Your essay will be
Two pages or so:
What is love?
Love around the world in various cultures and at various times
One or so pages on each person in the story -- Mel, Terri, etc. and their ideas of what love is and relate them to the ideas people have held as per the previous section on cultures -- similarities? Differences?
Last page:
Summary -- Did Carver accomplish what he set out to do according to the story's title. If yes, how (summary of characters' ideas)? If not, why not?