Originally Posted by
jlisenbe
This was the situation you presented. "Pretend you met me for the first time at the grocery store. We discovered, while standing in line at the deli, that we live on the same street and know some of the same people. You asked me if I attend any church. I vigorously shake my head "no" and say, "Yuk!" Walter, what would you say to me in response?"
Already, in your scenario, your rule has been broken. "You asked me if I attend any church." Certainly not an "I" statement and about as nosy as it gets, so you've already let the cat out of the bag. I wouldn't ask that to begin with, but that was your choice. If someone responded that firmly in the negative, I'd probably back up and say, "Sounds like you've had some negative church experiences." Bear in mind that in the deli line, you're not going to have all day long to psychoanalyze the person.