Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Dogs (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=417)
-   -   Ban of pit bull dogs (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=20091)

  • Mar 9, 2006, 06:15 PM
    labman
    Now we are bashing Poodles. I won't deny there are a bunch of poor ones out there. The breed may never recover from its over popularity in the 50's. Too many substandard dogs were bed. The Poodle actually was bred as a retriever originally. Poodle comes from the same root word as puddle. The good ones are highly prized as service dogs because they lack the dander that causes most of the dog allergies. I have done a blindfold walk with a Poodle as my guide. Here is a picture from from one of the training meetings for those raising puppies for dog guides.

    http://www.photolocker.net/images/La...idepuppies.jpg

    Here are a couple of web sites on Poodles I share. http://www.jagerslatijn.nl/jagerslatijn/poodle.htm
    http://www.vipoodle.org/

    I will warn you I haven't verified the reliability of those sites. They could be as big load of garbage as many dog care websites. I have never seen a pick up with a gun rack and a Poodle in the back.
  • Mar 9, 2006, 07:03 PM
    Melinda
    Labman, are you FOR bans? I'm am so against it, as my bank account will show you, there is no "pure bred" pit bull, pit bulls are actually crosses, they have men here in Cornwall, with no association with animals except to pick up strays, deciding whether a dog is a pit bull or not. Figure that one out, I couldn't pick a pit bull out of a batch of dogs... I have joined owners in Ottawa for sit ins, roughly 100 pit bull owners and dogs showed up, no fights what so ever, pits, stafforshires and mixes ARE dog aggressive, yes, it's a known fact, but socialize!! Have them fixed, pits are the most loyal , bum wagging dogs... IF in the right hands... same with shepherds, rotti's, any large breed... write to your govt, speak out for the dogs... for canadians.. fight bill 132 please... MY ontario includes pit bulls... does your state?
  • Mar 9, 2006, 07:05 PM
    Melinda
    I'm not bashing poodles... I'm bashing owners... irresponsible owners and just pointing out how any dog can be dangerous... poms also, chi's... anybreed... a lab in the wrong hands... I've had a rotti/lab/dane... so gentle... my daycare loved her... now I have a lab/shepherd 10 months old... gentle as a lamb with them... she was taught to be...
  • Mar 31, 2006, 03:25 PM
    turbodigger
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by NeedKarma
    Maybe it has something to do with the fact that we rarely, if ever, hear about crazed poodles or labs tearing a child apart.

    Poodle and lab aren't the only other type of dogs, maybe you picked those because you know that most other types of dogs do attak. The other day I was attacked by a jack russel terrier. 2 holes in my hand and ripped my finger nail off. So I guess we should kill all of them too. Oh and my brother was bitten by a german shepard when he was younger, they also should be killed. Come on now, the ones that are scared of pitbulls are only scared because of the news. German shepards attack just as much. Why do you think they are used as police dogs, so they have dogs that attack people. Hmmmmm intersting
  • Apr 1, 2006, 10:19 AM
    fredg
    HI, Turbo,
    Dogs have behavioral instincts and many are leaders of their packs. As you said in your post, I agree with it.
    Dogs are not the problem; the problem is owners who do not know how to train their dogs, are not aware there really is a problem, and do not even know enough to ask "why".
    I have seen little Chihuahuas go after anything much bigger than they are, and they think they are "King Kong"... don't know their own size. One of them can eat up a human baby before anyone knows what has happened; inflicting many skin tears and bites.
    It all comes back to the owner.
    As you said, it doesn't really matter about the dog breed. What does matter is the owner.
    I do think that German Shepards are used as Police dogs because of their size, and they also have a high intelligence. As I understand it, Poodles are the highest on the dog intelligence ladder.
    So, maybe Police Poodles??
  • Apr 1, 2006, 01:18 PM
    Melinda
    Exactly what I was trying to say, it's not the breed, it's the owners.
  • Apr 1, 2006, 01:19 PM
    Melinda
    Lilfrye *L* I accept being the new best friend *L*
  • Apr 2, 2006, 07:08 AM
    fredg
    Hi, Melinda,
    I agree that it's the owners, too.
    Sometimes, I have a hard time typing what I want to say.
    It's like can't walk and chew gum at the same time!
  • Apr 3, 2006, 04:19 AM
    Melinda
    I know how it is Fredg, if the govt would spend their money, not on bills and bans, but on wiping out byb's, and puppy mills, we'd solve half the problem, it's law to have your dog licenced, it should be law to have your dog spayed/neutured unless you show proof of being a registered kennel, ALL dogs should have to go to at least one session of puppy school. *gets off my soap box and tucks it away till next time*
  • Apr 8, 2006, 01:09 PM
    jennapbt
    You know what saddens me is that almost everyone has to put in their 2 cents on a subject even though they know absolutely nothing about that particular subject. Granted there are a few that actually OWN pit bulls and know what they are talking about. When a "pit bull" attacks it goes to the media because they figure that's what the community wants to hear. What most people don't know is that there have been MANY cases where it was said to be a "pit bull" but was really actually a totally different breed. There are also breeds out there that are very similar to pit bulls looks that people misidentify them as that breed. The "pit bull" gene is the most dominant gene therefore if a dog was only 10% "pit bull" it would look very similar to one. There are cases of other attacks by numerous breeds that arnt heard of that do occur. There was a story I remember of a pomeranian killing a baby. I agree with the fact that there are bad owners that eventually contribute to sad stories of dog attacks but it's DOG attacks not only pit bulls. I know of people that wanted to make their "pit bull" mean and vicious just because it's a pit bull, he would beat it and do all kinds of other cruel things but all in all the dog just didn't have a mean streak in him. I personally agree that if a "pit bull" shows any kind of human aggression they should get some pink juice. Pit bulls were in fact created for being game dogs to help farmers and butchers catch unruly bulls and other large farm animals. The one thing they weren't bred for was human aggression any pit bull that showed human aggression was, plainly put, shot to be killed. The behavior was learned not bred. I own and breed pit bulls and any type of aggression be it human or dog I do not tolerate. Now me feeding my dogs vitamins and a healthy food and caring about the bloodline and weights of my dog does not IN ANY WAY mean that I care about fighting my dogs. I care for my dogs like they are family, I care about their nutrition to live healthy lives, I care about their body weight to live healthy, I breed to better the breed, I care about bloodlines because I have show dogs. Everyone that meets my dogs always LOVES them, just for the fact that they are very sweet well mannered dogs. People have the right to hate something like the "pit bull" and I understand that and accept that fact that they are ignorant, I accept it when I have this breed of dog. I just hope that one day the pit bull will go back to what it was; the American Icon. After all of this abuse it deserves it, just to see that there are so many loving pit bulls that have been through hell and back and still find it in their heart to love no matter what. What about the rotties, shephards, dobies that were all the "bad dog" which are now seen as loyal protectors? Did you stop to think about WHY the police force uses the G Shephard? All in all this wonderful breed doesn't deserve to take the fall on human ignorance.
    I credit the people that are loyal to the breed because we see eye to eye on how wonderful these dogs are.
    I'll leave it on a good note, enjoy the "vicious pit bull" pictures!

    Mortal enemies... or close allies?
    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...tingcloser.jpg
    Who considers kisses as viciousness?
    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...oches09-05.jpg
    Why do people hate us, this child loves me.
    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...e/P1010118.jpg
    Even after the frustrations of carrying pups for 63 weeks she considers this one a pup also
    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...floyonjill.jpg
    How could you hate this?
    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...e/P4080030.jpg
    Nothing but love!http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...e/P1010069.jpg
  • Apr 8, 2006, 01:40 PM
    Melinda
    No one is arguing with you jenna, you've just more or less said what all of us are saying right along...
  • Apr 8, 2006, 01:43 PM
    orange
    Agreed. I think most of the people in this thread are against the pit bull ban, or ban of any breed of dog for that matter. I know I am.
  • Apr 8, 2006, 01:51 PM
    kriskstar
    I like the comment I read earlier about how if a human commits a crime, it's the fault of society, the fault of government, or it's always someone else's fault other than the person's, when the reality is that the person is worthless. And if I was to say oh, that's just a worthless black man that did the crime, I would have all these orginizations down my throat saying how I can't put the deeds of a few bad apples on a group of people. Yet when a dog did something bad, its never the result of how they were raised or the environment they are in, no it's because these dogs are evil, villanous masterminds who want to do nothing but harm. (sarcasm alert!) and of course every dog with the title of Pit Bull is bad. It's funny, we are the "advanced" species yet we need excuses for our wrong doing. But when it comes to animals, they just do what they do. Spare the pups, euthanize humans!

    8==8 A bone for the pups.
    -----------------------------------------------------------
    My Pit Bull is always there to lend a hand :-)
    http://www.pictub.com/users/2006/01/...s/im000521.jpg
  • Apr 8, 2006, 02:03 PM
    jennapbt
    I know I wasn't out to argue, I was just stating the facts. I'm glad it still stirs up a commotion about the ban. I give credit to all pit bull owners. :)
  • Apr 8, 2006, 03:23 PM
    Melinda
    I only give credit to any dedicated owner of any breed of dog that raises them right...
  • Apr 8, 2006, 05:00 PM
    jennapbt
    Lol of course, one upper, but since this is a pit bull thread, and I love pit bulls I thought I would give credit where credit is due. I love animals so of course I'm not going to be like oh you beat your poodle that's all right just don't beat your pit bull. :p
  • Apr 8, 2006, 07:39 PM
    Melinda
    *L* I like you jenn, you know how to give and take, I'm not an owner of a staffordshire or pitty, but I'm still fighting the ban, many of my friends own the bredd, in fact, my dogs trainer has three mixes that were deemed "unmanagable" and she adopted them, up until the ban, they were companion dogs and visted the seniors homes and schools in our area... the seniors were so upset when they could no longer be brought to the home.
  • Apr 8, 2006, 08:15 PM
    pwillett06
    I love pitbulls. I use to own one. I would own one again. Here is a story of an irresponsible owner. My fiancée and his four year old son were playing in the yard the other day when they heard a blood curdling scream coming from right in front of them. My fiancée saw two small children running towards a parked car with a pitbull following close behind. The children jumped into the car and the pitbull tried to claw itself into the vehicle. The police came and the pitbull went after them and was tasered to the ground. We were all very lucky that this ended this way. For me, all I could think was "thank god he didn't see my four year old son". This was a well cared for pitbull who escaped from his home when he saw the children pass by. He was raised to fight and kill. A pitbull is not born a killer, it is raised and trained to kill. Irresponsible owners are killing a beautiful breed of dog who are just as loyal and loving as any other breed when raised right. You can breed it out of them just as easy as you bred them into it. Dog temperament is unstable with any breed. Ask the woman who had a face transplant after her labrodor bit it off. Don't blame the breed, blame the breeder.
  • Apr 14, 2007, 09:54 PM
    brazygirl08
    Real quick. This is not in response to you... but everyone!
    I work at a Doggie Daycare/Boarding facility. I would like everyone to know that LABS are considered one of the most aggressive breeds! I have been bitten by a little Caring Terrier and a Lab and almost bit by many other labs. NEVER has a Rottie, Pit or Doberman tried to hurt me. They need to bring down the people that fight the dogs and punish them... not the poor animals! We have 6 pits and NEVER have had any problems. They are loyal, smart and great listeners... one of the smartest breeds I have ever owned! Own one before you dog them... One more thing... A LAB OR A GOLDEN RETRIEVER even a SMALL dog could be trained to KILL!!
  • Apr 15, 2007, 07:36 AM
    froggy7
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Melinda
    In 2003, 13 years after the ban on 'pit bulls' was implemented, Winnipeg reported 166 dog bites caused by the following dog breeds:

    Shepherd cross (38), Terrier cross (11), Rottweiler (11), Lab cross (10), German Shepherd (8), Husky cross (7), Border Collie cross (7), Bearded Collie cross (6), Rottweiler cross (5), Chow cross (5), Lab (5), Great Dane cross (3), Golden Retriever (3), Dalmation (3), Poodle cross (2), Golden Retriever cross (2), Cocker Spaniel cross (2), Boxer cross (2), Australian Shepherd cross (2), Terrier (2), Pomeranian (2), Chow Chow (2), Boxer (2), Border Collie (2), Samoyed cross (1), Mastiff cross (1), Heeler cross (1), Great Pyrennes cross (1), Doberman cross (1), Dachshund cross (1), Dalmation cross (1), Corgi cross (1), Akita cross (1), Springer Spaniel (1), Siberian Husky (1), Shih Tzu (1), 'Pit bull' type (1), Miniature Schnauzer (1), Irish Setter (1), Great Dane (1), Doberman Pinscher (1), Dachshund (1), Cocker Spaniel (1), Bull Mastiff (1), Brittany Spaniel (1), Bloodhound (1), Bichon Frise (1), Akita (1).

    Just a general comment on statistics like these. While they are helpful, they can be misleading, because you don't know the denominator data. 38 shepherd cross bites may seem like a lot, but is that 1% of the shepherd cross population or 50%? 2 poodle bites may seem low, but if they are the only two in Wiinipeg, that would be 100% of the poodle population. So keep that in mind when you see these sorts of things.
  • Apr 25, 2007, 03:20 AM
    sfwwfc
    It angers me to be reading the replies to this question. Ive signed up just to set those of you that seem uneducated or miss-educated on the path of pitbull enlightenment! Fr_Chuck.. what where the circumstances of your attack? Was the dog secured before it attacked you? Did the dog attack you or was there something about your behavior that triggered a predatory instinct? (tripped on the sidewalk, made eye contact with it, or run from it?) Is it possible that another breed would have bitten you in a similar circumstance? Sorry to burst your bubble, needkarma, but there are hundreds of accounts of children being attacked by other breeds. The most likely dog to bite is a Lab however you will never see that on the news. Sorry folks but Lab attacks just are not as sensational! In addition, Pits are not a "hunting" breed they are a "fighting" breed. My father has breed and continues to breed hunting animals. Bird dogs to be specific. Pits share very little with these breeds I grew up raising. Three years ago I met my first pit. She was a badly treated and under fed fighting dog. By fighting dog I mean her owner bet money on her KILLING other dogs. She is EXTREMELY aggressive! One night she appeared in my yard. Having a great base of knowledge about dogs I was confident approaching her and offering her the rest of my lunch. Thus beginning the best friendship Ive ever had! I adopted her and after this my first pitbull I will own no other breed. Extremely smart, fiercely loyal, and more protective than a pet lion. A lap dog never unwilling to show affection. Why would anyone own any other breed? I know if anyone where to approach my children in my yard she would be there. Better than a firearm for home defense that my daughter can find. While I know I can't bring her around other animals because of her past I would sooner trust my graceful pittbull playing with my toddler than a clumsy Lab unaware of his own strength! Educate yourself! Introduce yourself to the next bully breed you meet! Talk to a few owners! Breeds don't kill people breeders do!
  • Apr 29, 2007, 05:00 PM
    sadzgt
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by lilfyre
    [F]
    This whole thing just saddens my heart that a breed of dog will be eventually be destroyed because of bad people.


    [F]
    Why can we not just ban bad people?


    It is not the breed of dog it is the owners that need to screened. I remember through the course of my life time when German Shepards were the breed to beware of followed by Dobermans and Rottes now it is Pit Bulls. It is not the breed but the reason for, treatment of and type of owners that chose the breed. I have friends and relatives that have each one of these breeds in their family and they are all wonderful dogs. The key is that the dogs are part of their family. My son and his wife have three children ages 9,5,2 and Scooby Doo happens to be a pitbull. My neighbors have a German Shepard wolf mix,the dog is a love. Could they be dangerous? While I was sitting in our family car at age 8 our family dog a St. Bernard attacked me for no apparent reason, some say it was a drop in the barometric pressure, others says he thought I might hurt my little brother who was crying because the dog was licking his face I will never know. I do know that all dogs no matter the breed have the potenial to be dangerous.
  • May 12, 2007, 10:38 AM
    Binky2619
    I think it is absolutely STUPID, ( the ban ). I have a 6 week old pit bull pup named Romeo, and he has the most gentle nature. I know he is still young and has to grow into his personality, but you can just tell he is a lover. I have 3 other dogs and he follows everything they do. Teach them right, give them love, and they will be the most beautiful, loving family member you could ever imagine. My sister has a white, deaf pit bull named Zuece, and he is a 130pd BABY. He follows you around and gives you kisses, and wants to be a lap dog. He is also very good with her other two dogs. So please stop all the non sense, stop believing what you hear, forget the hype... If people would give them the chance and love them how they need to be loved, you would Stop hearind all the crap you hear today. SINCERELY A PIT BULL PET OWNER!!
  • Jul 13, 2007, 02:34 PM
    cartwright
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by nymphetamine
    ----------------- Bulletin Message -----------------


    "Rep. Wesselhoft said the proposed bill will also include provisions designed to bring about an eventual ban of pit bull dogs in the state.
    The grandfather clause contained in the bill would allow for the continuing existence of pit bulls currently in Oklahoma. However, pit bull owners would have to have the dogs spayed or neutered, and the animals would need regular rabies shots.
    In addition, a pit bull owner would have to be age 21 or older and would be required to have a $100,000 liability insurance policy on every pit bull.
    Also, each pit bull would have to be tattooed or otherwise marked when it is registered with the state. Owners would not be able to sell or transfer the dogs to other individuals in Oklahoma, excluding family members. And a person living in Oklahoma will not be able to bring in a new pit bull from out of state.
    After those pit bulls that are allowed to remain in Oklahoma under the grandfather clause of the proposed bill die of old age, Wesselhoft said there should be very few pit bulls remaining in the state, if any."

    I thank that is stupid to pick on one breed of dog .we have more parents killing there kids. Then pitbulls killing humans. People want to many rules for one breed of dog . I have a pit and if it was not for her I could have been hurt worse than I was .a boxer attacked me she was able to stop him. But you would not see anyone gripping about boxers.
  • Jul 30, 2007, 06:52 PM
    HorseLover
    Well I guess for someone who does animal rescue this is a hard question for me to face but I would like to make a attempt at it and throw some of my own views out there.I am sure this will cause some kind of stir from a few people and frankly I don't care it's my opinion and I have the right to express it... So here it goes... I have worked with many pit bulls and other aggressive dogs, which many we were able to rehabilitate(we used Dog whisperer methods,THEY WORK! ) and for those dogs they now have healthy happy homes. But let me include the types of dogs that were aggressive so maybe people will see that it is not just pit bulls and that any dog can be aggressive, it's not the breed of the dog it's the raising of the dog! As for the list cocker spaniels(these being one of the most we have seen), chows, labs, huskies,mixed breeds, pit bulls(in 15 years of animal rescue I have only seen about 2 dozen of these and all but 3 were able to be retrained),dachshunds, chihuahuas(please excuse the spelling), yorkie,mastiff,german shepard,boxer,cairns terrier, jack russel and a few others. You must realize that there are several good pit bulls out there just as there are several of all breeds out there.
    Do I think pit bulls should be banned? Hell NO! Banning our choice of animal to have is just like saying it is OK to say who can have children and who can not. Better yet it would be the same as saying people of different races and / or backgrounds can not love one another, so please take a moment and think about it, since when does (what is supposed to be a free world) allow the government tell us what we can and can not own in our own home? Does that seem like we are free with rights? It seems to me when we start allowing the government to decide for us we are nothing more the walking robots doing their every little bidding. I don't know about anyone else but I refuse to live like that, letting someone else rule my rights for me. Who are we to say to anyone else that they can't own what they choose to ? I do believe owners should be held liable for their dogs but how can we hold a dog liable for doing what he was taught to do be his human leader? It's unfair to the dog, we are responsible for the children we bring into this world why not be held responsible for the animals we choose to keep?? This is has become a war of who is stronger in politics and if we continue to let them decide for us there will come a day that your cute little dachshund or your fuzzy siamese cat will no longer be allowed either. I promise you that if we continue to sit down and keep quiet instead of raising our voices and standing up to these political bullies then we will one day be without rights. It is up to everyone of us to make a stand-UNITED WE STAND, Separate WE FALL!
    I have said my peace but if you have anything to add then please free as it is your god given right to do so!! ;)
  • Aug 10, 2007, 11:25 AM
    bfinstad
    I think this whole thing has gotten out of control. We need more responsible people out there breeding pitbulls to stop selling them to just anyone and stop breeding for the money! I own a pitbull that is wonderful and I would love to continue his bloodline. There is no way I would sell a puppy to just anyone. There are too many people out there trying to fight them. We need more responsible people calling in on dog fights, we need more animal cops (they are wonderful, but we need more) and regular cops. This issue is just as important if not more important than the drug issue. We have people out there traing and inbreeding dogs so that they are bigger and more aggressive than ever, and are killing people. This is a huge issue and people like michael vick need to be put away for a long long time for doing these things. If anyone told me I had to turn him in or do all that bull they're saying you have to do,I would honostly move out of this country. The government doesn't seem to know how to get things under control anymore and its starting to really make me sick!
  • Aug 14, 2007, 02:37 PM
    momofpitbulls
    At one time I was also scared to death of a pit bull (cause of what I had heard) really any dog cause I was bit by a dog as a young child & not a pit bull. Did not want one. Would not go into a yard that had one. After some one gave me one as a puppy and I trained it, loved it, it listens to me, well both (now I have 2 which the female Angel just had 8 puppies) do actually. Their good around my nieces and nephews, but don't let some hurt the kids cause they will take up for them.
    I do realize they can become mean, it's in their jean, but I also believe it's the way you treat them to. I'm also very careful with my dogs. If it seams their having a bad day, as we all can you know, I just don't let the kids around them.
    Just my opinion!!
    http://img.auctiva.com/imgdata/0/3/2...64042611_o.jpg
  • Aug 14, 2007, 02:43 PM
    momofpitbulls
    I also forgot to mention that I don't breed mine to make money, so far most of this litter of going to family or if I have any left and do decide to sell one I will be very careful who my puppy is going to. If I don't know you, then you DO NOT get my puppy. This was Angels first litter & our family has been deciding if we would like for her to have another one or not. Because we are scared of the fact someone may end of with one of the puppies and fight it. My heart would just break. I don't believe it that at all.
  • Aug 14, 2007, 03:46 PM
    bfinstad
    Congratulations Momofpitbulls!! Im so happy to hear that there are responsible pitbull owners out there! I love to hear about things like this and how you won't just gve your pups to anyone! By the way... hey are beautiful puppies!!
  • Oct 24, 2007, 02:14 PM
    Gmoney2007
    OK this is just dumb why hate the animal just because the person that owns it is a total idiot! I have 4 pitbulls for myself and the have never bitten anyone they never attack kids or none of that! So how can you say lets ban the dog all together this is ridiculous
  • Oct 27, 2007, 06:41 AM
    MOWERMAN2468
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by nymphetamine
    I agree that people should take responsibility for their animals however this affects the ones who never caused any harm also. Thats just like someone coming up to me and saying " off to the electric chair miss. we have too many brunettes burning down houses." Why should everyone else have to suffer? If people would learn not to train these dogs to be mean then it wouldnt be that way.

    Got cut off somehow with rating. This breed is ferousious to begin with. It is just good at hiding it and giving people a false sense of security around them, then it will, I said WILL turn on someone and could even cause death.
  • Oct 27, 2007, 06:51 AM
    MOWERMAN2468
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Nez
    Agree with Need.A pit bull is bred to hunt.Why own a dangerus animal.Just stick to faithful fido.

    So what cartwright is saying is that a gentle, loving pitbull (DEFINETLY NOT MY OPION), that is bred to work with a 2,000 pound bull, is so gentle, and loving? I think it would take a ferousious animal to try and attack a bull that outweighs it by about 1940 pounds. What do you think? Makes sense don't it.
  • Oct 27, 2007, 07:11 AM
    MOWERMAN2468
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by orange
    Apparently, the man who owned the dogs was a next door neighbor, and one of the dogs was pulling a sleigh with the little girl in it (who was 2, I just found out!). The sleigh went by the attacking dog and that's when he bit her in face. She was in the backyard with all 5 dogs, and I assume not much supervision! The other dogs were put down because their shots weren't up to date, and there was a question of rabies. The dog that did attack her was kept alive for rabies testing. When the testing was over and came back negative, the dog was put down too.

    I think it was awfully stupid on the part of the owner and the parents of the little girl, allowing such a little child in the backyard with 5 big dogs!! Like what were they thinking?? :confused:



    Yes exactly! We have a yellow lab, and we didn't have to get the special licensing for him. However if we mistreated him or let the child we're expecting kick or tease him or be mean, etc, he might attack too. Of course we'd never do that, and I strongly believe in supervision for little kids with dogs, for both the dogs and the child's protection. My dog is also in obedience classes. I don't think any breed should automatically be labled "dangerous".

    Why is it you people think that when an innocent child is attacked by an aggressive breed of dog that you think they were not attended by an adult? So silly, I was attacked, and was in a salvage yard garage with the owner, my grandfather, and my dad there, all walking in a single file through the shop and I was attacked for no reason. Get real people and just admit these dogs are dangerous.

    Also, just this week a young two year old girl was attacked by a pit bull when she went up to pet the dog. She had petted the dog many times before at her uncle's home. With no bad results. But this time she had to go to the hospital and almost had to have reconstructive surgery to her face. She to was not unattended, her father and uncle were there with her. The dog had never showed any aggression before to her. Guess what she too will grow up and be for any and all bans of this breed.
  • Oct 27, 2007, 07:12 AM
    MOWERMAN2468
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by bizygurl
    Your right Orange, that was really stupid on the parents fault for not keeping an eye on the little girl, and she was 2? Anytime you have a young child with bigger dogs especially more than one dog you need to keep an eye out beecause you don;t know what can happen. Being a mother this would have been just common sense since it would be dealing with dogs that were'nt mine.

    There was another situation like this that happened here a few weeks ago. The dog didn't attack the child but it was an accident and this is just to prove the point why children need to be supervised with big dogs.

    a little girl had been playing with her aunts dog in the backyard of her aunts house, I think the girl was four. She had been wearing a scarf, what happened was the dog had been playing with her and grabbed the end of the scarf and dragged her aroung the yard. She wasn't able to get the scarf off while this was happening and the dog ended up choking her to death. I beleive this dog was a German shepard.
    But because no one was keeping an eye on the little girl this unfortunate accident happened.

    Why defend the dogs here? Were you there? Do you know the child was unattended? Come on now, if you have a child that is injured by a dog, would you still be defending the dog? Probably not.
  • Oct 27, 2007, 07:20 AM
    MOWERMAN2468
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by NeedKarma
    Funny though, you rarely hear of psycho poodles ripping an infant to shreds.

    Hmmm, you say rarely? I don't recall ever hearing that a poodle ripped an infant to shreds. I have seen one lick an infant in the face though.
  • Oct 27, 2007, 07:32 AM
    froggy7
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by MOWERMAN2468
    so what cartwright is saying is that a gentle, loving pitbull (DEFINETLY NOT MY OPION), that is bred to work with a 2,000 pound bull, is so gentle, and loving? i think it would take a ferousious animal to try and attack a bull that outweighs it by about 1940 pounds. what do you think? makes sense don't it.

    So you are also in favor of banning bulldogs and bull terriers? After all, the "bull" in dog breed names comes from them being used with cattle, and in bull and bear baiting. So they have just as much of a propensity for being violent dogs, don't they?
  • Oct 27, 2007, 07:33 AM
    MOWERMAN2468
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by sfwwfc
    It angers me to be reading the replies to this question. Ive signed up just to set those of you that seem uneducated or miss-educated on the path of pitbull enlightenment!! Fr_Chuck.. what where the circumstances of your attack? Was the dog secured before it attacked you? Did the dog attack you or was there something about your behavior that triggered a predatory instinct? (tripped on the sidewalk, made eye contact with it, or run from it?) Is it possible that another breed would have bitten you in a similar circumstance? Sorry to burst your bubble, needkarma, but there are hundreds of accounts of children being attacked by other breeds. The most likely dog to bite is a Lab however you will never see that on the news. Sorry folks but Lab attacks just are not as sensational! In addition, Pits are not a "hunting" breed they are a "fighting" breed. My father has breed and continues to breed hunting animals. Bird dogs to be specific. Pits share very little with these breeds I grew up raising. Three years ago I met my first pit. She was a badly treated and under fed fighting dog. By fighting dog I mean her owner bet money on her KILLING other dogs. She is EXTREMELY aggressive! One night she appeared in my yard. Having a great base of knowledge about dogs i was confident approaching her and offering her the rest of my lunch. Thus beginning the best friendship Ive ever had! I adopted her and after this my first pitbull i will own no other breed. Extremely smart, fiercely loyal, and more protective than a pet lion. A lap dog never unwilling to show affection. Why would anyone own any other breed?! I know if anyone where to approach my children in my yard she would be there. Better than a firearm for home defense that my daughter can find. While i know i can't bring her around other animals because of her past I would sooner trust my graceful pittbull playing with my toddler than a clumsy Lab unaware of his own strength!! Educate yourself!! Introduce yourself to the next bully breed you meet! Talk to a few owners! Breeds dont kill people breeders do!

    Typical pit bull owner, thinking it was Fr_Chuck's actions causing the attack.
  • Oct 27, 2007, 07:37 AM
    froggy7
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by MOWERMAN2468
    hmmm, you say rarely? i don't recall ever hearing that a poodle ripped an infant to shreds. i have seen one lick an infant in the face though.

    Poodle attack brings lawsuit - Pittsburgh Tribune-Review

    And keep in mind that "everyone knows" that the dogs that attack are "pit bulls", so a lot of mixed breed dogs that attack someone automatically get labeled as "pit bulls". If it's a lab/sheperd mix and attacks someone, it's a "pit bull". If it's a lab/pit mix and it attacks, it's always described as a "pit bull" or a "pit mix", almost never as a "lab mix".
  • Oct 27, 2007, 07:37 AM
    MOWERMAN2468
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by momofpitbulls
    At one time I was also scared to death of a pit bull (cause of what I had heard) really any dog cause I was bit by a dog as a young child & not a pit bull. Did not want one. Would not go into a yard that had one. After some one gave me one as a puppy and I trained it, loved it, it listens to me, well both (now I have 2 which the female Angel just had 8 puppies) do actually. Their good around my nieces and nephews, but don't let some hurt the kids cause they will take up for them.
    I do realize they can become mean, it's in their jean, but I also believe it's the way you treat them to. I'm also very careful with my dogs. If it seams their having a bad day, as we all can you know, I just don't let the kids around them.
    Just my opinion!!!
    http://img.auctiva.com/imgdata/0/3/2...64042611_o.jpg

    WHY, would you own such a creature that when you think they are having a bad day you would not allow the children around them? When it happens to be too early one day for you to detect the pit is having a bad day, I hope the child(ren) is not injured too badly. Then they too will grow up to want this breed banned.
  • Oct 27, 2007, 11:08 AM
    labman
    I am afraid all of Mowerman's posts in this thread reflect the same ignorant stereotypes about dogs that we no longer accept with people. They certainly are at odds with the reality of all the sweet, loving Pit Bulls that live to old age and never cause a problem. I have yet to see one of his posts showing much knowledge of dogs.

    All breed specific legislation is a bad idea.

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:36 AM.