Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    makdan's Avatar
    makdan Posts: 46, Reputation: 3
    Junior Member
     
    #1

    Jun 24, 2007, 04:43 AM
    different size down payments-splitting house sale proceeds -- VA
    My (former) girlfriend and I are joint owners of a house in VA. I made a much larger down payment, but the title/deed does not specify unequal ownership. The relationship is now so unpleasant that I want to sell it, probably at a loss. How will the (losing) sale proceeds be split between us, assuming the following hypothetical amounts?

    Purchase price: $500,000
    Her total payments: $50,000, unspecified as to closing vs. down payment
    My total payments: $150,000 down payment, $10,000 closing costs at purchase
    Improvements: Her=$30,000
    Other: I paid $4000 toward her half of the mortgage when she couldn't make the payments.

    Sale price: $410,000
    Mortgage balance: $290,000
    Sales commission: $20,000
    Net check to us: $100,000

    If, after paying off the mortgage and the sales commission, we receive a check for $100,000, how will it be split?

    The best case answer might be a formula for distributing the proceeds, or a link or reference to a formula. Second best would be a general discussion that mentions how each of the variables specified above is typically handled. I need to know

    1. whether we take equal losses, or losses proportional to our expenditures
    2. If losses are proportional, does the timing of our payments matter, i.e. are payments converted to present value?
    3. how to handle her $50,000 payment: does it = $5000 for her half of the purchasing closing costs, with the rest applied to a down payment?
    4. whether her improvements, about half for new windows/doors, and half for new appliances, "count" like a down payment does
    5. whether she will have to pay me back for the $4000 mortgage payments I made for her
    excon's Avatar
    excon Posts: 21,482, Reputation: 2992
    Uber Member
     
    #2

    Jun 24, 2007, 05:08 AM
    Hello mak:

    Out of the sale price, everybody gets back what they put in, and the rest is split equally.

    excon
    Fr_Chuck's Avatar
    Fr_Chuck Posts: 81,303, Reputation: 7692
    Expert
     
    #3

    Jun 24, 2007, 05:13 AM
    No, sorry unless you have a contract about splitting this, or unless you had the deed listed to show percents of ownership.

    At this point you both own equal shares of the home, and you will split the check evenly unless she agrees otherwise.

    Or what will happen is the check will have to be held in a escrow account while the two of you fight over it in civil court.

    But no you were not making "mortgage payments" for her, you were making your and her mortgage payments since you name is on the mortgage payment also, and it is not "her bill" and "your bill" unless you had a partnership contract drew up.
    It will basically be looked at as if you were married, and as your girlfirend, you shared bills and helped each other.

    So if you get a 100,000 dollar check, you get 50,000 and she gets 50,000 and you walk away with a good lesson learned about love and house buying. If she will agree to something else, great, but if not, you will have to fight it out in court. Normally there will be one check issued to both of you, If you fight over separate checks for closing, remember if you both don't agree, this is prolong the closing and can actually allow the deal to fall though,

    What is she wanting?
    excon's Avatar
    excon Posts: 21,482, Reputation: 2992
    Uber Member
     
    #4

    Jun 24, 2007, 05:33 AM
    Hello again, mak:

    My suggestion is how the proceeds SHOULD be split. The Padre is right about how the proceeds will probably BE split, if you can't agree.

    excon
    makdan's Avatar
    makdan Posts: 46, Reputation: 3
    Junior Member
     
    #5

    Jun 24, 2007, 05:59 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by Fr_Chuck
    No, sorry unless you have a contract about splitting this, or unless you had the deed listed to show percents of ownership.

    At this point you both own equal shares of the home, and you will split the check evenly unless she agrees otherwise.

    What is she wanting ??
    We haven't specifically discussed selling the house or division of proceeds recently. It was my (verbal) understanding going into the deal that our investments would be equalized after she sold her other house, by her paying for improvements to the house (appliances, new windows and doors, new roof, landscaping) and cash to me. She made the first 2 improvements and paid me some cash, but I still have about twice as much invested as she does. When I have complained, she has repeatedly stated that when we sell the house, a judge would hear the case and give us shares proportional to our respective investments. More recently she has given a smirky smile and sort of whispered that "I own half the house," which causes me concern that she might want a full half.

    My question today is a follow-up to my question yesterday about "removing her son when joint owner objects", which you answered.

    She has tried to essentially blackmail me into paying for roof and landscaping, rather than her paying-as she originally promised, by saying that I will lose more than she does (because I have proportionally more invested) if we sell at a loss without improving those items. She has also asked me a for $50k interest-free loan from me, and this after she netted about $230k after selling her house right after we bought one together.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Division of sale proceeds [ 4 Answers ]

I have an estate planning question. My aunt and mother are both listed on the deed for a single family house they inherited from their parents. Only the aunt lives in the residence, pays taxes and utilities, and maintains the property. When the property is sold, how should the proceeds be...

Landlord putting house up for sale before end of lease [ 8 Answers ]

I entered a 1-year lease on 3/1/2007. I was informed by a realtor on 6/4/07 that the house was going up for sale but not to worry, it might take months for it to sell... Can a landlord do this? Even if the house takes a year to sell, how about my right to enjoy a quiet environment (for sale...

No Lien, but can creditors come after house sale proceeds? [ 10 Answers ]

Hi- hope someone can help. Can't get a straight answer from my lawyer! My mother passed in 2004 with a large $20,000 hospital bill. They did drain their savings to pay about 25,000 of it! My dad had been making payments on the balance until he got sick. My dad died last March. He willed the...

Enrichment? House sale [ 1 Answers ]

My perents got a legal separation and so that my mother can live by herself she they are about to sell a 5 familly house in brooklyn. They bought this house about 10 years ago and for the past 7 we have owned it but have rented out the apartaments and have not lived in it ourselves. We own and have...


View more questions Search