Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    ramonborges's Avatar
    ramonborges Posts: 7, Reputation: 1
    New Member
    		  
    #1

    Jul 25, 2012, 08:49 AM
    Can I use a Lower Watts Element(3500w) instead of(4500w) on Water Heater?r
    Will the water heater work with this change of element wattage?This is for the upper element since the lower element is not working.

    Original requirements for this water heater:
    Upper element: 4500w, 240v
    Lower element: 3500w, 240v

    Thank you,
    RB
    speedball1's Avatar
    speedball1 Posts: 29,301, Reputation: 1939
    Eternal Plumber
    		  
    #2

    Jul 25, 2012, 09:29 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by ramonborges View Post
    Will the water heater work with this change of element wattage?This is for the upper element since the lower element is not working.

    Original requirements for this water heater:
    Upper element: 4500w, 240v
    Lower element: 3500w, 240v

    Thank you,
    RB
    Yes! You may lower the wattage. It just won't heat up as much as a 4500 watt element. Why would you wish to do this?
    BUT WAIT!
    You have a bigger problem, You said.
    This is for the upper element since the lower element is not working.
    This is the most impotent and hard working element in your heater. Without it you'll get very little hot water. My advice? Replace both elements with 4500 watt elements. Good luck, Tom
    ramonborges's Avatar
    ramonborges Posts: 7, Reputation: 1
    New Member
    		  
    #3

    Jul 25, 2012, 10:51 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by speedball1 View Post
    Yes! You may lower the wattage. It just won't heat up as much as a 4500 watt element. Why would you wish to do this?
    BUT WAIT!!
    You have a bigger problem, You said. This is the most impotent and hard working element in your heater. Without it you'll get very little hot water. My advice? Replace both elements with 4500 watt elements. Good luck, Tom
    ************************************************** ****************
    Thank you for your advice Tom..

    The other problem that I have is that I cannot remove the lower element ( too much rust, sediment.?. ) I tried to unscrew it with a 1.5" socket, a wrench, etc.. but to no avail...
    Thus, I was hoping to work the heater with just one top-element
    (will try with a 4500w instead of the 3500w-element that I have…)

    Hope for the best.. (ahh, those cold showers!! )

    RB
    speedball1's Avatar
    speedball1 Posts: 29,301, Reputation: 1939
    Eternal Plumber
    		  
    #4

    Jul 25, 2012, 04:39 PM
    Let me tell you what will happen. You step in the shower and turn on the hot water. As soon as you open the valve cold water enters the water heater where it's directed to the bottom via the dip tube. Now normally the bottom element would heat the cold water and it would raise to the top where the heat would be maintained by the upper element.
    But you don't have a bottom element so as you exhaust the small amount of hot water on top it will be replaced by cold water as you will be drawing it out faster then the top element can catch up.
    Unless you dig cold showers I strongly advise you to lube the threads with WD-40 and take a impact wrench and replace the element.
    Your only other option would be to replace the heater . Good luck, Tom
    Attached Images
     
Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions
 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Water Heater Element [ 1 Answers ]

Can I put a 4500 watt element and a 3500 watt element in a water heater. I have an energy smart Whirlpool 40 gal. with the circuit board on top. The reason I ask is the bottom 4500 watt element burned out and I had this 3500 watt element from a previous tank. So can I have a 4500 watt and a 3500...

Replacing element in water heater have to be the same watt element? [ 1 Answers ]

My water heater has 2- 4500 watt elements installed now. Went to find replacements. Could only find 3800 watt. The guy at home depot said it should not hurt just might not heat as fast. Is this correct or should I take these back?

Electric water heater element kw [ 3 Answers ]

Dear All Please guide me that the element in electric water heater (Kw) is equal to the electric power(Kw) used to heat water. Regards :confused:

Replace a water heater 120 element with a 220 element with proper wiring [ 4 Answers ]

Can I use a 220 heating element in a 110 water heater as long as the wiring is for 220. We had a 40 gal water heater 220 volts in a weekend cabin with one shower a complete over kill. Want to replace with a 20 gal 110 water heater but to take advantage of the 220 wiring can I just swap out the...

Can I use 3500 watt water heater elements to replace 3800 watts? [ 3 Answers ]

I haven't actually pulled the elements yet but the tag on the water heater shows elements rated at 3800 watts. The ones readily available at the local big box are even numbered, 3500, 4500,5500. Can I use the 3500 watt rated elements to replace elements in this water heater?

View more questions Search