Originally Posted by
aaj2008
by scolding i didnt mean beating the hell out of your dog..i meant negative reinforcement...sorry for my poor selection choice of words that everyone on this site seems to nit pick at
What do you mean by negative reinforcement?
Dogs don't learn by being yelled at or hit etc. Dogs sense attitude, need positive reinforcement to learn what is expected of them.
Most people think that rubbing a dogs nose in his urine or poo is the way to go, after all that's what people did a long time ago, and it worked. Yes, it does work, by instilling fear in your dog. A fearful dog is not a good companion.
Think about it. We are all born as infants. As infants we cannot use the bathroom, we need diapers until we're old enough to walk, and feel when we have to go to the potty. Now, how do most parents toilet train their kids? Do the take off the dirty diaper, rub the babies nose in it, yell and hope that it will learn? I'm sure that technique would work, but does that mean it's okay? Of course not. When potty training a child we use positive reinforcement, repitition, praise, and patience. It's the same with dogs.
A dog does not know that it's bad to go in the house, it needs to be taught to go outside. Sometimes it can take a few days, other times it can take weeks, even months. It depends on the dog and the owner.
Negative reinforcement is the easy way out, and you're not training your dog when you do it, you're only making your dog afraid to do what comes naturally. Most times these are the dogs that later on will start to pee and poo in the house, even if they've been trained for years. Why? Because they never learned proper behaviour.
That's not nit picking, that's disagreeing.