008, 11:31 AM
    cadillac59

    I don't think there's anything wrong with that. Everyone has a legal duty to support his kids whether there's a support order in effect or not.
  • Nov 16, 2008, 11:40 AM
    rhiannahunt
    Ok thank you. So when he sees his lawyer does he tell him that he wants to do the emergency exparte. And I know it may take awhile to get this going, but with the "emergency" do they take that in consideration?
  • Nov 16, 2008, 11:40 AM
    rhiannahunt

    Can you refer me to someone in Washington?
  • Nov 16, 2008, 11:41 AM
    rhiannahunt
    Around the vancouver area?
  • Nov 16, 2008, 12:07 PM
    cadillac59

    I don't think they allow that on this board (maybe in a private message). There is someone who is in Vancouver, WA who is pretty well-known and well-respected but I won't say who it is unless the board's moderators say it's OK.
  • Nov 16, 2008, 03:54 PM
    JudyKayTee
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rhiannahunt View Post
    around the vancouver area?



    Can't do it publicly or privately - check with your local Bar and see who is on their recommended list.

    (Attorneys advertise on these boards and it would be unfair to refer to someone who does not.)
  • Nov 21, 2008, 04:19 PM
    rhiannahunt
    Trying to get custody of child because of ABUSE
    OK. SO when the abuse happened the only people that were there was the father, our son and the step father bio son. They boys are the same age. Now the mother was apparently at the park with friends. Down the street. She got a call saying that she needed to come home right away and hung up. She got there and the paramedics and police were there. The police would not allow the mother to see or talk to the step father. The child had been bleeding from his nose, couldn't get the bleeding to stop for awhile. Then the mother took the soon to my mother in law. Where they called us, and we went to see the boy right away. We took pictures. And the child said that he was punched, then pushed. We took him to the hospital, and the nurse told us to take all his cloths off so we can see if there were any other marks. There were. There was a handprint on his bottom, and prints around his neck and back. We took pictures, and even the mother said, she ignored signs like her husband treating her son a lot different then his. Like disciplining worse and more often. CPS got involved. Made a no contact order, and caught them not following it. By the time his court hearing, the CPS Investigator guy didn't even go to the hearing and let the court know that they have been breaking it.

    Then we had a conference with CPS and family. But we were on the phone. And they gave the mother 20 hours of free daycare. And my mother in law offered to watch him over the weekends. Ok so you are probably wondering why they gave her this because she is not even working. Well she is pregnant. So that day she asked the fathers mother to watch her son because she was arguing with the step father, so of course she agreed. The mother left the son there over night so she can calm her husband down. The next day she came to pick her son up, and was acting very weird and a argument occurred with the fathers mother and her. Make a long story short. She took the son away and would not let the gma see him. Wouldn't let any side of our family see him for 2 months.

    About 2 weeks after this incident th court just gave him parenting classes and probation. Because of this the step father can't even see his bio son now. The mother of that son, says that they neglect him.

    About 3 weeks ago from today, I tried talking to the mother of the abused child and got her to let her son see my fiancés side of the family. So all is OK there. Then we went to visit about 2 weeks ago and she wouldn't even let us have the child over night, because she is scared we will kidnap him!

    When her son was around 2 in a half years old. She dropped him off with "of course" my mother in law to stay the night. Because she had to go to a different city to meet some guy she met on the internet.

    Now she has been emailing me because we "owe" her back child support. The only court papers we had for child support lasted 3 months and SHE is the one who ended that.

    About a week ago I found out that I can get the paperwork started at the court facilitator office. I went online and looked at all of the packets. I have no idea which one to use. These are the ones that popped up-

    # Dissolution (Divorce)
    # Paternity (Support and/or Custody-Parenting Plan when parents are not married)
    # Modification of Child Support and/or Custody-Parenting Plan
    # Contempt
    # Step-Parent Adoption
    # Non Parental/Third Party Custody
    # Relocation

    They were never married, and she lives in Washington and we live in Nevada.

    Can someone help me! We don't have the money right now to hire a attorney, but we WANT to get the paperwork going. And when we sit down and do this at the court, what paper work must we have. I know we need the proof of the abuse, but is there anything else?

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 11:08 PM.