Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    Rehmaan's Avatar
    Rehmaan Posts: 6, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Mar 15, 2013, 10:16 AM
    for purifying from sin what he did, is that not more sinful?
    0
    take my Salam. I have a question regarding pre-marriage affair issue. I have one muslim female friend who were is a relationship with a muslim guy. Both of them used to pray 5 times namaz, highly bemaintain halal & haram .Except their relationship, they don't do anything wrong. They also believe that this pre-marriage relation is not allowed as well as fair. That girl loves that boy & the main thing is she trusts him blindly. Though they are always afraid about this relationship issue and islamic rules which conflict on their mind. That girl prays to allah for pardon her for being in a affair and wants the blessing of allah so that she can marry that boy. That boy loves her from the very beginning. He promised her to be together forever. Even they kiss each other. But then they asked touba for that. After 6 moths relationship that boy went to abroad. Then he realized he had done great sin ny being in a pre-marriage affair. So for solving/ recovering that sin he left that girl. He breaks that love and relationship. That girl could not believe herself that he can leave her. She got trauma. Now she doesnot talk with anyone, even she doesnot get anything what's going around her.

    Now my question: is that right what that boy have done? For purifying from sin what he did, is that not more sinful?
    joypulv's Avatar
    joypulv Posts: 21,591, Reputation: 2941
    current pert
     
    #2

    Mar 15, 2013, 10:53 AM
    I am not a Muslim, but can't believe that any religion considers that this man becomes free from sin by abandoning the woman he supposedly loved and wanted to marry! His sin is that he lied.
    Do you know this man? Would you say that he really believes that what he did is correct, or he just looking for an easy way out, or he won't marry a woman who had an affair, even if that affair was with him? Shame on him.
    Rehmaan's Avatar
    Rehmaan Posts: 6, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #3

    Mar 15, 2013, 11:18 AM
    Yes, I know this guy personally. He is a proud muslim who believes that Allah is very merciful & he will forgive his followers for their bad deeds. So he makes touba in namaz. But he does not even try to know about the girl who was crying 24/7 & now she does not talk at all. Yes may be its an easy way out for him. But he puts all the blame on that girl.


    Quote Originally Posted by joypulv View Post
    I am not a Muslim, but can't believe that any religion considers that this man becomes free from sin by abandoning the woman he supposedly loved and wanted to marry! His sin is that he lied.
    Do you know this man? Would you say that he really believes that what he did is correct, or he just looking for an easy way out, or he won't marry a woman who had an affair, even if that affair was with him? Shame on him.
    joypulv's Avatar
    joypulv Posts: 21,591, Reputation: 2941
    current pert
     
    #4

    Mar 15, 2013, 11:32 AM
    He puts all the blame on her?? Double shame, triple shame!
    I hope you can talk her into being angry at him instead of crying. It takes time to get to that stage. He obviously thinks very highly of himself. Who would want someone like that?
    Does she have an imam (or do you) who might be understanding, and help her, or is this something a woman is afraid to ask for fear of being blamed by him too?
    Is there nothing in Islam that allows a family to sue the man for dishonoring a woman?
    Rehmaan's Avatar
    Rehmaan Posts: 6, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #5

    Mar 15, 2013, 11:46 AM
    Yes he blames on her that he is not happy to be in relationship considering religious facts. He tells her to be normal becoz even married couple get divorce. So its not a big deal to leave her after doing all those things. & that innocent girl still believes that he can't do this to her. She still trust him & trust the every words what he promised. She thinks that boy is now out of his own mind. He is not like that. He will be back.
    Actually I live in different country. I don't know family of that boy. & almost nobody knows about this relationship. & that girls doesnot tell to anybody because other may consider that boy as a bay guy what she doesnot want. From her point of view he is still a angel.
    I don't know if I should try to inform that boy's family or not?



    Quote Originally Posted by joypulv View Post
    He puts all the blame on her??? Double shame, triple shame!
    I hope you can talk her into being angry at him instead of crying. It takes time to get to that stage. He obviously thinks very highly of himself. Who would want someone like that?
    Does she have an imam (or do you) who might be understanding, and help her, or is this something a woman is afraid to ask for fear of being blamed by him too?
    Is there nothing in Islam that allows a family to sue the man for dishonoring a woman?
    joypulv's Avatar
    joypulv Posts: 21,591, Reputation: 2941
    current pert
     
    #6

    Mar 15, 2013, 12:08 PM
    'I don't know if I should try to inform that boy's family or not?'
    Not a good idea... families usually protect their own.
    I'm sorry you aren't there for her.
    Could she visit you?
    afaroo's Avatar
    afaroo Posts: 4,006, Reputation: 251
    Ultra Member
     
    #7

    Mar 15, 2013, 07:41 PM
    Hello Rahmaan,

    I would suggest to talk to the girl to forget about this boy he lied to her he used her and now who knows what is he doing to other girls this is just an excuse that he is good muslim and does not want this poor girl, he did bad things to her and Allah will funish him and will not forgive him, I am praying for her and hope she come out of this drama, Thank
    Rehmaan's Avatar
    Rehmaan Posts: 6, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #8

    Mar 15, 2013, 07:42 PM
    Yes that's another point that he is a very good boy who is praying 5 times prayer at mosque(from other's poin of view). So his family or others may not trust everything what he had done. And that girl is not in a such condition to go anywhere. I did call her thousand times to talk so she could be feel fresh. But she doesnot talk with anyone. Even her family don't know about all this things.



    Quote Originally Posted by joypulv View Post
    'I dont know if I should try to inform that boy's family or not?'
    Not a good idea... families usually protect their own.
    I'm sorry you aren't there for her.
    Could she visit you?
    Rehmaan's Avatar
    Rehmaan Posts: 6, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #9

    Mar 15, 2013, 07:47 PM
    That's what I am trying to tell her but she couldn't forget that for any single moment. & she thinks he will be change like before he was so good with her. She also consider that may be there is her fault in any way so that he is leaving her.


    Quote Originally Posted by afaroo View Post
    Hello Rahmaan,

    I would suggest to talk to the girl to forget about this boy he lied to her he used her and now who knows what is he doing to other girls this is just an excuse that he is good muslim and does not want this poor girl, he did bad things to her and Allah will funish him and will not forgive him, I hoping for the girl to come out of this drama, Thank
    smkanand's Avatar
    smkanand Posts: 602, Reputation: 56
    Senior Member
     
    #10

    Mar 27, 2013, 12:23 PM
    That is called zina in islam and solution will be that they should get married with each other.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Prove sin x-sin 7x / 2 sin^2 2x-1 = 2 sin 3x [ 0 Answers ]

I need to answer this

Is my wife's interest in art a sinful thing? [ 3 Answers ]

Asalam alikum sir, I wanted to ask you this question and more important solution for this as it is bringing very much fight between my wife and me,my wife is new muslim from 1 year and she is trying her best to practise islam and I will say she is very good following,as she pray 5 time...

Is it wrong/sinful/haram to fast on chandraat [ 2 Answers ]

Is it wrong/sinful/haram to fast on chandraat as I want to fast on chandraat because I don't want to miss the roza because sometimes people in india end up fasting for only 29 days because of misunderstandings relating to the moon.So I want to fast on chandraat can I or not?

Chemistry - isolating & purifying an inorganic and one organic compound [ 1 Answers ]

Explain the purposes of these stages in the isolation process: - the use of propane - using filter paper and funnel - re-crystallisation

When I am in church or holly places I have fear of having sinful thoughts. [ 11 Answers ]

IM A Christian,When I am in church or holly places I have fear of having sinful thoughts I am not in that situation when Im in my home or somewhere with my friends,walking.. this condition is getting worse when I am under some emotional pressures or I am tired ,I start to worry and try to control...


View more questions Search