[ChrisLW47130]

We are working with a local contractor who is going to be taking our existing bathroom down to the stud walls following water damage due to a ruptured pipe. We have a small, brick ranch with one bathroom. My wife and I are both 52 with back and knee issues and we are thinking of eliminating the bathtub in favor of a nicely tiled and appointed shower area with a bench seat and a 4" to 6" curb. I've heard varying opinions that having no tub will reduce the resale value of the house. We've lived here for 23 years and I don't foresee moving in the next 10 to 15 at least, so I figure we need to have the bathroom we want and have a shower/bathing area that is as easy as possible to get in and out of.

I would love to hear what other folks have to say on this matter. IS a bathtub a necessity in a single bathroom house or is it a matter or personal preference? Any opinions/answers would be appreciated. Thanks in advance for any and all advice!

[tickle]

I renovated my small one bathroom bungalow and had the tub taken out because it took up too much room. I don't have back problems and I do enjoy that shower all glass enclosure with a lot more room in the bathroom.

[talaniman]

I wouldn't worry about the resale value since you are not planning to move and a bathroom custom made for you may make you stay forever.

DO IT, and enjoy YOUR house!!

[joypulv]

It does seem to be standard real estate knowledge that a tub is a must, I would guess because without one, you eliminate people with small children (and people who really do like to soak in tubs).
I agree that it is nice to do what makes you happy.
And there is so much demand these days for more than one bathroom, I'm not sure that it matters. My house was originally a typical 1970 ranch with one bathroom, and someone built a big addition in 1986. Buyers of your house someday can put on an addition, like the ridiculous bloated 'master suite.'
Or maybe by then the public will have gone back to small is good, cheaper, and energy saving.
So I too say: put in your shower.
I don't care for tiled curbs. They are too wide, tall and squared. Too easy to stub a toe and tiles often crack if you buy a glass door that is attached to the curb in any spot, and the floating ones are very expensive. I prefer premolded bases with a tiny lip.

[hkstroud]

Never though about it but I doubt that there is any code requiring a tub. A toilet is probably required.

I took a lots of baths in a little round tub in front of the fireplace when I was a kid, after my sisters. Haven't taken more that half a dozen as an an adult and they were in the first couple years after I was married.

Ask you wife and do it your way (your wife's way). She over rides any code.

Besides, what's any bureaucrat going to do. Take away your birthday, kick you out of your home, take you to jail. Bet they don't have tubs in jail?

[talaniman]

I have been drooling over these babies for a few years now

American Standard Gelcoat Standard Series 48 in. x 28 in. Walk-In Whirlpool Tub with Quick Drain in White-2848.104.WLW - The Home Depot

[ma0641]

Take a look at homes in adult neighborhoods. Very few have tubs. We have a shower and a tub. Might use the tub 2X per year. A tub is not required under any code I know of unless local.

[ChrisLW47130]

Wow! Thanks to every one of you who has chimed in on this. I'm glad to hear there are other folks out there who are abandoning the bathtub. I used to take long baths many years ago (and, if I had the $$$ and the space, would love to have a jetted bathtub), but haven't actually soaked in a tub in probably ten or more years. joypulv, your comment about people with small children is the argument I hear the most about why we should keep a tub. My wife and I have no kids and, being in our fifties, don't foresee any in our future, so that argument is largely moot to us. We would much rather have a nice, fully-tiled shower enclosure with the wall jets, etc. to enjoy.

hk, you're definitely right when it comes to who trumps who in the world of building codes. Heck, I have decisions overturned on a daily basis by my other half! LOL!

talaniman, we actually looked at the tubs of the type you posted and the contractor we're working with said he has put a few in, but he hears back from people a couple of years later who want to get rid of them because of leakage issues and, apparently, even though they have rapid pump draining systems, the tend to leave the users pretty chilly while waiting to get out (unless you have your heat cranked pretty high, I could easily see that happening).

So I believe we are going to kiss our tub goodbye and go with what will make us happy and also what will make it easier to get in/out of the shower.

[talaniman]

LOL, peruse these then and show your wife...

Luxury Showers Home Design Ideas, Pictures, Remodel and Decor.

I know, expensive but whats wrong with dreaming BIG!!!

[joypulv]

I mentioned small kids ONLY in the context of resale.
There's plenty to be said for doing what makes you happy.
I think in my case, being almost 70, that I factor resale in a bit more each year.
Even in your 50s, you have no idea what the future holds re your health and mobility and ability to even keep your home.
There's no formula. You talk about it and decide and hope it works out.

[tickle]

LOL, peruse these then and show your wife...

Luxury Showers Home Design Ideas, Pictures, Remodel and Decor.

I know, expensive but whats wrong with dreaming BIG!!!

The master bath beauty, the second from end, is what I chose to replace my bathtub. It is big enough for a teak stool to sit on inside the enclosure, in case you want to just relax under the hot water for a bit.

I mentioned small kids ONLY in the context of resale.
There's plenty to be said for doing what makes you happy.
I think in my case, being almost 70, that I factor resale in a bit more each year.
Even in your 50s, you have no idea what the future holds re your health and mobility and ability to even keep your home.
There's no formula. You talk about it and decide and hope it works out.

If people with children are looking for a house, they will not choose one with no bathtub anyway, so a mute point. I am 73, Joy, and have already factored in my new bathroom for resale purposes, and it comes out on top.

[ChrisLW47130]

I renovated my small one bathroom bungalow and had the tub taken out because it took up too much room. I don't have back problems and I do enjoy that shower all glass enclosure with a lot more room in the bathroom.

I'm glad to hear that we aren't the only ones who are willing to abandon a bathtub. Our bathroom is very small (I believe no larger than 25 square feet) and I feel like if I get rid of the tub and put in a glass enclosed shower, it will open the room up a bit more. Thanks for chiming in!

[tickle]

I'm glad to hear that we aren't the only ones who are willing to abandon a bathtub. Our bathroom is very small (I believe no larger than 25 square feet) and I feel like if I get rid of the tub and put in a glass enclosed shower, it will open the room up a bit more. Thanks for chiming in!

I always said you couldn't swing a cat in my bathroom before it was renovated. The tub was half the bathroom ! A good contractor made it all happen by designing and measuring everything I wanted to happen. If you are doing this yourself, maybe you should use a CAD programme to make sure you make use of all available space.

[joypulv]

'If people with children are looking for a house, they will not choose one with no bathtub anyway, so a mute point.'

That's the POINT if you want to sell your house!! This is now the third time!!

Mute = silent. Moot = no point arguing

[smoothy]

Worrying about what remodeling will add to the value of the house is really only important if you will sell soon after the work is done. 10 - 15 years down the road, its not going to look fresh anyway.

Anything that far out you do for yourself now, who knows what will be important 10 or 15 years from now... tastes change all the time, trends are exactly that... something else starts becoming more or less popular. That far out... you need a really good crystal ball.

Once upon a time Jacuzzi's were all the rage, right now they are an albatross because of how much water and time you need to fill them up... in 15 years maybe tubs will be a relic, maybe they will make a comeback... who knows. Spend you money on what you will get to enjoy the next ten years or so.

[tickle]

'If people with children are looking for a house, they will not choose one with no bathtub anyway, so a mute point.'

That's the POINT if you want to sell your house!! This is now the third time!!

Mute = silent. Moot = no point arguing

OK so I get it the third time for WHAT :