Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
    garule's Avatar
    garule Posts: 2, Reputation: 1
    New Member

    May 3, 2012, 04:58 AM
    The Ex Dilemma?
    I'm a 29 year old woman sharing a house with my friend (a girl my age); half a year ago my boyfriend moved in with us. We get along great and all is fine.

    This girl and I have been friends since we were 17; we have a very tight knit group of friends, which involves the two of us and three guys. We've all been friends since I was 17. We don't get to see each other very often, some of us live far away, etc etc, but we do try to get back together whenever we happen to be in our hometown. My boyfriend doesn't know them because I now live far away.

    One of these friends came to visit in the fall last year, and it was nice catching up and getting to spend time with him. My boyfriend did meet him and quite liked him.

    Now the other two guys want to come visit. The problem is, I used to date one of them when I was 17-21. We remained good friends and we both enjoy the company of our friends.

    But my boyfriend doesn't like the idea. He doesn't want my ex in our house. I think my ex is more of a friend than an ex (it's been YEARS!) - plus, he's also my roommate's friend. I'm conflicted. I really want them to come visit. They're great guys and my boyfriend can't possibly have anything personal against him. I see it as once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for all of us to get together - my roommate will be moving out soon, plus it's really complicated for the other two to get organized - one lives out of the country, etc etc, and for once they got their act together and decided to come for a visit..

    On one hand, I want my boyfriend to be happy, but on the other hand, I'm afraid to let him control my friendships, my visits, etc. I want to be able to see my friends. He's the guy I'd like to spend my life with, but I don't want to doom myself to a life with no friends. I don't want to blow it, but I do want him to understand. As I said, I live far from my friends and I would really enjoy their company from time to time.

    Am I being reasonable at all? I know I probably shouldn't invite the two friends in order to keep peace but it makes me miserable.
    talaniman's Avatar
    talaniman Posts: 54,288, Reputation: 10853

    May 3, 2012, 08:14 AM
    Makes you miserable if they don't come, makes him miserable if they do come. A challenge but not a dilemma, because you will talk and work out something that works for you both, like a dinner, instead of an extended visit, or sleep over/stay with. Maybe two dinners. ALL of you, including your boyfriend.

    Propose this compromise, and stress the need for him to be a total part of it.

    Much Luck!
    mmresd's Avatar
    mmresd Posts: 2,002, Reputation: 553
    Ultra Member

    May 3, 2012, 11:37 AM
    While your ex is in town, only see him when your boyfriend is around, explain to him how your feelings are gone romantically and that there is only a friendship left. If he is unable to understand your point of view because of his personal insecurities, that is something that he has to deal with, not you.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions


Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.

Check out some similar questions!

Serious Dilemma. [ 1 Answers ]

I have been on and off with my boyfriend for 6 years and been together from a very young age.there has been cheating on both parts, and he says he canít trust me. However I still to this day canít trust him 100%, the amount of lies etc he has told me before. I left him and met another man about a...

Dilemma [ 94 Answers ]

Entire story merged I just found out my girlfriend of 3 years has been cheating on me. She basically blames the fact that she had to ask me for affection as the root cause for her seeking comfort elsewhere. She says she carried me and that she was sick of it. I really miss her. I have had...

Dilemma [ 28 Answers ]

Hi. I need some advice and would like to get some perspective to help me make a decision here. I've been a relationship for 5 years now. Things have been good between us, and I truly love my girlfriend. We've talked about marriage and I'm ready to propose to her. My problem is that about 6...

Another dilemma [ 4 Answers ]

So... this is kind of an extension of my last post "So Confused..." I went on a student trip for the past 10 days, and I went with a very close friend that is a girl (that happens to be a friend of the girl from my last post). On day 2 we ended up hooking up when we were semi-drunk, but it was in...

A dilemma [ 11 Answers ]

So me and my ex were going out for 5 months, after about 3 months she stopped talking to me about how she felt, which this being my first relationship I didn't pressure her into talking to me. Fast forward to about a month ago when she broke up with me telling me it wasn't working for her any more,...

View more questions Search